Varoon Shekhar wrote:http://ibnlive.in.com/news/devils-advoc ... 168-3.html
Not bad discussion at all, considering the group consists of Ramachandra Guha, Romila Thapar, Dipankar Gupta and host Karan Thapar. No attacks on or criticism of, Hindu groups or Hinduism. Question is posed as to why the US has been successful in preventing another major terrorist attack, while India has not.
I found the discussion dishonest for the most part. Yes, as they have emphasized, I myself have pointed out that most of India's ills including inability to thwart TSP sponsored terror can be traced back to lack of national cohesion and core sense of national identity as opposed to caste or linguistic, or in the case of many Muslims/Christians, religious identity.
But I found the participants either scared or slimy in pointing out why US has decimated terror, while India is a sitting duck. Note they were even coy to use the phrase "Isalmic terror". True to her role as a useful idiot, Romilla sticks to the colonial line: "9/11 was an act of global terrorism", "9/11 was a declaration of war on oh so poor innocent US", while terrorism against India (and our neighbor meaning TSP, so India & TSP are both victims of terror) is the result of specific "South Asian" grievances, the attacks are intended to send a message, and other patently false, disgusting nonsense.
What I came away after watching that show was that its becasue of ruling elite like those gathered who even shy away from honestly describing the terror threat India is confronted with, is the real reason why India is a sitting duck for TSPA/ISI, and why India could yet unravel as a result of such intellectual cowardice.