Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Locked
ChandraS

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ChandraS »

sum wrote:
India's first anti-terror university -- Surakha University.
Im guessing its a typo and its "Suraksha univ"

However, i have lost whatever respect i had for Modi....
~50 bombs being planted undetected is a monstrous failure whatever way one sees it, no matter what tough talk the administration makes...
Sum saar, please read this before you jump to your conclusions.

How Modi's police cracked the blasts case
.....
It is credit to Modi's determination and the Gujarat police's zeal, aided by the Intelligence Bureau's extraordinary efforts in giving relevant inputs to the state police, that this case could be cracked.
....
More than 11 teams were formed within the first few hours of the blasts. One team was asked to handle the investigations into the material used in the bombs. Another team was asked to investigate the use of bicycles. Another team was formed to thoroughly check all the phone calls made in Ahmedabad from certain areas just before and after the blasts. Another team was set up to reach out to all the police informers and gather their opinions on and information of the blasts. One team followed the cyber crime aspect of the case. The overall investigation of the case was assigned to the crime branch of Ahmedabad where more than 100 people started following whatever little leads that were available, from the midnight of July 26.

All of them were told that even if "communal riots (the possibility was always there) take place in Ahmedabad they should not divert their attention."
......
Now this shows that cops can crack the case if adequately supported by the politicos. Getting the politicos to support the cops to the hilt is a tricky thing. They will not do it unless their nuts are on the line. :evil: So now we have to figure out how to make their nuts be on the line all the time. :roll:

The above may not apply to Modi specifically, since these blasts were a slap across his face for his claims of total security and such during elections. I remember B Raman's article grading the diff CM's for security effort and NM scored a B- or C something. But this effort of cracking the case should get him an A- atleast. Hopefully the moves for a NS uty and all is not just some gimmick for public consumption. Time will tell...
Atish
BRFite
Posts: 417
Joined: 07 Jul 2000 11:31
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Atish »

Sindbad,

I am a trader too. will like to get in touch for professional reasons. Cant help you with the intelligence stuff. PM me if you can at atishbazi at gmail dotcom.

Cheers.
Atish.
ChandraS

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ChandraS »

satya wrote:...

7} Need intel on financial & commodity markets to be sure about moves tht other players are making very imp. to protect the Indian economy from nasty surprises . So far all the info tht GoI receive in this fiel are from secondary sources . Need to develop primary sources in this vital field .
I wholly second that. My father is a financial consultant and in the 90's worked a lot with the EOW of Mumbai police. His views were pretty much the same. There is no institutional setup to monitor and counter manipulations in the fin sector. Most of the efforts are in reaction to any events. Recently, there was an announcement of a FIU being setup. But their charter seems to be mainly money laundering and such FIU-Functions. There is no single agency with a clear mandate to monitor the financial sector and commodities market to guard against a Soros type crash of the 90's in the Asian markets. We already have diff agencies - EIU, DRI and now FIU. I am too confused by these variants of the alphabet soup...and the unavoidable turf wars they bring with them. :roll:
Sontu
BRFite
Posts: 103
Joined: 06 Aug 2008 19:32

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Sontu »

The first and foremost....we need people in our RAW or IB or NTRO or ..or..or..

Who has at least following personal qualities…

1. Has a fantasy for the job (loves the JOB not MONEY).
2. Has high degree of love/patriotism for the country.
3. Just wants job to be done, not expects any publicity ( his name to be published in paper or forums).
4. Is intelligent and have very good observation capability using all his senses.
5. A good team leader and planner.
6. High degree of dedication & moral sense.
7. Does the job with perfection and leaves no stone un-turned to accomplish the objective.

If we can flood these organizations with this kind of people..then only we can expect something can be done...provided political people allow these organizations to work autonomously without interfering in their matters..(Which is impossible in India, :-) )
ASPuar
BRFite
Posts: 1538
Joined: 07 Feb 2001 12:31
Location: Republic of India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ASPuar »

***Flash - All BR Members***

If you are interested, last Sundays Hindustan Times carried an ad calling for Research Officers in R&AW. Euphemistically termed "Research Officers" for the "Cabinet Secretariat".

Feel free to apply, any one who is interested.
There is no reservation for these posts, BTW, so they are all open category.
ramana
Forum Moderator
Posts: 59810
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ramana »

From Satya's post above

That began to change in Iraq, where a lot of the debriefing got automated, and even the smallest infantry patrol, could easily report their findings electronically. By capturing the data electronically at the lowest level, and building database tools to handle it, information did not expire (as battlefield information tends to quickly do).
With lots more fresh battlefield data available, it was now possible to do things that, only a few years earlier, were believed the province of much larger, and better funded, organizations.
For example, there is data fusion. This is collecting intelligence from many sources, and sorting through it for useful patterns and items that, in seen in the right context, are very valuable. The first of these fusion centers were set up at the national level two decades ago. But during the course of the Iraq war, the concept moved down the food chain. Cheaper, and more powerful, computer hardware was able to use analysis software to speed the fusion process, even in the hands of a relatively inexperienced operator. (MAACs in Indian Context )
Some of the most effective intelligence tools used in combat today, data mining and predictive analysis, were invented a century ago along with the development of junk mail. Who knew? For decades, the statistical tools used to determine who to send junk mail to (so the sender would make a profit) were not much use to the military. Then came cheaper, and more powerful computers, and the development of data mining and analysis tools. This made a big difference, because the more data you have to work with, the easier it is to predict things. This has been known for centuries.
Now, with thousand dollar laptop computers equipped with hundred gigabyte (or more) hard drives, you can put large amounts of data in one place, do the calculations, and make accurate predictions. This wasn't possible thirty years ago, when a 75 megabyte hard drive cost $45,000, and the computer doing the calculations cost even more than that. You also didn't have digital photography (more data you can store for analysis), or a lot of data, in general, stored electronically. It's all different today. That hundred gigabyte hard drive (holding over a thousand times more data than the $45,000 one of yore) costs less than a hundred bucks.

