Human Trafficking Crisis in India

The Strategic Issues & International Relations Forum is a venue to discuss issues pertaining to India's security environment, her strategic outlook on global affairs and as well as the effect of international relations in the Indian Subcontinent. We request members to kindly stay within the mandate of this forum and keep their exchanges of views, on a civilised level, however vehemently any disagreement may be felt. All feedback regarding forum usage may be sent to the moderators using the Feedback Form or by clicking the Report Post Icon in any objectionable post for proper action. Please note that the views expressed by the Members and Moderators on these discussion boards are that of the individuals only and do not reflect the official policy or view of the Bharat-Rakshak.com Website. Copyright Violation is strictly prohibited and may result in revocation of your posting rights - please read the FAQ for full details. Users must also abide by the Forum Guidelines at all times.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Gujarat is a destination for trafficking especially in the Bt cotton fields

Preventing Child Trafficking in India
Something was not quite right about the little group that climbed onto the bus.

On their hour-and-a-half bus ride home to Udaipur, India, from the project office in a small village where they had spent that late-July day, Joseph Mathew and his colleague, Hemlata Verma, spotted the man and six children right away. The pair quickly realized they were likely looking at victims of child trafficking. Mathew, as coordinator for ChildFund India’s anti-trafficking project Udaipur, lived and breathed the issue every day and knew the signs.

The man appeared middle-aged, and the children looked mostly 12 to 16 years, so it was unlikely they were his own.

The children sat separately, and an older boy, about 17, kept an eye on them. Mathew and Verma knew that traffickers often engaged older children to serve as leaders.

All of them carried bags containing a few pieces of clothing, often a sign of children migrating for work.

“I asked my colleague to start chit-chatting with the kids who were sitting next to her,” says Mathew. “The idea was to know who the children were and where they were going.”

Verma managed only brief conversations with the children before the older boy stopped them, but she heard enough to confirm what she and Mathew feared. Says Mathew, “We came to know that they were being trafficked to Gujarat to work in child labor."

Child trafficking has long been a problem between the neighboring states of Gujarat and Rajasthan, in western India.
Most trafficked children are put to work in Gujarat’s vast Bt cotton fields — as many as 100,000 per year, as a 2008 study conducted by ChildFund found — because of the belief that cross-pollination of the genetically modified plants requires small hands, and because child labor is cheap. Living under inhuman conditions and paid much less than they are led to expect, children work as much as 12 hours a day, often carrying huge loads of dangerous pesticides and suffering abuse. About 45,000 girls work these fields. Up to 5 percent end up becoming sex workers.
The ChildFund study also brought to light the fact that no national organization was working exclusively on the issue of trafficking in persons in the area. It was a given that local authorities were ill-equipped to prevent and respond to trafficking; in fact, even the police would often turn a blind eye to traffickers at checkpoints in exchange for cash.

ChildFund began working to strengthen community-based child protection systems to prevent and respond to child trafficking in Rajasthan. Beginning in 2009, with funding from the United States Department of State, ChildFund’s Trafficking in Persons (TIP) project trained dozens of personnel from local organizations, created task forces, raised awareness in communities and trained government officials and local authorities.

ChildFund’s work to fight child trafficking in the area now continues under a new name — Prevention of Child Trafficking, Rajasthan — and with new funding from BMZ Germany. As in any ChildFund effort, the best interest of children remains a running theme throughout all events and materials.

On that hot evening on the road toward Udaipur, ChildFund’s anti-child trafficking efforts made themselves felt in the lives of six children on the bus.

“Immediately, we tried to contact every possible concerned official who could help rescue the children,” says Mathew, but no one picked up — it was evening. Finally, the Additional Superintendent of Police responded to a text message and talked Mathew and Verma through what would happen next.

Soon, two police officers boarded the bus, others surrounded it, and the man was arrested. The local Child Welfare Committee arrived on the scene as well.

“This is a great example of combined effort by a civil society group and law enforcement agencies,” says Dola Mohapatra, ChildFund India’s national director. “It’s also a testimony to the level of awareness and alertness we have been able to create in the area about trafficking of children.”

The raised awareness is changing the local system. Project team members report a shift in the dialogue they share with police, from hesitant to proactive. Lawyers are more sensitized and contribute voluntarily to the fight against child trafficking.

And six children spent the night safely in a shelter while their trafficker languished in a cell between interrogations.

The problem of child trafficking continues in the area, but it’s not nearly as easy for the culprits as it used to be.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Human trafficking cases up by 10% in 2013, shows police data

http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-new ... 87486.aspx

The torture and subsequent death of a 35-year-old maid by the wife of a politician in Chanakyapuri late last year had brought the issue of human trafficking back into the limelight, sources believed.
Sachin
Webmaster BR
Posts: 8989
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Undisclosed

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Sachin »

Kerala witnessed a major case of human trafficking last week. At Palakkad the police find a huge contingent of around 500 children in a train coming from the North Eastern states. Questioning the few adults escorting this gang, it was found that this group was to be delivered at an Orphanage at Mukkam, in Kozhikode Rural Dt. The Orphanage is run by Islamic charity group(s). The children are said to be mainly from Jharkhand. Some links:-
1. Central team should probe the issue of children brought to Kerala: Arjun Munde
2. Orphanages portrayed in poor light: Basheer
3. Jharkhand officials confirm child trafficking to Kerala

