

(opsss there is no dance smiley

The discussion was with respect to Para Infantry Battalions and not SF. A RMO in SF needs to do the above so that he becomes qualified to earn the Balidan Badge. A RMO being part of assault teams/sections/platoons in Para Bn. is a rarity and not par for the course.Gaur wrote: <SNIP> An AMC doctor who has cleared SF probation will be part of an assault team. What is so fancy about that?
The failure to get new artillery for IA is nothing short of criminal.ramana wrote:So the Solvakia gun barrel burst and they decided to cancel the Rheinmetal offer too? Are they serious or is this another pissful CBM?
I am sick and tired of us claiming to know more than the Army itself especially in this case!Marut wrote:^ Their ranks are honourary so no mandatory service. This is a PR exercise from the MOD to entice youth to join the forces.
For folks wondering about the Rao couple, please head over to the SF and the Misc pics dhaaga for some past discussions about them and other charlatans. Surya mullah will send me to reeducation camp for wasting bandwidth on these cretins if I post too much
Vik--> Quick post here. Have been put through seminars by this gentleman. I would take their claims with a pinch of salt. Would rather have the army play safe than risk controversy by associating with people who are perceived by a sizable chunk of the population as shady.I am sick and tired of us...I only wish that Prof Rao was given a higher rank than Dhoni as it seems he is directly involved in training the armed forces.
1. When someone promotes themselves excessively with liberal doses of hyperbole about such things, it makes this abdul suspicious.VikB wrote:I am sick and tired of us claiming to know more than the Army itself especially in this case!Marut wrote:^ Their ranks are honourary so no mandatory service. This is a PR exercise from the MOD to entice youth to join the forces.
For folks wondering about the Rao couple, please head over to the SF and the Misc pics dhaaga for some past discussions about them and other charlatans. Surya mullah will send me to reeducation camp for wasting bandwidth on these cretins if I post too much
Who are we to call the Rao couple as charlatans when the Army chief himself has decorated Dr Rao? Let us mind our language while talking about people who are doing much more than us who majorly only talk.
I only wish that Prof Rao was given a higher rank than Dhoni as it seems he is directly involved in training the armed forces.
India approves third set of two mountain divisions in its buildup against China. The first set of two was raised last year; approval for two more had been recently given, and now a third set of two has been cleared. Though the second and third pairs are under the 2012-2017 defense plan, which will start next year, its likely the new divisions will be raised well before 2017.
With this approval, Indian Army has obtained its minimum requirement against China. It actually wants a total of eleven new divisions, doubling the size of the force available against China.
The next step is up to China. We have said before that for absolutely no rational reason China has brought this Indian buildup on itself by pushing and pushing India in the north when India was perfectly content to mind its own business. China has to learn it may be the center of the Earth, if it mistreats neighbors there will be a reaction. If China now reacts by further provoking India, then those five extra divisions will happen. To begin with 15 large divisions facing Tibet is not exactly a joke, but twenty will be even more devoid of comedy.
Moreover, India deliberately misleads the world by talking of "mountain divisions", implying that its plains divisions cannot be used in the mountains. They very much can.
In addition to the six divisions raised or cleared, India has also cleared two mountain infantry and two armored brigade groups for the China border.
Sadly you are going to be more sick and tired thenI am sick and tired of us claiming to know more than the Army itself especially in this case!
Who are we to call the Rao couple as charlatans when the Army chief himself has decorated Dr Rao? Let us mind our language while talking about people who are doing much more than us who majorly only talk.
I only wish that Prof Rao was given a higher rank than Dhoni as it seems he is directly involved in training the armed forces.
Both armoured brigades are not in Ladakh I would assume?rohitvats wrote:From Orbat.Com:http://orbat.com/
India approves third set of two mountain divisions in its buildup against China. The first set of two was raised last year; approval for two more had been recently given, and now a third set of two has been cleared. Though the second and third pairs are under the 2012-2017 defense plan, which will start next year, its likely the new divisions will be raised well before 2017.
With this approval, Indian Army has obtained its minimum requirement against China. It actually wants a total of eleven new divisions, doubling the size of the force available against China.