In the last few years, intel analysts have realized how powerful their tools are. And for those who studied math, statistics or business in college, they know the power of data mining, because it has become a very popular business tool. In places like Iraq and Afghanistan, lots of data is being collected all the time. It was data mining that led to the capture of Saddam, and the death of Zarqawi. Actually, over a hundred senior (team leader and up) al Qaeda terrorists have been killed or captured in Iraq using these techniques.
Data mining is basically simple in concept. In any large body of data, you will find patterns. Even if the bad guys are trying to avoid establishing a pattern to their actions, they will anyway. It's human nature, and only the most attentive pros can avoid this trap. Some trends are more reliable than others, but any trend at all can be useful in combat. The predictive analysis carried out with data mining and other analytic tools has saved the lives of hundreds of U.S. troops, by giving them warning of where roadside bombs and ambushes are likely to be, or where the bad guys are hiding out. Similarly, when data was taken off the site of the Zarqawi bombing, it often consisted only of names, addresses and other tidbits. But with the vast databases of names, addresses and such already available, typing in each item began to generate additional information, within minutes. That's why, within hours, the trove of data generated dozens of raids, and even more leads.
Speed has always been an advantage in combat, but, until recently, rarely something intelligence analysis was noted for. No longer. Predictive analysis is something the troops depend on, not only to tips on what to avoid, but for names and places to go after.
I think the Indian police should also go in for massive computerization. There are so many sundry leads and a variety of spellings and Abu this and Abu that, it becomes difficult to keep track of these folks.

The good thing is MKN is supposed to have introduced computers while he was IB chief per MK Dhar. Maybe he can do the same now at field level and have them send in the reports to the local data centers.
ramana
Forum Moderator
Posts: 59810
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ramana »

ASPuar
BRFite
Posts: 1538
Joined: 07 Feb 2001 12:31
Location: Republic of India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ASPuar »

ramana wrote:Sad story
Press Release from PIB

The sadness in the story lies not in the behaviour of the officer concerned. But in the response of the establishment.

If an officer in a very responsible position becomes mentally unbalanced, the organisation must express its regret, it must do its utmost to see that the officer and her family receive the best possible care, and it must close ranks to see that she gets the help that she needs. But she must be removed from her very sensitive post!

But the organisation, seems to have become mentally unbalanced itself, and started imagining that the best way to deal with these things is to ignore them!
Mandeep
BRFite
Posts: 186
Joined: 15 Jun 2000 11:31
Location: Chandigarh, UT, INDIA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Mandeep »

The Nisha Bhatia case and the allegations levelled by her against senior officials must not be swept under the carpet or brushed away. They must be inquired into by an impartial authority.

There's more here than meets the eye.
ASPuar
BRFite
Posts: 1538
Joined: 07 Feb 2001 12:31
Location: Republic of India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ASPuar »

It appears from news reports that an enquiry was indeed made into the accusations. The committe was composed of the deputy NSA, a lady, and two other lady officers. It seems that it turned nothing up? It also seems that this officer does not wish to communicate with any enquiry committee... why not? How will an enquiry be instituted without her cooperation?

Of course, news reports can be manipulated... I wonder what else lies under the plaster?
Mandeep
BRFite
Posts: 186
Joined: 15 Jun 2000 11:31
Location: Chandigarh, UT, INDIA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Mandeep »

More than news reports its govt enquiries that seem to be manipulated.You just can't beat the system ! But I do hope Nisha Bhatia gets justice and those responsible for harassing her, their just desserts.
manjgu
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2615
Joined: 11 Aug 2006 10:33

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by manjgu »

a) nisha is not unbalanced or mentally unsound but there is more than we will ever know
b) i personally know one of the officers implicated by her and can safely say that i was shocked since the gentlemen in question is a very very fine man / officer .. i know his family etc etc.. he is a man of utmost integrity , DARING and patrotic .. never heard him utter anything wrong ever... very honest and upright .. lives very very simply in a DDA flat.
can never beleive that he said all that Nisha ji is saying on TV. just cant believe...
Mandeep
BRFite
Posts: 186
Joined: 15 Jun 2000 11:31
Location: Chandigarh, UT, INDIA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Mandeep »

There are depths to a person which those around him can never plumb.However to be fair to everyone, there must be a free and impartial enquiry conducted by a panel of unimpeachable integrity.
Inder Sharma
BRFite
Posts: 135
Joined: 18 May 2006 14:35

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Inder Sharma »

ASPuar wrote:***Flash - All BR Members***

If you are interested, last Sundays Hindustan Times carried an ad calling for Research Officers in R&AW. Euphemistically termed "Research Officers" for the "Cabinet Secretariat".

Feel free to apply, any one who is interested.
There is no reservation for these posts, BTW, so they are all open category.
Saar, dont have that edition with me. Could you please publish more detail and the wherewithal for application onlee.

thanks!
ASPuar
BRFite
Posts: 1538
Joined: 07 Feb 2001 12:31
Location: Republic of India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ASPuar »

@RahulM: I'll root around and do what I can!
shyamd
BRF Oldie
Posts: 7101
Joined: 08 Aug 2006 18:43

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by shyamd »

Indian Spy Agency Hit by Scandal Over Attempted Suicide by Sexually Harassed Director
The attempted suicide by a female officer at India's external intelligence agency, the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW), on Tuesday was more than a cry for help, and it has uncovered a dark and murky web of corruption and deceit that goes to the core of the spy agency she works for.

Nisha Bhatia, a director at the spy agency involved in external affairs, tried to kill herself by consuming rat poison right outside the Prime Minister's Office. It appears this was the final act of a desperate person who was not being allowed to register a complaint at the office regarding her allegations of sexual harassment by senior male colleagues.


As Bhatia was recuperating in hospital, Ashok Chaturvedi, the scandal-prone head of RAW, immediately and mercilessly began a campaign to besmirch her reputation by alleging that she is "mentally unstable."


In addition, the RAW chief claimed -- without offering any factual evidence -- that Bhatia, a mother of two daughters, only alleged sexual harassment because she was angling for a foreign posting.


It is troubling that the head of a premier intelligence agency would publicly and systematically try to dismantle the career and character of one of the few senior, and competent, female officers at RAW.