State Police DIG investigating the case has said that prima-facie this is a case of human trafficking. The Home Minister of Kerala has said that the case would be investigated in detail. And off course the "secular" forces now consider him to be an RSS man ;) Questions are now being raised on:-
1. Are these kids to be from Jharkhand, or from Bangladesh?
2. If these people are indeed from poorer parts of India, why not the concerned charity organisations in Kerala build up better infrastructure in these states? Why bring these kids to Kerala, and utilise the welfare measures which ideally can be given for kids in Kerala.
3. How long would these kids stay put in orphanages? What happens after that? Are they even getting sent abroad (mainly to the Gulf countries) as cheap labour, and perhaps for child prostitution.
vishvak
BR Mainsite Crew
Posts: 5836
Joined: 12 Aug 2011 21:19

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by vishvak »

Puts a question mark over claims of the ruling leftists as progressive thinkers as also statewide statistics. Plus how come leftists didn't tend to examine and take strict actions over long time is something to think about.
Sachin
Webmaster BR
Posts: 8989
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Undisclosed

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Sachin »

vishvak wrote:Puts a question mark over claims of the ruling leftists as progressive thinkers as also statewide statistics.
Current ruling regime in the commie cuckoo land, Kerala is not LDF, but the UDF with INC and "secular" parties like Kerala Congress and Muslim League. The "progressiveness" of the leftists is nothing but propaganda, which would put Goebbels to shame. As I see it today, the commies in Kerala are as dogmatic to their holy book just like earlier Keralites (esp. upper castes) who were very dogmatic about their holy books (which even determined how far one caste should keep away from another caste).

Sorry for going OT.
ramana
Forum Moderator
Posts: 59808
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by ramana »

Moving the thread to Strat Forum as it has inter-, intra-state, and most likely foreign aspects to the whole issue.
symontk
BRFite
Posts: 920
Joined: 01 Nov 2001 12:31
Location: Bangalore

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by symontk »

Lets give the credit where its due, ie. Kerala police. The train did not fly from North India to Kerala. It came thru several states. What were the police forces of those states doing?

The train was intercepted at the first station in Kerala
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

What sort of hell do Indian children go through? First the shelters and now this

In the mid-nineties international adoption from India was precisely banned for this reason. The girls were being taken to the middle east for prostitution and the little boys for camel rides and later slavery. The middle east has institutionalized torture of children. True demons.

http://m.rediff.com/news/report/keralas ... 140604.htm


Kerala's 'orphan industry' sells kids in the Gulf

trafficking of 589 children to shelter homes in Kerala has exposed a deep-rooted racket with a network in Gulf. Vicky Nanjappa reports

More that 589 children from two orphanages in Kozhikode and Malappuram, Kerala, were rescued in a case of suspected child trafficking last week.

The arrest of eight people based in West Bengal from the Palakkad railway station in connection with the alleged racket has brought under the scanner private shelter homes run in the state.

The children in the age group of eight to 13 were rescued after the arrest of the alleged traffickers, who were running orphanages in north Kerala. Children from the northeast, Bihar and Jharkhand were admitted to the orphanages and later sold into slavery. Most of these children were kidnapped or purchased from parents who find it difficult to make ends meet with the promise of a better life and education.

The Railway Protection Police found it suspicious that eight men were accompanied by over 100 children. First, a batch of 466 children from Bihar and Jharkhand arrived at the Palakkad railway station by the Patna-Ernakulam Express. Then came the second batch comprising 123 kids from West Bengal. The children were detained by the railway police as they arrived on May 24 and 25.

During the course of the investigation, three accused confessed that they were working for the Mukkam Muslim Orphanage and the others said they belonged to the Vettathur Anwarul Orphanage in Malappuram.

Further probe revealed that several such orphanages have mushroomed in north Kerala. These organisations have a team in Gulf countries that collects donations under the guise of child welfare. After a few years, the children are sold in the Gulf.

The children are purchased by the orphanages for anything between Rs 1,000 to Rs 3,000 depending on their age. A three-year-old is purchased for Rs 1,000 and a 12-year-old for Rs 3,000, the accused told the police.

The orphanages then sell these children in the Gulf for anything between Rs 5,000 to Rs 100,000. The girls are forced into prostitution and the boys are employed as servants in the houses of the rich, the police investigation revealed.

“This is not a new racket. But after the recent arrests we have realised how deep-rooted this problem is. This is just a start. We will work on putting an end to this,” a police officer said.

Another police officer from Kerala said, “We are going to investigate the functioning of other orphanages in the state. If people have information, they should come forward,” he urged.

At the centre of the child trafficking racket is Mallapuram’s Vettathur Anwarul Orphanage. Over 125 children from West Bengal and Bangladesh have been admitted here over the past year.

The issue took a political turn after the Indian Union Muslim League, a partner of the ruling United Democratic Front, alleged conspiracy against their community. IUML General Secretary and Lok Sabha member E T Muhammad Basheer said, “I feel that there is something wrong in the manner in which the case is being probed.”

However, he had no answer when asked why the children were in the custody of the eight men without any proper documentation. The Kerala government is likely to hand over the investigation to the Central Bureau of Investigation.
Lilo
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4080
Joined: 23 Jun 2007 09:08

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Lilo »

^
Wonder how many children were sold to Arab pedophiles all these years of sikular rule of dienasty before the Kerala Police balled up enough courage to intervene seeing the Modi regime at center.

Surely an operation of this scale could not escape the attention of sleuths all this time - ergo they were under central orders not to intervene in the flesh export to Arabs - under the direct backing of the dienasty nonetheless.

Image

And our bogus civil society watchdogs headed by our Paidmedia (which does "stings" against Rs 2 lakh bribes and snoopgates just to make a show of their "investigative journalism" "of the most daring kind") and Rights groups doing pointless exercises as Slutwalks and Pink Chaddi campaings gave a nelsons eye to the unimaginable atrocities being visited upon thousands and thousands of children in such meat processing centers (Circulating themselves as mainority "Orphanages and Shelter" homes - with special mainority protections).