The next step is up to China. We have said before that for absolutely no rational reason China has brought this Indian buildup on itself by pushing and pushing India in the north when India was perfectly content to mind its own business. China has to learn it may be the center of the Earth, if it mistreats neighbors there will be a reaction. If China now reacts by further provoking India, then those five extra divisions will happen. To begin with 15 large divisions facing Tibet is not exactly a joke, but twenty will be even more devoid of comedy.
Moreover, India deliberately misleads the world by talking of "mountain divisions", implying that its plains divisions cannot be used in the mountains. They very much can.
In addition to the six divisions raised or cleared, India has also cleared two mountain infantry and two armored brigade groups for the China border.
Yeah, while I appreciate Shiv Aroor for providing regular defence updates and pics, the people commenting in that blog are a really ignorant, arrogant and disrespectful bunch to put it most mildly. Sometimes, I read the comments just for the humour value. But most of the times, the comments end up spoiling the mood rather than providing any humour value.Singha wrote:livefist has new pix of marcos teams training in the andamans.
not the gadget heavy khan type unit, each lugging 50 li-on cells to power all that eqpt..but very light kit, very fit looking...
lots of comments by readers:
1. posture is not 'tactical' whatever that means
2. not looking menacing enough
3. no eyewear (presumably oakley will do onlee)
4. no MPs, just INSAS whining
5. some guys have no rucksack
6. send them for training in bering sea, andaman is too comfy
7. woolen face masks
There is tankable country in the extreme north, not very large by Ladakh standards but still large enough to deploy some tanks.rohitvats wrote:as per media reports, one is for ladakh and other is for sikkim. But from whatevdr i have seen of the geography ov sikkim, the real estate for deployment of armor is very limited. May be some areas in extreme north in the finger area.
Beyond a certain point in north Sikkim is the Tibetan plateau and it continues into TibetSingha wrote:on the contrary, RoyC sir was saying once you get past the chokepoints further south in central sikkim, north sikkim and adjoining vast area south of Lhasa is flat as a tabletop, without any blocking areas and ideal for armour.
dont just think of what is within our border as the playground. think tibet , chumbi valley etc.
+1. Not just the current GOI - all of them IMO. So that the next time 26/11 happens, they can claim the IA was not ready for war. They'd prefer that IA remains restricted as a "COIN-operated Army"merlin wrote: The failure to get new artillery for IA is nothing short of criminal.
I'm of the firm opinion that the current GoI intends to totally hobble the forces ability to fight - all part of pissful CBM and Nobel fishing onlee...
These 3 totally vague and utterly ambiguous points are supposed to be logical and objective points of argument? Your statements have no basis as yourMarut wrote:1. When someone promotes themselves excessively with liberal doses of hyperbole about such things, it makes this abdul suspicious.VikB wrote:I am sick and tired of us claiming to know more than the Army itself especially in this case! Who are we to call the Rao couple as charlatans when the Army chief himself has decorated Dr Rao? Let us mind our language while talking about people who are doing much more than us who majorly only talk.
I only wish that Prof Rao was given a higher rank than Dhoni as it seems he is directly involved in training the armed forces.
2. When more than a handful of people knowledgeable in this matter (not just this forum) make a similar assertion, the suspicion transforms into doubt.
3. When that someone claims to have trained the military all along for no compensation at all, then doubt becomes a certainty.
Interesting read:
Cold Start is Rawalpindi’s favorite bogeyman. But what is it? In the words of a cable released by Wikileaks, it is “a mixture of myth and reality.” As I argue in a forthcoming paper in the Journal of Strategic Studies, it tells us a little about the aspirations of Indian officers, but a lot about the fears — real, imagined and contrived — of their Pakistani counterparts.
:
That logic was tested in 2002. The militant group Lashkar-e-Taiba precipitated an international crisis by assaulting India’s Parliament. New Delhi rushed to respond. A million men were mobilized by both sides and India spent $2 billion. Eight hundred soldiers died in accidents and skirmishes — making the exercise deadlier than Kargil, an actual war. A year later, India slunk back, having extracted some desultory and quickly reversed promises by then-President Pervez Musharraf to curb terrorism.