Bhatia has a Masters degree in Mathematics from the prestigious St. Stephens College in New Delhi and is regarded as a person of substance. This is in contradiction to the image Chaturvedi has tried to portray of her.


On the contrary, as has been witnessed by a number of observers, the RAW chief's own mental state is more in question at this stage.


In early July, Bhatia had written to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh citing in detail a litany of sexual harassment occurrences she faced from Chaturvedi's clique in RAW. In that letter she warned she would take her own life in front of the Prime Minister's Office if the harassment continued.


Tragically, her words proved to come true. Bhatia's actions were not on impulse or the result of a psychotic state, but expressed a desperate plea for help by a woman surrounded by predatory male colleagues seeking to take advantage of her.


Congress Party insiders have revealed that privately party president Sonia Gandhi is deeply incensed by the treatment of Bhatia.


Importantly, the minister of state for women and child development, Renuka Choudhary, publicly extended her support to Bhatia and condemned RAW over the issue. Further, she said that her ministry would seek an explanation from the intelligence agency in connection with the suicide bid and allegations leveled by Bhatia.


There are plans now to institute a high level inquiry into the issue which will either be handled by the Supreme Court or the Prime Minister's Office.


Sexual harassment in the workplace is a common theme in India as more women are taking up jobs in the commercial and industrial sectors as the country's economy continues to grow to record levels. There are also greater numbers of women joining governmental organizations.


Because of the growing number of sexual harassment cases, most large companies and governmental organizations have set-up units specifically to deal with these types of complaints. The Indian Supreme Court itself states that all places of work should have units that deal with sexual harassment issues.


However, RAW has no established recourse for anyone who is being targeted by colleagues, say sources familiar with the culture.


Bhatia was formerly married to an officer who worked with the Indian Administrative Service. Their marriage broke down after he physically assaulted her.


But Bhatia's real problems began after her divorce. In India, divorced women are often targets for sexual harassment by men who prey upon them in the workplace because they are seen as vulnerable.


Bhatia is currently posted at RAW's training center in Gurgaon, just outside New Delhi.


When she was stationed at the agency's central headquarters on Lodhi Road, she rejected alleged repeated sexual advances from a senior colleague, Sunil Uke, a Customs officer on deputation to RAW, who had the rank of joint secretary.


On Aug. 3, 2007, Bhatia alleges that Uke offered her around $700 to spend a night with him in a hotel using money he would withdraw from funds belonging to the organization.


Bhatia initially complained to Uke's immediate superior, Sanjiv Tripathi, Chaturvedi's close friend, protégé and potential successor. But Tripathi dismissed her claims out of hand.


Had he handled the issues with more sensitivity, perhaps the situation would not have spiraled out of control as it has today.


As reported by the Middle East Times on Feb. 6, she had also made a complaint against Chaturvedi who she said did not treat her grievance with any seriousness. He stated: "I don't want to be disturbed by such nonsense."


The RAW chief is known for being insensitive about gender issues. In fact he downgraded her performance assessment in the Annual Confidential Reports. Tripathi then tried to drive her out of the agency all together.


While recuperating in hospital after her failed suicide bid, Bhatia calmly and with lucidity gave further details about her discussions with Chaturvedi. She alleges that he called her a "good looking girl" and that she should "find another man." Her apparent ease in talking to the media without any histrionics also suggests that she is not insane or suffering from any mental problems.


Bhatia had given copies of her complaint and discussed it with National Security Advisor M.K. Narayanan and Cabinet Secretary K.M. Chandrasekhar. During these meetings, she expressed an intention to resign but was persuaded not to on the assurance that an independent inquiry would be conducted.


However, Chaturvedi strongly favored the immediate dismissal of Bhatia for being, in his opinion, "mentally unstable" and creating "problems," but was overruled by Narayanan until a full investigation was conducted as he did not want RAW to be shrouded in more controversy.


Had Chaturvedi's policy been implemented, it would have resulted in a massive controversy over an officer being victimized without an inquiry.


A committee headed by Leela Ponappa, the deputy national security advisor, released a questionable report in May that found Bhatia to be emotionally traumatized and recommended counseling while rejecting her harassment charges. Also, no punishment was to be leveled against Uke.


After the committee's report, Chaturvedi started disciplinary proceedings against Bhatia for alleged misconduct, which was to have started the day she attempted suicide.


The claim that she refused to attend its proceedings carries a number of flaws.


According to a senior government official source, the RAW inquiry was never going to be fair but was "rigged" and Bhatia would not be given "proper representation."


The source added that Bhatia would have been "exposed to a pack of wolves."


In addition, the inquiry ignored a key and important fact that Bhatia had become a common victim and was also the target of other senior RAW colleagues.


What was of particular concern was the fact that the charge sheet against her was not written on any paper, it was all verbal and therefore lacked any credibility.



The Bhatia tragedy forms part of a long list of problems that lie at the door of Chaturvedi. His flagitious handling of RAW has seen the spy agency lose its way.


The paralysis which has hit the organization could not have come at a worse time. Western intelligence agencies have become increasingly, if belatedly, disillusioned with the intelligence agency, the ISI, in neighboring Pakistan and greater dependence on RAW was planned. And in particular with direct input on the security situation in Afghanistan, Pakistan, and the war in terror in general, all of which are key priorities for New Delhi.


With Chaturvedi still at the helm that won't happen.


Despite being described by analysts as a walking talking disaster, Chaturvedi has managed to keep his position. According to a source in the Prime Minister's Office, "In any other county Chaturvedi would have…. [lost his job]"


There is an unwritten rule within the political establishment to avoid publicly criticizing the head of an intelligence agency for fear it would bring ridicule and humiliation to the organization.


There are persistent rumors that Chaturvedi, who is due to retire next Jan. 31, is seeking an extension that would see him continue as RAW chief until India's 2009 general elections. This would give him a chance to try to secure Tripathi as the next head of RAW.


This though appears to be highly unlikely. The Congress-led coalition is keen to avoid repeating the same costly mistake by making sure Chaturvedi's successor is able to repair the damage and bitterness that has been created.