Even Bji mentioned about this child trafficking racket and shooting demand for castrated boys in north Kerala long time back in these forums.I refuse to believe that the Kerala Police didnt know :evil: :evil:
Last edited by Lilo on 05 Jun 2014 05:51, edited 2 times in total.
Karan M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 20782
Joined: 19 Mar 2010 00:58

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Karan M »

^^ Wonder where our secular leaders do no wrong crowd are now. The INC have truly used this country in the worst way possible, encouraging all these criminals.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

What evil and what adharma. Even those who have no kids will shiver in horror let alone those who have children
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Isn't it remarkable that under Maino no atgo liv priest in India was arrested for child abuse when we all know that it is a rampant problem in RCC. Looks like all the RCC priests in India are really different from the rest of the world
Vriksh
BRFite
Posts: 406
Joined: 27 Apr 2003 11:31

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Vriksh »

There seems to be a problem of documentation for the kids. However I could not find any substantiation for alleged export of kids. This said a proper investigation of such activities should help weed out illegal activity and create a framework for children to access better educational opportunities all around India.
ramana
Forum Moderator
Posts: 59808
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by ramana »

Would you agree the children are from out of Kerala?
Would you agree that they were sent to Gulf countries per the Kerala Police?
And two institutions were at the core of this outrage?
trafficking of 589 children to shelter homes in Kerala has exposed a deep-rooted racket with a network in Gulf. Vicky Nanjappa reports

More that 589 children from two orphanages in Kozhikode and Malappuram, Kerala, were rescued in a case of suspected child trafficking last week.

The arrest of eight people based in West Bengal from the Palakkad railway station in connection with the alleged racket has brought under the scanner private shelter homes run in the state.

The children in the age group of eight to 13 were rescued after the arrest of the alleged traffickers, who were running orphanages in north Kerala. Children from the northeast, Bihar and Jharkhand were admitted to the orphanages and later sold into slavery. Most of these children were kidnapped or purchased from parents who find it difficult to make ends meet with the promise of a better life and education.

The Railway Protection Police found it suspicious that eight men were accompanied by over 100 children. First, a batch of 466 children from Bihar and Jharkhand arrived at the Palakkad railway station by the Patna-Ernakulam Express. Then came the second batch comprising 123 kids from West Bengal. The children were detained by the railway police as they arrived on May 24 and 25.

During the course of the investigation, three accused confessed that they were working for the Mukkam Muslim Orphanage and the others said they belonged to the Vettathur Anwarul Orphanage in Malappuram.

Further probe revealed that several such orphanages have mushroomed in north Kerala. These organisations have a team in Gulf countries that collects donations under the guise of child welfare. After a few years, the children are sold in the Gulf.

The children are purchased by the orphanages for anything between Rs 1,000 to Rs 3,000 depending on their age. A three-year-old is purchased for Rs 1,000 and a 12-year-old for Rs 3,000, the accused told the police.

The orphanages then sell these children in the Gulf for anything between Rs 5,000 to Rs 100,000. The girls are forced into prostitution and the boys are employed as servants in the houses of the rich, the police investigation revealed.

“This is not a new racket. But after the recent arrests we have realised how deep-rooted this problem is. This is just a start. We will work on putting an end to this,” a police officer said.

Another police officer from Kerala said, “We are going to investigate the functioning of other orphanages in the state. If people have information, they should come forward,” he urged.

At the centre of the child trafficking racket is Mallapuram’s Vettathur Anwarul Orphanage. Over 125 children from West Bengal and Bangladesh have been admitted here over the past year.
Now Kerala Govt is asking for CBI inquiry as its too close for comfort.
Anand K
BRFite
Posts: 1115
Joined: 19 Aug 2003 11:31
Location: Out.

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Anand K »

Arab Sheikhs used to "import" kids and lightly built teens from TSP as jockeys for their camel races. The lives of these young ones are living hell. Certain countries such as the UAE banned these officially but there are many who flout the law. Wonder if some of the Indian kids ended up in those slave pens....
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Not much has changed since the Arabs first came to India.
India was a source of wealth, science, civilization and slave labor of all types.
India still plays the same role. Indian muslims are nothing but fodder for this transfer
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Anand K wrote:Arab Sheikhs used to "import" kids and lightly built teens from TSP as jockeys for their camel races. The lives of these young ones are living hell. Certain countries such as the UAE banned these officially but there are many who flout the law. Wonder if some of the Indian kids ended up in those slave pens....

This demoniacal civilization revels in the torture of helpless. Torture of the helpless is institutionalized. Children are objects.
This demoniacal civilization that has caused so much pain and adharma over centuries needs to be ended.
Vriksh
BRFite
Posts: 406
Joined: 27 Apr 2003 11:31

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Vriksh »

I have been trained to spot problems in Mainstream media reports by my stint in BR. First the detention was done by Railway Police which is a central govt organization. I am under the impression that railway stations and property is monitored by Railway Police and typically state police have their eyes elsewhere. So it is possible to slip from state to state using railways unless there is specific intelligence of malafide intent.

I am still awaiting hard proof that Kids were exported out of these orphanages to Gulf as slaves. If this is proved conclusively then we have to act decisively.