The army, whose lower ranks were apoplectic at being held back, made a simple diagnosis. India had taken too long to move its ponderous strike corps from the country’s heartland to the front line. As the weeks passed, the international community built up a crescendo of calls for restraint, and the element of surprise was lost.
Moreover, this was still the army that had cut Pakistan in half in 1971. It was trained to thrust toward the Indus and throw the enemy off balance. But in the nuclear age, that sort of total victory was so reckless as to become impossible. Maj. Gen. D.K. Palit, one of the few soldier-scholars in the history of the Indian Army, once noted that wars between India and Pakistan resembled “communal riots with armor.” The challenge in the nuclear age was to keep them like that.
:
So the army had to become suppler, quicker to rise (hence “Cold Start”), nimbler on its feet, less of a hatchet and more of a scalpel. It was reorganized into eight so-called “battle groups,” modeled on old Israeli and Soviet formations. Each would punch into Pakistan at unpredictable points, but to a much shallower depth and therefore below the imagined nuclear threshold. Only if war could be limited, went this argument, could it be credibly threatened.
:
:
Talk of combat experience coming from someone who sits in front of a computer screen dropping smilies in a text box? What would you understand of combat experience that can rival that of not just COAS VK Singh but two other Army Chiefs before him? Questioning the capabilities of the senior-most Officer of the IA would amount to High Treason anywhere else, but of course you're hiding behind a computer screen in an internet forum which gives you diplomatic immunity to shoot your mouth off.Surya wrote: Sadly you are going to be more sick and tired then
simble question
What real combat experience do the Raos have??
Please educate us.
Take a deep breath and read againTalk of combat experience coming from someone who sits in front of a computer screen dropping smilies in a text box? What would you understand of combat experience that can rival that of not just COAS VK Singh but two other Army Chiefs before him? Questioning the capabilities of the senior-most Officer of the IA would amount to High Treason anywhere else, but of course you're hiding behind a computer screen in an internet forum which gives you diplomatic immunity to shoot your mouth off.
Anothing intelligent sounding bull sh*t.....if all that a Harvard Scholar and RUSI member do is pull references from articles written in indian dailies by DDM par excellence and come up with his own concoction of nonsense, then god save us.VinodTK wrote:The Mythology of Cold Start
I appreciate your sentiment but you chose the wrong door to enter BRF. Please let us know if you have a non free email domain to register. You are banned till then.fullmetaljacket wrote:Talk of combat experience coming from someone who sits in front of a computer screen dropping smilies in a text box? What would you understand of combat experience that can rival that of not just COAS VK Singh but two other Army Chiefs before him? Questioning the capabilities of the senior-most Officer of the IA would amount to High Treason anywhere else, but of course you're hiding behind a computer screen in an internet forum which gives you diplomatic immunity to shoot your mouth off.Surya wrote: Sadly you are going to be more sick and tired then
simble question
What real combat experience do the Raos have??
Please educate us.
Missile silos so close to the border( just 40 K.Ms)?The dragon is breathing down the neck where India is most vulnerable — part of the ancient silk route that connects the Ladakh region in the northern most part of Jammu and Kashmir to the bordering Xinjiang region in China.
The Indian defence establishment recently began counter-measures
after coming across intelligence that China had set up at least two missile storage facilities just across the line of actual control (LAC) in that area.
While New Delhi began building infrastructure in northern Ladakh, particularly at Daulat Beg Oldi on the old silk route, the intelligence on the missile site at Xaidulla came as a big surprise just three months ago.
The Indian Army has proposed deployment of short-range missiles, such as the BrahMos, along the LAC with the option of using the long-range ones also to act as a deterrent.
Satellite images showed 13 tunnels had been built at Xiadulla, an old base of the Chinese People’s Liberation Army of China, just 98 km from the Karakoram mountain pass between Ladakh and the Xinjiang Uyghur autonomous region.
Another missile facility has been located at Qizil Jilga, 40 km off the LAC in eastern Ladakh near the Western Tibet highway.