Since Chaturvedi became RAW chief on Feb. 1, 2007, the intelligence agency has suffered a scandal virtually every three months. The Bhatia tragedy is the latest, but most damaging.


Bhatia was a woman driven by desperation to the extent that she attempted suicide. To date no action has been taken against those who hounded and persecuted her. It appears that people want to avoid asking the tough questions.


Sadly, Bhatia has become the latest public, and humiliated, example of what many Indian women are having to endure in the workplace. However, her case has attracted the attention of the world's media and international women's rights organizations and consequently will not be forgotten.


Particularly so as a general election is due next year and both the Congress-led government and the opposition Bharatiya Janata Party, are acutely aware that 55 percent of the electorate are women. To alienate them to protect Chaturvedi and his coterie of supporters would be a price not worth paying.
Baljeet
BRFite
Posts: 410
Joined: 29 May 2007 04:16

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Baljeet »

Mandeep wrote:The Nisha Bhatia case and the allegations levelled by her against senior officials must not be swept under the carpet or brushed away. They must be inquired into by an impartial authority.

There's more here than meets the eye.
Mandeep
Are we that cynical we can't believe anything anymore. What has establishment done wrong in this case they gave her every opportunity to present her case, sent for psychiatric evaluation, she was recommended for further evaluation, all laid out procedures were followed. Ever thought that sexual harrassment case is the easiest to be filed, even if the allegations are baseless, the onus is on the defendant to prove his innocence. She threatened the establishment of consequences, doesn't that tell you she has gone crazy. Why is she writing a letter to PM, for heaven's sake PM has more things on his plate that are more important. Every Joshi, Tiwari, Sharma threatens to write a letter to PM. It is typical Old wine in new bottle kinda thing, In 70's and 80's every goon politcian who didn't get pampered would ask for PM Resignation for everything under the sun.
Is it possible that Sexual harrassment is used by Bharat ki Sati Savitri for their financial and career gains. Sooner we realize that and place checks and balances, sooner we can all get along and focus on the task in hand.

No wonder RAW can't do her job, this agency is busy trying to keep her house in order there is no time for doing the real work.
Sontu
BRFite
Posts: 103
Joined: 06 Aug 2008 19:32

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Sontu »

This issue will now hold any lady..who wish to make her career in RAW as analyst and she possibly will need to give a second thought about joining the same.

I think that women are less prone to corruption apart from being more dedicated and reliable for this kind of job in India, They should be encoureged to join RAW and IB. But this kind of issues are going to have adverse effect in meeting that objective.
Last edited by Sontu on 22 Aug 2008 00:04, edited 1 time in total.
Rahul M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 17169
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 21:09
Location: Skies over BRFATA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rahul M »

ASPuar wrote:@RahulM: I'll root around and do what I can!
thanks a lot ! :)
Paul
BRF Oldie
Posts: 3801
Joined: 25 Jun 1999 11:31

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Paul »

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Border chars remain out of security radar
R Dutta Choudhury
GUWAHATI, Aug 21 – Though police and security agencies issue warning on the possible threats from Bangladesh-based fundamentalist forces including the Harkat-ul Jehadi Islami (HUJI) from time to time, the measures taken so far to deal with the threat raised doubts on whether the Government is really sincere in dealing with the problem. The char areas, particularly those located near the international border, are considered most vulnerable from the security point of view as anyone who manages to sneak in from Bangladesh by taking advantage of the porous border can always take shelter there before moving to other parts of the State, but unfortunately, till date, the State Government has not been able to increase security presence in those areas and the river police force has also not been strengthened either to improve vigil along the riverine international border or to keep a watch on the chars.

Highly placed official sources admitted here that the police or security forces have very little presence on the chars, particularly those located along the international border with Bangladesh to ensure that persons inimical to India manages to take shelter in those. The river police force does not have adequate manpower or required infrastructure including boats to keep a watch on the chars and till date no one knows whether any person inimical to India have taken shelter there with a view to create disturbance. Most of the posts of the river police force are lying vacant and the force has to depend mostly on hired boats whenever any crime is reported and there is hardly any patrolling by the personnel of the force along the international riverine border. Sources admitted that a proposal for establishing 19 new police stations of the river police force is pending with the Government, while, proposals have been forwarded to the Government for procuring speed boats for the force under the police modernization scheme.

Giving an example of the present state of affairs, official sources pointed out that Dhubri district having long international border with Bangladesh has more than 40 kilometres of riverine border, but no police station of outpost of the river police is now functioning in the district. Of course proposal for opening of police stations and outposts are now pending with the Government.

Sources pointed out that the district has more than 400 registered chars, some of which are right on the international border. In fact, the international boundary bifurcates a few of the chars. Though the Border Security Force (BSF) has its BOPs in some of the chars located along the international border, the main duty of the border guarding force is not maintenance of law and order but to check infiltration of foreign nationals. There is urgent need for setting up of police stations and outposts of the river police force in the district to keep a close watch on the chars, but that has not been done, leaving the chars vulnerable.

Sources revealed that at present only three police outposts are operating in the chars. These are located at Bondihana char, Fakirganj char and Sukhchar and each of the outposts has been provided with one engine fitted country boat. However, it is only semblance of police presence on the chars and majority of the chars are left unguarded. The personnel posted in the outposts can at best keep an eye on the other chars in the vicinity and no one knows what is going on in others. There are chars where polling parties start moving ahead two days ahead of any election and there is hardly any presence of either police or administration in those. Interestingly, there have been instances when police came to know about any crime in the chars in isolated areas only few days after the incidents and whenever any crime is reported from any char in remote places, the police first has to hire a boat to reach the spot of crime. Under the circumstance, it is very easy for anyone with ulterior motive to take shelter in the chars along the international border. Moreover, the mobile phone network of telephone companies of Bangladesh, particularly of the Grameen phone, is easily available in the Indian side of the border, which also posted a security threat.

Of course it will not be possible to set up police pickets in all the chars, but efforts should be made for deployment of forces in the strategically located chars, which are of permanent nature.