But more worryingly how will the Indian state deal with similar cases. I am also running scenarios in my mind of say other boarding schools with children being sent for education. As of now minors are being transported all across India with nary a eye on documentation. Heck recently my MIL chaperoned many relative's kids (6) to her native place for a family function (who is to say she was not trafficking). How will the state react to such activity now. Just yesterday 2 matronly ladies from some posh SoBo high school took 30 young girls (grade 9-12) by flight to Pondicherry for a field trip (I don't know if they had any documentation). Will we start charging the chaperones with child trafficking. How will we evolve a robust workable non intrusive mechanism to ensure freedom of movement and protection of minors.
RamaY
BRF Oldie
Posts: 17249
Joined: 10 Aug 2006 21:11
Location: http://bharata-bhuti.blogspot.com/

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by RamaY »

^ Until 80% trafficking networks are broken & punished there should be extra caution.

Police can carry smart phones and make Face Time App with parents when in doubt for confirmation. If the doubt persist, police can demand daily attendance (they don't have to go to police station but police will visit them) during the field trip and confirmation of kids return.

Use technology, be innovative!
ramana
Forum Moderator
Posts: 59808
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by ramana »

Vriksh dont start straw man attacks. The instances you mention are definitely not under the category of interest. And straw man ideas shouldn't detract from doing right thing.
Sachin
Webmaster BR
Posts: 8989
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Undisclosed

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Sachin »

Vriksh wrote:Heck recently my MIL chaperoned many relative's kids (6) to her native place for a family function (who is to say she was not trafficking). How will the state react to such activity now. Just yesterday 2 matronly ladies from some posh SoBo high school took 30 young girls (grade 9-12) by flight to Pondicherry for a field trip
My take would be that the RPF or GRP (in train) can still question these people. Off-course your MIL, or the matronly ladies would be able to come up with a good explanation. Perhaps combined train tickets etc. etc. Then the kids parents also would be available to give clarifications if required. Where as in this game in Kerala it was around 200++ kids who were transported en-masse in un-reserved coaches. From what I could make out there were no women at all, it was all men who were escorting these kids. And these worthies had not purchased any tickets as well. That is what made the RPF and GRP suspicious. Now we are hearing the stories that these Ustaads had collected Rs.200 from the parent of each kid for transportation. Ustads have neatly pocketed the money.

Yes it is a mystery on how these large contingent of kids managed to come by train crossing at least 3 states before landing up in Kerala. Are such journeys a common practice in these places, I don't know. How ever Malayalam local media report that the Indian Union Muslim League is now actively working on scuttling the case. They are trying to wash down the case by saying only procedural lapses were there, and the intent were all good.
vishvak
BR Mainsite Crew
Posts: 5836
Joined: 12 Aug 2011 21:19

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by vishvak »

How come 'international' rich secular people like sheiks from middle east, who are part of the trafficking crisis and at top of pseudo secular pyramid, remain below scrutiny. Only secular people seem to have an answer such 'international' part of, and financial and criminal factor of, the crisis.
A_Gupta
BRF Oldie
Posts: 12125
Joined: 23 Oct 2001 11:31
Contact:

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by A_Gupta »

I think targeting the supply side alone will not work, one has to attack the demand side as well.

So, e.g., someone with a transplanted organ that was illegally obtained should get an automatic jail term. DNA can easily establish that an organ is someone else's.
ramana
Forum Moderator
Posts: 59808
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by ramana »

Lilo, I request you to periodically map the reports in both twitter handles to show the prevalence of the crimes in a graphical manner. Please post here and on the twitter handles.
Thanks, ramana

PS: I have been periodically requesting my followers to follow and spread the news about those two handles.
Vriksh
BRFite
Posts: 406
Joined: 27 Apr 2003 11:31

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Vriksh »

ramana wrote:Vriksh dont start straw man attacks. The instances you mention are definitely not under the category of interest. And straw man ideas shouldn't detract from doing right thing.
I understand it is a strawman but I highlighted it to show how such incident unless handled thoughtfully may have wider repercussions due to overambitious legislation as a result of this incident. (Just like after 911 in the US passengers can be potentially cavity searched at random).

I understand that the scale of the incident mentioned is unprecedented and worrying plus the possibility that these kids could be enslaved abroad. However suppose the perps had taken precautions and booked in smaller groups of 20 kids with women chaperones would that be ok?

I still look forward to proof that some of the kids from these orphanages are now working as slaves in the Middle east so decisive action can be taken against erring entities.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

There has been ample proof over the ages that Indian children have been trafficked to the Middle East. Google child trafficking Middle East and some key words and it will throw up the details.
I don't see why other people have to provide proof for something so talked about and written about. Just do it yourself
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32429
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by chetak »

Child trafficking plot thickens...- Under ally pressure, Kerala govt shies away from launching full-fledged investigation

Thiruvananthapuram, June 7:

Nearly a fortnight after over 500 children were found stuffed in trains that arrived in Kerala late last month, investigators are yet to press trafficking charges against the orphanages that are under the scanner or even question its officials.

Many of the children, over 160 from Jharkhand alone, had gone without food and water for hours together and were travelling ticketless.

Some of them were travelling with their parents. Yet all were going to Mukkam Muslim Orphanage in Kozhikode.

In terms of action, there have been only a few cursory arrests of alleged agents who brought the children along. And if the Kerala government is seen to be dithering on moving quickly to bring the culprits to book, there are reasons.

The chairman of the orphanage is Syed Hyederali Shihab Thangal, the tallest leader of the Indian Union Muslim League, which is also an ally of the ruling Congress-led United Democratic Front government.

“The railway police division of Kerala police has registered a case under Section 370(5) of the IPC. The charge relates to trafficking of minor children and they are investigating,’’ Palakkad district collector K. Ramachandran told The Telegraph.

