Bharat Rakshak

With all due respect to Vivek. The last air-ware scenario is bit Toma Clancyish

Dear Vivek,

None would be happier if proved wrong . In the first scenario the MKIs are yet to be engaged with Chini SUs and in the second the Arjuns are waiting in Askai Chin. The comment was just my assesment not as a criticism.

^
He is never going to finish it. First time also he left halfway.

Vivek Welcome back. My two pice suggestion: If you want to publish the book on your own why dont you launch a advance pre booking after initial talks with the printer. This will help you on two counts i) give you a better estimate of the number of copies you target to print ii) help you with working...

Hope he completes one of his earlier scenarios instead of starting another new one. Eagerly waiting for the Arjuns to reach Ladakh

Somehow I have a feeling he wont continue with this scenario anymore. Isnt it logical if he is writing book not to tell the end of the story beforehand. I will be glad if I am wrong

Vivek Sir,

Last time also you left your scenario midway and vanished

Bala,

The (desi) Pinakas are already in action and making life hell for the Chinese.

Vivek Sir, There is a slight variation from what you posted for Day 5 earlier and what you are posting now.

What is the procedure if one wants to attend the Mumbai meet?

Please dont mark J&K as disputed. It means we agree to the Paki view point.

Vivek Saar,
Get well soon, we are starving

Yes and since this is our first nuclear sub I think DRDO, Navy and BARC would like to very sure about all systems before criticality is planned for. After low power criticality is achieved then slowly they will increase to full power.

Brando Post subject: Re: INS Arihant (ATV) News and Discussion -2 PostPosted: 26 Feb 2010 01:38 am BRFite Offline Joined: 26 Feb 2008 12:48 am Posts: 254 The article that claims "India's nuclear submarine doesn't have a working reactor" and is "no more than a floating hull" seems...

The reactor on Arihant is not critical, but I dont think it will be bought on land again and tested. It will be commissioned in sea that's how it is done for all US nuke subs. A review committee okays everything and gives go ahead to make the reactor critical.

I agree with Somnath. There two sides to the issue, But one thing we must remmber that unless we develop our own MIC we will always at the mercy of other people. There's no permanent friend. IMO both the armed forces and the DRDO are to be blamed and overall above the GOI. There has been absolutely ...

The other two hulls under construction are neither heavier nor bigger, similar design. If one wants to change/improve designs then one waits till the first one is commissioned to get feed back data. I think it should be 80MW Th, a submarine will need only a 3/4 MWe for its electrical needs.

Edited.. No name calling. ramana

Bala,

Can you mail it to me too please . jffun.at.rediffmail.com.
It can be my christmass present .

Shankar ji,

Its U238 which gets coneverted to Plutonium239 by capturing a neutron. And usually PWR type nuclear reactors dont produce much superheat. INS Arihant could be a special design.

I dont know about viveks military expertise or what he does but I know some other things. Anyway I am restrained by some other conditions. I totally agree with Rahul, the authors are not under any obligation whatsoever regading the frequency of the posts or scenarios. We as BRFites have every right ...

Vivek,

The tragedy is that in this forum a "self styled expert" is preaching without any understanding/appreciation of the effort involved in writing a realistic scenario. He had been snubbed more than once in the past but I think it has no effect on his kanchan armour type of skin.

I thought this was " Possible Indian Military Scenarios" thread

Ramanna thnx for the info. No offense intended to anyone but sometimes too much of uncalled for advise is unwarranted IMO. And we are not exactly kids here and if we all knew the 'true identities' of people here may be some of the 'experts' would think over once more before commenting. Anyway I rarl...

Hari, Please stop directing others. Its not the first time you have done so. Just remember that what vivek or shankar or any other author is doing is just as a hobby and not as paid job so none of us (including your highness) has any right to question his frequency of posts. And about manners its be...

And what is the time line for this Arhnem type operation ?

The difference between India/Pakistan is not same as US/Iraq or Russia/Georgia. About taking action against Bangladesh without going out for a full scale war will endanger the life of 1.2 crore hindus living there.

directly to nuclear conflict