It may be mentioned here that from time to time, the police and intelligence agencies come across reports of attempts of fundamentalist forces including the HUJI to create disturbance in the State and just before the Independence Day, all the district police forces were alerted of such a threat. Fundamentalist forces also planned another attack near the Guwahati Railway station in July 2006 but that was foiled as the police came to know of the game plan.
sum
BRF Oldie
Posts: 10195
Joined: 08 May 2007 17:04
Location: (IT-vity && DRDO) nagar

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by sum »

Any article about the situation in BD-WB border awlways gives me the jeepers-creepers....

It seems to be a time bomb waiting to explode.
Philip
BRF Oldie
Posts: 21538
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Philip »

Why the Allies won the war.They knew,thanks to Bletchley Park/ULTRA,every secret German communication thanks to the fact that they had broken the German codes.Montgomery was able to win the battle of Alamein because of it,so also was the "War of the Atlantic" against German U-boats won thanks to ULTRA.Armed with such knowledge germany was lost.Indian intel agencies/ABV also threw away a priceless asset when they revealed how they had broken Pak's military communications,intercepting Mushy's conversations with his generals.In WW2,Churchill at times allowed for military setbacks and large loss of life rather than prevent ULTRA's secrets from being exposed.He lost the small battles and fooled the Germans in order to win the biggest and most important

As with the case of the Soviets,we probably will have to wait for another 20 years before being able to do so again.The crying need of the hour is for the setting up of our own equivalent of the NSA,totally independent from R&AW,etc.The technological advances in telecom and the abuse of such technology by the enemy/terrorists ,makes it imperative that a specialised agency that has all the requisite asets,dedicated satellites,etc.etc.plus the human resources like those at Bletchley and India has its share of mathematical geniuses who wopuld rise to the task,to give any govt. of the day that crucial advantage-hard intelligence of the enemy's thought and intentions in order that we might counter them.

Bletchley Park: a fitting memorial to our enigmatic nature
Dramatic work was done there, but it wouldn't have without two great British traits - secrecy and eccentricityBen Macintyre
The campaign to save Bletchley Park, the wartime codebreaking centre, is gathering pace. Last month 97 academics and scientists wrote to this newspaper calling for the site to become a national museum of computing, in recognition of the pioneering work carried out there in the Second World War. Thousands have signed a petition urging the Government to restore the building and rotting wooden huts where Hitler's supposedly unbreakable codes were unravelled.

The campaign has tended to focus on the scientific advances, the cracking of the Enigma Code and the role of the codebreakers in hastening the end of the war. Yet Bletchley Park also stands as a monument to two often undervalued aspects of the British character - secrecy and eccentricity.

The intelligence gathered there was, simply, the best-kept secret in history, and it was created and preserved by some remarkable, and remarkably unconventional, people. The Park should be preserved as a memorial to scientific and military ingenuity, but also to the triumph of discretion and human oddity, two vital British traits that have decayed along with Bletchley Park over the past half century.

Sigmund Freud wrote: “He that has eyes to see and ears to hear may convince himself that no mortal can keep a secret.” Britain's wartime codebreakers proved him wrong. Some 10,000 people worked at Bletchley Park, codenamed “Station X”. Several thousand more were privy to the intelligence gleaned from breaking the Enigma Code, codenamed “Ultra”.

Background
Bletchley Park is ‘hallowed ground’
Decoding the mystery of Bletchley Park
Enigma and the Ruthless plot
A family day out in the name of science
For 30 years after the war, those achievements remained a secret protected by an almost sacred vow of silence. Many who worked at Bletchley Park, from senior cryptanalysts to teamakers, went to the grave without telling friends or family what they had done. Even today, when most of the documentary evidence has been declassified, some of the surviving codebreakers remain reticent, uncomfortable with discussing matters so long held in deepest trust.

The Bletchley Park cryptanalysts were, in Churchill's words, “the geese that laid the golden eggs, and never cackled”. Churchill knew from personal experience the dangers of cackling: in 1923, he was a member of the Cabinet that authorised revealing the coded contents of intercepted Soviet messages, thus compromising Britain's most important intelligence source. Moscow, alerted to the breach, switched to a new cipher system; for 20 years Britain was unable to read any secret Soviet communications.

To protect the Enigma secret in wartime was challenging enough; to preserve it for three decades after was little short of miraculous. An MI6 report immediately after the war, recently declassified, was adamant: “It will be hard for those who worked on Ultra to avoid hinting at what they did in the war. But avoid it they must.” And avoid it they did. Even after the Government finally gave them leave to cackle, many preferred silence.

In an age when a “secret” is something told to one person at a time, when bean-spilling represents a pension plan for almost anyone connected to government, from the Prime Minister's wife to the head of MI5, that seems almost unthinkable. Today's culture is confessional and immodest: nothing remains hidden for long, least of all success. But for the wartime generation, schooled in the belief that careless talk cost lives, there was nothing strange in keeping secrets, even from the closest friends and family.

The British are a naturally clubby race, and for many who worked in Bletchley Park, membership of the most exclusive elite was satisfaction enough. That is why the British make such good spies, but also such effective double agents and moles.

If secrecy was one key to success, eccentricity was another. There might have been no secret to keep had not intelligence chiefs understood the military value of the inspired misfit. The mathematicians, linguists, technicians, classicists, crossword buffs, cryptanalysts, chess champions and other boffins were, collectively, quite brilliant, the brightest and the best; many were also quite peculiar.

Even in an age when eccentricity was more tolerated, two stand out. Dilwyn “Dilly” Knox was a classical papyrus expert from Cambridge who pioneered the Enigma analysis. He often worked in his pyjamas, smoking a large pipe, into which he occasionally stuffed his sandwiches by mistake. He recruited only women to help, and only tall ones. A keen and spectacularly dangerous driver, he invented a pseudo-mathematical equation to defend his speeding. After one excursion in the lanes around Bletchley Park he remarked happily: “It's amazing how people smile and apologise to you when you knock them over.”

Still more remarkable was Alan Turing, the mathematician and logician who developed the electromagnetic bombe used to decipher Enigma messages. Shabbily dressed, notoriously absent-minded, Turing was a homosexual, a marathon runner, a loner and a genius. He cycled around in a gas mask because of his allergies, and chained his teacup to a radiator to deter thieves.