But what he does not say is that this has been the position since May 25 when the children were found in the trains that arrived at the Olavakkode railway station in Palakkad.

Around 500 children, mostly from Bihar and Jharkhand, were found hoarded — some of them had gone without food and water for hours — in three compartments of the Patna Kochi Express, which reached Palakkad on May 24.


Another 123 children from West Bengal had arrived by another train a day later. The first batch of children was to be taken to Mukkam orphanage, while the 123 were to be sent to Anwarul Huda orphanage in Malappuram district.

A high-level crime branch team constituted to probe the incident has so far arrested 10 persons, allegedly agents.

While four of them are from Malda in West Bengal, the rest belong to Godda in Jharkhand.

The last arrest, that of 30-year-old Shafeek Sheikh of Persia village in Godda, was carried out yesterday. Police say he was in the train with the children but had fled the scene on seeing them. He has been working in the Mukkam orphanage as a cook since the last three years and had helped bring at least a dozen children to Kerala in the past.

His wife Rubic Hatoom is a cleaner in the orphanage.

However, even the crime branch team is yet to take any of the orphanage officials into custody for questioning. The reasons are obvious.

The IUML is upset at the manner in which the investigation was proceeding and wanted the state to drop the trafficking angle.

Party MP E.T. Mohammed Basheer said neither the officials of the states to which the children belong, nor their parents, had complained to the Kerala government of any illegality and hence it could not be termed child trafficking.

Orphanage authorities also maintain that it was only a case of lack of understanding of the legal provisions and that there was nothing wrong in trying to give children from poverty-stricken areas in Jharkhand, Bihar and West Bengal food and education.

But the answer fails to explain why children whose parents were alive were labelled as orphans and admitted to the orphanage.

The ally pressure seemed to show on the ruling Congress too, with Kerala chief minister Oommen Chandy terming it procedural lapse and home minister Ramesh Chennithala saying he did not want to comment for fear of influencing the investigation.

Not many seem to agree with their versions.

The state child welfare committee has written to the railway police seeking legal action against the perpetrators and demanding a report at the earliest.

The nodal officer of the State Human Rights Commission (SHRC), DIG S. Sreejith, was one of the first to examine the issue and had gone on record to say that it was a “clear case of child trafficking’’.

The rules for inter-state transfer of children did not seem to have been observed, he had said.

Rights commission chief Justice J.B. Koshy said he would wait till the inquiry was over before reaching any conclusion, but added that several suspicions like the likelihood of the children being subjected to organ trade or sexual abuse needed to be probed in detail.

He revealed that some of the orphanages had resisted when the commission tried to conduct an audit of their activities in the past.

One institution from Malappuram had even approached the state high court against this.

But just as the government appeared to be chickening out, there was hope from Kerala High Court. Acting on a plea by an NGO, a bench of Chief Justice Manjula Chellur and Justice P.R. Ramachandra Menon has called for a “serious investigation’’ into why such large number of children had come to Kerala.

The court has also issued notices to Jharkhand, Bihar and West Bengal. The Union ministry of social welfare and railways were also impleaded in the petition. The hearing is on June 19.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Another large trafficking destination in the middle east

http://www.irinnews.org/report/84897/is ... rafficking

ISRAEL: Still a destination for human trafficking

TEL AVIV, 18 June 2009 (IRIN) - The latest US State Department report on trafficked persons, released on 16 June, says Israel is still a destination for men and women trafficked for forced labour and sexual exploitation.

Women from the former Soviet Union and China are still being trafficked across the border with Egypt into Israel for forced prostitution by organized criminal groups.

According to local NGOs, such as Isha L’iash and Moked, each year several hundred women in Israel - many of them foreigners - are trafficked within the country for commercial sexual exploitation, according to the report.

In 2006 Israel was put on the US State Department’s Tier 2 watch list and has been described as a “prime destination for trafficking” by both the State Department and the UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC).

However, the State Department report recognized Israeli efforts in the past three years: Although the government did not fully comply with minimum standards for the elimination of trafficking, it had made significant efforts to do so, with law enforcement, police activity against traffickers, and the provision of assistance and shelter to victims of sex trafficking.

In 2008, the Israeli government gave US$1.25 million to a local NGO, Ma’agan, which provides shelter to foreign victims of sex trafficking. The funds were used for rent, utility bills, security and medical care. During the year, the shelter assisted 44 women.

Forced labour victims

The report said the Israeli government did not provide most of the forced labour victims with protection services (safe shelter or medical and psychological aid) and recommended that it begin to do so.

Israel lacks a shelter for victims of labour trafficking, including migrant workers who come to the country voluntarily. However, the authorities referred six female victims of forced labour to the Ma’agan shelter during the reporting period.

Workers from China, Romania, Turkey, Thailand, the Philippines, Nepal, Sri Lanka, and India migrate voluntarily and legally to Israel for contract labour in the construction, agriculture, and health care industries. Some subsequently face conditions of forced labour, including the unlawful withholding of passports, restrictions on movement, non-payment of wages, threats, and physical intimidation.

Many recruitment agencies in the workers’ countries of origin and in Israel require workers to pay recruitment fees ranging between US$1,000 and US$10,000. This makes the workers highly vulnerable to trafficking or to becoming victims of debt bondage once they arrive in Israel.

The director-general of the Ministry of Justice, Moshe Shilo, told reporters on 16 June he was satisfied that the report had noted the efforts made by the government and the Justice Ministry.

Attorney Adi Vilinger, human trafficking force coordinator at the Hotline for Migrant workers, a local NGO working for the rights of migrant workers, refugees and trafficked persons, told IRIN: “We recognize the great progress the government has made in the past three years on the issue of trafficked women from outside Israel, but regret to see that the government has yet to make sufficient progress on the issue of trafficked foreign workers and local Israeli women trafficked inside Israel for sexual exploitation. We still have a long road ahead of us.”

In March 2009, Israeli police uncovered the largest human trafficking gang to have ever operated in Israel.

The suspected traffickers are accused of smuggling hundreds of women from the former Soviet Union into Israel to work in the sex industry. According to the police, they trafficked over 2,000 women into Israel and Cyprus over a six-year period. They are now on trial.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Only 6 Percent of Child Trafficking Cases in India Result in Prosecutions
And therein lies the problem. Unless people are punished this will go on. Children seem to be at the bottom of the totem pole

http://therealnews.com/t2/index.php?opt ... ival=10154
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Ramana, to your point about surrogacy being a new frontier of trafficking.
My view is that like organ trade surrogacy needs to be completely banned in India until majority of our people are out of shackles of misery. Else, there is a potential of it getting misused badly as below. People who would never be able to tap into adoption because of proclivities are using surrogacy.


I
sraeli Sex Offender Taps India's Booming Surrogacy Trade For Baby Girl

The revelation that a convicted sex offender from Israel succeeded years ago in hiring a surrogate mother and taking a baby girl home from India sent shock waves through India's booming, controversial surrogacy industry this week.

But there is little that India or Israel can do at this point to influence the fate of the little girl, who is now 4 years old.

“The child is not going to be removed from the home now because according to the law in Israel if there's no proof that the parent is severely harming the child [the authorities] cannot take the child out of the home,” Elizabeth Levy, director of international relations at the Jerusalem-based National Council for the Child (NCC), told GlobalPost.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Any thoughts on how to make this thread more active? This is such a massive problem. It is bigger than the impact of terrorism in India. It is truly heinous.
Imagine your child kidnapped and trafficked for sex or organs. Is that the only thing that will wake people our.
The most helpless and innocent of our people are slaves and tortured.
Any ideas to increase awareness. Given the power of social media, increased awareness can put a severe dent on this problem.
Sachin
Webmaster BR
Posts: 8989
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Undisclosed

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Sachin »

NHRC issues notices to Kerala, Jharkhand over orphanage issue
Local vernacular media reports that many of the kids have now been sent back back to their mother states with police escort. The state government agencies got a few special coaches attached to a train going towards North Eastern parts of India. Major whine-fest in social media of how poor kids now sent back to north east India in an AC Coach only to be forced to work in brick kilns.
Anand K
BRFite
Posts: 1115
Joined: 19 Aug 2003 11:31
Location: Out.

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Anand K »

Mischa Glenny's McMafia gives a chilling account of the Israel hub of human trafficking - though on the flesh trade. The illegal organ trade is strong in Israel - even harvested organs from dead Hezbollah types.
Anyway, till the 1985 ban, India was a source of skeletons and "human materials" - veritable bone factories in Bengal and Bihar just like the Mummy factories of Egypt. When the British passed the Anatomy Act in 1832 this killed body snatching (which even claimed Milton's corpse) but also promised the god-fearing subjects that no white men's bones will be used to grace the private clinics, homes and hospitals. So the Calcutta Medical College was churning a thousand skeletons a year by Shanghaing the Dom caste which used to dominate cremations. This continued till the late 1980s as a rather roaring trade.

Illegal organ trade also still exists in a huge scale but China leads the charge here. The tradition continues with the Preet Mandir Adoption Racket, the Gurgaon Kidney Racket and Tsunami Nagar "Kidneyvakkam" and the like.... The kids-forcash equivalent is there, and predominates, but organ trade should also exist - it's way too profitable. :roll:
Lilo
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4080
Joined: 23 Jun 2007 09:08

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Lilo »

ramana wrote:Lilo, I request you to periodically map the reports in both twitter handles to show the prevalence of the crimes in a graphical manner. Please post here and on the twitter handles.
Thanks, ramana

PS: I have been periodically requesting my followers to follow and spread the news about those two handles.
Ramana garu,

The feeds related to rape and human trafficking often have articles on general policy,opinion,Op-eds,conferences etc regarding violence on women and human trafficking issues.Also there is some repetition of feed items on incidents reported by multiple news sources too.
A geographical prevalence chart will be timetaking (have to sift out above mentioned news articles) to get data which can be used for generating a geographical distribution of unique incidents as reported by english MSM .
MSM however themselves purchase news reports from the press agencies like PTI,IANS etc .
So every rape/human traffiking incident is not picked up by agencies from their police sources, and of those picked up by agencies not every story is reported in English MSM.

Best methinks is to directly use police records to give a graphical distribution(say district wise) of the incident map.

The feeds are good for spreading general awareness on the issue and getting a most recent glimpse on the kind of crimes being reported in english MSM.

However all the historical feed data on both feeds is being dumped into google spreadsheets for the purpose of any which way it can be utilized, as linked in my previous posts ,
>> http://forums.bharat-rakshak.com/viewto ... 6#p1505706
>> http://forums.bharat-rakshak.com/viewto ... 4#p1432744
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

The horror The horror

Between greed and poverty: child trafficking rampant in Kerala orphanages

http://www.hindustantimes.com/india-new ... 32244.aspx
Lilo
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4080
Joined: 23 Jun 2007 09:08

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Lilo »

^
Between greed and poverty: child trafficking rampant in Kerala orphanages

While transporting cattle to Kerala from neighbouring states, there are strict guidelines: all animals must be vaccinated, they should not be kept in overcrowded pens, and carriers must produce papers showing where they were loaded. But when railway authorities and the district administration rounded up 600 children from three compartments at the Palakkad station in two different incidents last month, they found that even cattle are transported in a more humane way.
Half the children were travelling without tickets. Many had starved. Aged between three and 12, they were carrying big trunks and some were barely clothed. “Ustad will tell you all,” was all they could say. They had no idea where they were being taken.