When this unlikely assortment of code-breakers arrived at Bletchley Park, locals were told they were “Colonel Ridley's shooting party”.

It is impossible to imagine any government department employing such a strange collection today, yet the rampant individualism at Bletchley Park was part of its success. Like the façade of the building itself, the codebreaking team was an idiosyncratic mixture, but left alone they experimented in directions that more conventional thinkers would never have taken.

Bletchley Park should be saved for the nation, not just in recognition of its wartime role, but also as a wider memorial to a sort of Britishness that would also benefit from restoration - discreet, modest, intellectually indomitable and heroically different.

Have your say

Yes, its a wonder that the 'Elf N Safety' Goblins and others of that ilk have not been in to close the place down as being 'Inconducive to New Labour's view of 21st Century Multi-cultural Britian'. Maybe the playing of Bagpies and Morris Dancing will be scrutinesed by these self appointed fools!

B Clark, Chelmsford, England UK

Yes this would be just impossible in today's wonerful world. The whole project would be squashed flat bt the grey men demanding "business cases", "method statements" and "safety assesments"

Ian, London,
sum
BRF Oldie
Posts: 10195
Joined: 08 May 2007 17:04
Location: (IT-vity && DRDO) nagar

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by sum »

The crying need of the hour is for the setting up of our own equivalent of the NSA,totally independent from R&AW,etc.The technological advances in telecom and the abuse of such technology by the enemy/terrorists ,makes it imperative that a specialised agency that has all the requisite asets,dedicated satellites,etc.etc.plus the human resources like those at Bletchley and India has its share of mathematical geniuses who wopuld rise to the task,to give any govt. of the day that crucial advantage-hard intelligence of the enemy's thought and intentions in order that we might counter them.
We did try/are trying that with the NTRO but it seems to be caught up the usual turf wars which Indian agencies seem to love!!! :roll:
satya
BRFite
Posts: 718
Joined: 19 Jan 2005 03:09

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by satya »

NSA in US complements the intel capabilities of other intel agencies and is not an exclusive provider of techint . Initially when NTRO was suggested as per my understanding it was suppose to bring in fresh start and again provide an extra source of techint to other agencies but somehow this idea was moulded and was presented as a long term cost saving idea where all the techint is gathered by a single agency . Think for a second , type of tech-intel required by Defence forces varies from one required by Home Ministry and economic related ministries . It will be a nightmare pm NTRO staff ,either NTRO will have specialists for each field ( if so why u create a new agency ? )

Agreed MACCS are a good proposition but only at regional levels not at very ground/field levels where each intel agency work under its own charter and way and cant really adjust to others ways .

IB has some good set up to monitor internet in India now if NTRO gets its hands on it ,we will need Joint field offices of various agencies at ground zero ( espionage by foreign agencies will become easy as even one of their mole inside can provide them intel from other intel agencies as well !) so intel can be made available in real time without delays tht will mean other than different name , all these NTRO staff will be actively working under existing Intel agencies , is this the purpose we want for this new super techint agency ? or alternatively will NTRO staff will seek permission of their superiors ?

No wonder RAW & IB not too happy to part with their techint assets .
Philip
BRF Oldie
Posts: 21538
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Philip »

It is precisely to avoid these turf wars and the fact that there are glaring loopholes and flaws in our current setup-just look at the state of security at the moment,that a different outfit for all tech garnering methods is needed.The R&AW and the IB rely upon humint to a great deal,which is essential for penetrating terrorist/foreign networks,which requires a huge amount of fieldwork.There would be no problem to have the two outfits responsible for internal and external security to have (real time) access to the equiv of the NSA.Britain has its GCHQ too.

As for the current mess we are in,here is a scathing indictment on the performance or rather lack of it of our NSA honcho,"Mike",MK Narayanan,who Outlook earlier claimed,spent months "lobbying" in secret hideouts MPs for the N-deal vote.MIke's performance and that of our Home Minister,"what's-his-name?" (as no one knows if he exists at all!) has been so disgraceful that by remainign in their seats,they add insult to the injury that our enemies have caused us.Their indifference to our fate is inexcusable.

http://www.newindpress.com/newspages.as ... in+Article&
Mike misses the big party
Saturday August 23 2008 02:22 IST
Aditya Sinha

We assume our nation is in the hands of the wise, the balanced, the judicious, the magnanimous, and the visionary. Instead,we find ourselves at the mercy of luminaries like the National Security Advisor, M K “Mike” Narayanan. No wonder that there are parts of our nation intent on tearing themselves apart.

Though Mike has so far escaped the opprobrium that commentators have heaped on Shivraj Patil (one called him Minister for Rome Affairs, so easy a target is he), this column cannot help but commiserate with Mike. Because of a bunch of damn protestors in Srinagar and in Jammu, he has had to miss out on the jamboree in Vienna,where India’s top minds were trying to convince the 45-member nuclear suppliers’ cartel to allow India to do nuclear commerce.

For Mike, the nuclear deal has been one long party. He got to travel the world, rub shoulders with the Americans, and soak in the limelight in Washington DC, Vienna, Singapore, and other world capitals — all the while trying to make the case for allowing India to inhabit an existential twilight zone where it would become the not-fullybut- only-sort-of-declared-yet-still-non-proliferating nuclear state.

As he has been dealing with an issue involving the ultimate currency of human power, you can’t blame Mike for feeling a bit like Major “King” Kong, the air commander who straddles a nuclear warhead as it is launched at the climax of Stanley Kubrick’s Dr Strangelove or:How I learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb. You can just picture Mike, a big missile between his legs, humming to himself: They like me in London/ They love me in Berlin/They hugged me in Moscow/And also in Beijing. It’s a heady thing.

It’s not surprising then that Mike does not have time for Kashmir, for Maoists, for Islamist terrorists, or even for the former Pakistan President, Pervez Musharraf. (Come to think of it, even Mike’s boss doesn’t seem to have time for anything besides the nuclear deal. Come to think of it, who IS his boss — benefactor Sonia Gandhi or Prime Minister Manmohan Singh? Things are so murky, no wonder Mike prefers to hang out in Vienna rather than in the Valley.) The irony is that Mike, the only person to twice serve as the Intelligence Bureau’s chief, doesn’t even have time for India’s intelligence community.