Twelve-year-old Khatoon, a resident of Murshidabad, opened up after much prodding. She had been sent away from home in the hope that she would get three meals a day and an education. Jharkhand’s Ameena had a different story to tell. Her parents had sold her and her six-year-old brother for Rs. 10,000.

Authorities say this is a routine affair. There are 1,000-odd orphanages in Kerala. During investigations, some told police that they had been enrolling children from other states for the past eight years. Shakeel Ahmed, one of the agents who was arrested, told the police he had brought in 500 children in two years. “It seems in India, human lives really are cheaper than cattle,” says a district official who was part of the rescue team.

Most of the papers seized from people accompanying the children were fudged. All the 50 kids from West Bengal had the same date of birth and village officers’ affidavits showed the same handwriting. Police say at least a dozen agents are active in taking children to Kerala and Bangalore. Their modus operandi is simple — they show parents photos of these institutions and say their children will get education and care. Often, they take money from both, parents and orphanage officials. Sometimes, they give parents money in exchange for their children.

“When we rounded them up, most of the children had no idea where they were going. Tired, some of them couldn’t even walk,” says the Palakkad Child Welfare Committee chief Father Jose Paul. Many orphanages don’t keep track of missing children. Recently, six minor ragpickers detained in Kochi told the police that they had fled from an orphanage in Malappuram because they were being ill treated. No missing complaint had been filed.

Interestingly, religious sanction has resulted in more orphanages coming up In Kerala with a majority of them being Muslim and Christian institutions. Not to be outdone, the Sangh Parivar is also planning to widen its charity network. Since Kerala is socially and economically advanced, many orphanages do not get local kids.

Most of them, however, do good business by accepting generous donations from across the country and from West Asia by citing these ‘orphans’. Last year, one of the orphanages, Kozhikode-based Markauz Saquafathi Sunniyya, received Rs. 2.4 crore in foreign aid and also claimed a grant of Rs. 13,90,231 from the state government by concealing the foreign contribution. Most of these institutions get state social welfare ministry grants after providing false affidavits about not getting foreign assistance. Last year, these orphanages got roughly Rs. 300 crore from abroad. Now, fearing a CBI inquiry, most are in a hurry to conceal records. They are also trying to dump children admitted without any records. About two weeks ago, 23 kids were found abandoned at Thrissur railway station. 18 were found at Thiruvalla.

Since the Palakkad incident, many genuinely charitable institutions have also come under the scanner. There is no denying, though, that money was being made off the children even there. If these institutions really have the children’s best interest at heart, why aren’t they working in the states that need them?

“In the north, there is ghettoisation. Muslims are generally confined to their villages. In Kerala, they rub shoulders with everyone on an equal footing :lol: . Once they go back, they can be better citizens,” says the Mukkam orphanage (one of the biggest and best run) general secretary VE Moi Haji explaining the reasoning behind bringing children from other states. Of the 1,100 inmates at the orphanage, 430 are from other states. One even got selected to the civil service in 2011.

Can this sort of initiative be termed child-trafficking? Chief Minister Oommen Chandy admitted there had been procedural lapses in the ‘recruitment’ of the children but stopped short of labelling the Palakkad case as one of trafficking. But 10 persons arrested in this connection have been booked under Section 370 (5) (child trafficking and abuse) of the Indian Penal Code. Child Line officials insist it is an outright trafficking case and want stricter measures in place. The situation has triggered a rift in the ruling coalition. The Muslim League, the second-largest partner in the UDF, is upset with the Congress for invoking strict provisions. Most of the detained children were bound for two Muslim orphanages in north Kerala. But whether it was a case of trafficking or not, there is no doubt at all that this is no way to transport little children.

Image
The parent's words in the graphic shows that the momeen are happily predisposed to sell/give their kids even if its to the devil - provided that the devil is a muslim devil.

Guess its the same "flesh is yours but bones are ours" mindset seen in their brethren across the borders.
... In many cases, families take their sons to madrassas because they cannot afford to raise them themselves. A researcher with the AIDS Prevention Association of Pakistan (who asked that her name not be used) cited a saying such parents have for the teachers when they bring them their sons: "His flesh is yours, but his bones are ours."

http://forums.bharat-rakshak.com/viewto ... 8#p1520408
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Middle East needs to be completely destroyed. These people are monsters. Who does this to children. Old news but child trafficking is big business. The treatment of child jockeys - torture through starvation and thirst makes any trafficking in India seem like peanuts. Notice that none of lefty shits have ever raised a stink about this

http://www.gluckman.com/camelracing.html
Every year, scores of kidnapped children are smuggled from South Asia to the Middle East where they are maimed and killed, all for the amusement of the oil-rich rulers of kingdoms on the camel racing circuit

This is typical, according to authorities in India, who smashed several child-selling gangs during the early 1990s. The kids are sold for as little as US$3. Hundreds more are kidnapped, often toddlers as young as two.

A five-year-old rider was beaten to death by other child jockeys last year. But neither he, nor his six-year-old assailants, were mentioned in media or police reports. "This happens often, too often," says a local reporter, who requested anonymity for fear of reprisal.


Th
e tiny riders are kept to a painful pace. As soon as they finish one race, they are pulled from the camels, tossed in vans, and saddled up for the next, which starts within minutes. Jockeys wear the colors of their owners, jogging suits of blue, white, red and green, topped with tiny helmets or headgear. Many are equipped with small radios, so the trainers can signal every swing of the riding crop.


Camel jockeys: Popular Arab sport costs Pakistani children their sanity
“Imran is mentally retarded and can not learn any more in school,” his father Muhammad Shakoor repeats an assessment of the young boy’s teacher.

“My ‘Sheikh’ and my trainers used to continuously beat me—this is what I can recall,” Imran tells The Express Tribune.

A senior physician at Bahawal Victoria Hospital in neighbouring Bahawalpur, Dr Naeem, has a history of treating former child camel jockeys. He says that as many as 34 former jockeys had been admitted in the hospital between 2005 and 2007 for treatment. A majority of them, Dr Naeem notes, were mental patients.
Last edited by Jarita on 02 Jul 2014 22:05, edited 1 time in total.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Child slavery in the middle east

http://www.frontpagemag.com/2011/stephe ... ninsula/2/
Unfortunately for its innocent victims, both present and future, the eradication of slavery on the Arabian Peninsula will be difficult, if not impossible, to achieve. It is an ingrained, centuries-old institution. And despite it being officially banned since the early 1960s, many fundamentalist Muslims there still view destroying innocent young lives as their legal right. Under sharia law, which governs Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States, Muslims are legally allowed to own slaves. Bernard Lewis, the eminent scholar of Islam, writes “…the institution of slavery is not only recognised but is elaborately regulated by Sharia law.” Another reason for this inhuman sense of entitlement is that the prophet Muhammad was also a slave owner, setting the example for the fundamentalists.
A
nother problem that hinders eradication is that highly-placed officials responsible for enforcing the laws in Arabian countries probably own slaves themselves. One former black African slave girl, Mender Nazer, who escaped from slavery in London, England, belonged to a highly-placed official in the Sudanese embassy. Nazer was the second slave to escape from her Arab master’s household in the British capital and wrote an account of her years in bondage in Slave: My True Story.
Victims of child slavery also cannot look to the United Nations Human Rights Council for help. It contains despots and tyrants whose human rights records are just as bad as Mauritania’s and Saudi Arabia’s, as well as Islamic countries that bribe them and may be practising slavery themselves.
American and European leftists, who worked themselves into paroxysms of moral outrage over Mohammed al-Dura, the 12-year-old boy they claim was shot dead by Israeli soldiers, also have yet to exhibit the same level of empathy for child victims of the Arab slave trade. The reason they haven’t so far is that they want to maintain the image they have carefully constructed that Israel and America are the only oppressors in the Middle East and Arabs the victims. Admitting that Arabs are enslaving children would only undermine their propaganda campaign. The left also wants to keep the focus on the trans-Atlantic slave trade. It has always been a useful weapon to use against the Untied States.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

Silent Slaves: Stories of Human Trafficking in India

http://www.womenundersiegeproject.org/b ... g-in-india
In a six-bed women’s ward in New Delhi’s Safdarjung Hospital lies a frail 15-year-old girl. Her face and head are bandaged, leaving visible only a bruised blue-black eye and swollen lips. Burn marks and scabs extend down her neck to her whole body, and a disfigured ear clings on to her face like a piece of mangled flesh. A strange stench surrounds her. The nurse who comes to check on her explains the smell: A wound on the girl’s skull is rotting and has filled with maggots.

The girl tries to speak. In a muffled voice, she says: “My employer would beat me every day with a broom and a stool. Many times she would put a hot pan on my body and burn my skin. That’s how the skin on my skull started peeling out as she repeatedly burned the same spot.”

Somehow the horrific brutality inflicted on this teenager is not an isolated case. Thousands of girls are trafficked every year from remote villages to large cities and sold as domestic workers. Many are abused or sexually exploited.

Extreme poverty, lack of education and employment, and poor implementation of the government’s minimum wage system in rural India make girls more vulnerable to being trafficked. The 2013 Global Slavery Index, published by the Australia-based Walk Free Foundation, an organization that works to end modern slavery, found that almost half of the 30 million “modern slaves” in the world are from India.
Jarita
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2649
Joined: 30 Oct 2009 22:27
Location: Andromeda

Re: Human Trafficking Crisis in India

Post by Jarita »

So what do we do. Child trafficking is on the rise in India. Who knows where these children land up and what trauma they go through.
Any thoughts on what the government and citizens can do to halt this in the tracks.
Just in 2011 90,000 children went missing in India. The police force is a big problem as they do not like to write reports. Some ideas listed below. It may be valuable to develop on each of them. Perhaps this new government will be open to some.
  • Street children chapters in each town (especially vulnerable areas) - All linked so that communication is enabled
    Child issues have to be first response for the Police - missing children goes to top of list
    File missing child & person report online which goes to local thana as well as central repository to serve as an audit trail
    Bharat Nirman type of ads and campaigns in rural areas to educate about the consequences of selling children
    First response during natural calamities is to rescue children - traffickers hunt during natural calamities in Bihar because children are lost
    Safe havens across the country for children at any age - if a person cannot support child they abandon or sell but we need a third option
    Legalise prostitution - more on this later
    Fast track trafficking cases
    Increase trafficking penalties
    Have worthies like Gurus and Priests talk about this

Anything else. I will try and study and expound on each of these. It is pointless to talk about what is happening. One cannot sleep at night. It would be great if people could take each one of these on and make it happen. Perhaps we put a proposal together and submit to GOI or NGO

As a side note, parents selling their kids due to poverty are better off killing them with poison. Gentler death than at hands of these traffickers
Post Reply