No wonder, then, that one of our spies tried to kill herself. Nisha Bhatia of the Research and Analysis Wing had complained about a senior officer offering her money for sex (he was probably trying to exploit the fact she is a divorcée with children). At one point, Mike ordered an inquiry into her charges. After all, the accused had a history of complaints against him; he was thrown out of the RAW and sent back to his state cadre. Yet Mike is a busy man, with little time for the grinding wheels of justice; Nisha lost confidence in the panel and was “erratic” in her evidence, and she took the extreme step. The RAW’s response was to sack her. It has been a near-tragedy that Mike has no time for.

Things have been no better at the strategic intelligence agency itself,where the current chief, Ashok Chaturvedi, is a universally proclaimed dimwit. A couple of years ago, he was superseded by some good officers because he was seen as a potential liability. When Mike became NSA, he wanted to clean up the spy agency. He brought in a new chief, P K Hormese Tharakan, over the heads of long-serving, competent officers, one of whom took early retirement. Tharakan served out his term, the RAW remained as useless as ever, and then Mike played his master-stroke: he elevated Chaturvedi to the top job. This inexplicable move would not be so bad if, for the past four months,word had not spread that one of the IB’s best officers,Kashmir-specialist N Sandhu, was going to be the new RAW chief; not only has it not come to pass, but it has left the RAW, the IB, and even Sandhu, completely irritated.

One could argue that these are merely administrative matters, and that the real issue is Kashmir. It has been over four years since the UPA took power, and what has Mike done vis-à-vis Kashmir? For comparison, just look at the bad news, anti-Muslim BJP: as prime minister, A B Vajpayee made several gestures towards a political settlement, including a famous handshake offer in Srinagar to Pakistan; even his deputy L K Advani had two back-slappingly cordial meetings with the moderate wing of the separatist All Parties Hurriyat Conference.

In addition, the Americans had leaned heavily on Musharraf to seal a deal with India on Kashmir. Musharraf was the first Pakistani head of government to openly state that borders could not be redrawn; Musharraf repeatedly called for “out-of-the-box” solutions; Musharraf privately leaned on the Hurriyat to seal a deal with India; and even Omar Abdullah, chief of the eternally mainstream National Conference, had a one-onone meeting with Musharraf during a March 2006 visit to Islamabad, and returned to India convinced that we should do business with “the General.”

The irony is that after Musharraf resigned on Monday, the ever-taciturn Narayanan told a Singapore newspaper: “Whether he is impeached or not is not important from the Indian point of view... that leaves a big vacuum, and we are deeply concerned about this... It greatly worries us…” Perhaps the protests in J&K woke Mike up to the fact that he had just missed a great window of opportunity (open long and wide from 2004 to 2008). The time was obviously spent wringing his hands over the nuclear deal; in the bargain, he neglected to hammer out a Kashmir policy. And now, things have spun so out of control that even Omar speaks of debating azadi instead of discussing autonomy.

Admittedly a Kashmir policy does not get formulated overnight, and though it took the NDA two years to have their own policy, each government’s approach does not vary too much from the others. (The NDA bettered even the USA, which always appears to begin working on the Palestinian problem in the final year of each Presidency.) Mike has not even attempted a Kashmir policy; after all, who has time for all those autonomy reports, expert committees, valuable suggestions and friendly advice? The people can’t be fooled forever, however, and if anger has exploded in both Srinagar and in Jammu over a barren 40 hectares, it’s because the people know they’ve been neglected by rulers who aren’t in the least bothered.

Mike has to thus stay home and pay the price for his neglect. As the nuclear deal nears being clinched, Mike’s buddies like Shivshankar Menon and Anil Kakodkar jetset to the cool climes of Vienna and Washington, while Mike has to douse the fires in Jammu and Srinagar. And poor fellow, he has no clue as to where to begin. This column has a suggestion. Mike, go and seek out the wise, the balanced, the judicious, the magnanimous, and the visionary; and let them run the show

editorchief@epmltd.com About the author: Aditya Sinha is the Editor-in-Chief of The New Indian Express and is based at Chennai


PPS: Good piece on the escape of Russian spy Blake.The suspicions remain that Sir Roger Hollis ,the chief of MI6 was also a Russian agent,recruited decades earlier in the Far East.
Cold War spy story: The Blake escape

New documents released under the Freedom of Information Act reveal the official complacency that allowed the Russian spy to be sprung from Wormwood Scrubs in 1966. Robert Verkaik reports

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/ho ... 06534.html
Rahul M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 17169
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 21:09
Location: Skies over BRFATA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rahul M »

Philip ji, have you read "spycatcher" by peter wright ? he conducted the hollis investigations in various capacities in MI5. engrossing insider account in MI5 workings.

p.s. I have the ee kitab in case anyone is interested. :wink:
Rupesh
BRFite
Posts: 967
Joined: 05 Jul 2008 19:14
Location: Somewhere in South Central India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rupesh »

We manage our top Intelligence agencies with chalta hai attitude, what else explains DGP's of state police being appointed as heads of RAW, IB , CBI etc. There is no seperate cadre for Intelligence. Repeated terror attacks does nothing to improve the setup. I don't see things improving in the near future due to over politicization of intelligence.
Dilbu
BRF Oldie
Posts: 8272
Joined: 07 Nov 2007 22:53
Location: Deep in the badlands of BRFATA

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Dilbu »

Rahul M wrote:Philip ji, have you read "spycatcher" by peter wright ? he conducted the hollis investigations in various capacities in MI5. engrossing insider account in MI5 workings.

p.s. I have the ee kitab in case anyone is interested. :wink:
Saar, can you please send the e-kitab to dilbaasuran at gmail dot com. Thanks. :)
sum
BRF Oldie
Posts: 10195
Joined: 08 May 2007 17:04
Location: (IT-vity && DRDO) nagar

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by sum »

Philip ji, have you read "spycatcher" by peter wright ? he conducted the hollis investigations in various capacities in MI5. engrossing insider account in MI5 workings.
One of the reasons why the book was critisized was that he devotes half the book trying to implicate Hollis.....very nice read though and the facts he states against Hollis seem plausible.

Rahul saar, you have e-book of either B.Raman's or M.K.Dhar's book?
Rahul M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 17169
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 21:09
Location: Skies over BRFATA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rahul M »

One of the reasons why the book was critisized was that he devotes half the book trying to implicate Hollis.....very nice read though and the facts he states against Hollis seem plausible.
well, given the original premise he could hardly have done something different !
Rahul saar, you have e-book of either B.Raman's or M.K.Dhar's book?
no, sum. I usually prefer buying books especially when those are by Indian authors.
you know, giving the author his due and all that. but was looking for an e copy of Capt. Amarinder Singh's book since I was not able to find it in book shops frequented by me. unfortunately,ebooks of Indian books are notoriously difficult to get.
p.s. just rahul would do fine ! :wink:
shyamd
BRF Oldie
Posts: 7101
Joined: 08 Aug 2006 18:43

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by shyamd »

Philip wrote:It is precisely to avoid these turf wars and the fact that there are glaring loopholes and flaws in our current setup-just look at the state of security at the moment,that a different outfit for all tech garnering methods is needed.The R&AW and the IB rely upon humint to a great deal,which is essential for penetrating terrorist/foreign networks,which requires a huge amount of fieldwork.There would be no problem to have the two outfits responsible for internal and external security to have (real time) access to the equiv of the NSA.Britain has its GCHQ too.
RAW doesn't rely on Humint any more, it is purely open source info(newspapers etc) and Techint(MKN said so himself aswell). IB does have its Humint. NTRO is hardly what it was meant to be, currently producing software for credit card safety and so on. RAW and IB have refused to co-operate with NTRO and dont want to hand over their Techint assets. Basically they aint doing anything too secretive currently. I wouldnt criticise IB too much, as they're interception of conversations are filtering to the field fairly quickly. But on the whole can do a lot better.

The need of the hour IMO is to create indigenous capability in code breakers as well as interception eqpt. We are over reliant on foreign eqpt for this. US/UK were refusing to sell interception eqpt couple of years back. Some one needs to kick start the indigenous drive in this capability.

I have posted details of how the BND were listening to interceptions done by Russia, Egypt and Oman who bought interception eqpt made by Siemens.

Next thing is to rapidly improve our HUMINT capability accross the border, in China and so on.
Rahul M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 17169
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 21:09
Location: Skies over BRFATA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rahul M »

RAW doesn't rely on Humint any more, it is purely open source info(newspapers etc) and Techint(MKN said so himself aswell).
I find it a little hard to believe. with NO humint at all an intel org may as well close shop.
could you provide a link where MKN said this ?
Jagan
Webmaster BR
Posts: 3032
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Earth @ Google.com
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Jagan »

Rahul M wrote:[ was looking for an e copy of Capt. Amarinder Singh's book since I was not able to find it in book shops frequented :

Rahul, were you looking for this Kargil Book?
Rahul M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 17169
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 21:09
Location: Skies over BRFATA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rahul M »

yes.
shyamd
BRF Oldie
Posts: 7101
Joined: 08 Aug 2006 18:43

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by shyamd »

The performance of the existing intelligence agencies has clearly proved to be inadequate. While the IB has been burdened with gathering political intelligence, the external intelligence agency, raw, has come in for severe flak from the highest quarters. National security advisor M.K. Narayanan recently told the Union cabinet that raw was spending more time analysing events rather than generating intelligence. "raw doesn't have any major primary sources of information, and now depends mostly on secondary sources," a source told Outlook.
Link

Couldn't find the exact link. I got told first hand.
ChandraS

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ChandraS »

Part II of the Gujarat blasts case article on Rediff. Looks pretty balanced. Gives a lot of info on the modus operandi of the SIMI cadre in Guj.
Gujarat cops hope they have an airtight case
Some specific points I think are important -
The bombs meant for Surat were assembled at Imran Sheikh's home in Baroda, while the bombs for Ahmedabad were assembled in Yunus Mansoori's home in that city's Bapunagar area.{This explains why the Surat bombs didn't go off. Some QA/QC issues with the whole batch of Surat bombs}
There were three types of bombs: Tiffin bombs, bombs in the shape of a boat and car bombs. All the bombs placed on bicycles exploded at the same time while the car bombs were fitted along with gas cylinders.
The Gujarat police's interrogation of Zahid Sheikh and Sajid Mansuri suggests that the absconding Taufique alias Abdus Subhan Qureshi possibly had a role in the Mumbai train blasts of July 11, 2006. In the first week of August, a team from the Gujarat police which included a Muslim officer went to Taufique's home in the Nayanagar area of Mira Road outside Mumbai. While serving them seviyan, the traditional sweet dish, Taufique's wife gave enough hints to the police that her husband is unlikely to be caught. She almost threw them a challenge.{So this whole SIMI thing is much bigger than just some individuals. This may be the first piece of evidence that a section of IM population is getting radicalized to the extremist ideology}

Taufique was detained by the Mumbai police after the 2006 blasts, but was released after six days of interrogation because they could not find anything against him.{The lack of coordination between diff states' policies and agencies is now getting too costly to be brushed under the carpet anymore. The MAC or any such setup has to be put in place ASAP. We can't have such snafus anymore. I have a gut feeling that the next round of blasts will be way bigger and way more deadlier than what we have seen so far.}
Usman Agarbattiwala, who was arrested in Baroda, gave initial hints of the operation to the Gujarat police. A confidant of Kapadia, Usman was doing a diploma in human rights at Baroda University. The SIMI leadership wants its cadres to penetrate the legal field, media and human rights outfits all over India.{So they want to replicate the Naxal model. There are going to be more Dr. Sen & Afzal Guru situations. The whole security & law enforcement and judicial machinery has to be overhauled with more terrorism specific laws and such. This jehadi/terror phenomenon can't be neutralized by our current IPC}
Baroda Police Commissioner Rakesh Asthana says, "These are committed people. Imran's old father was treated at the Ahmedabad civil hospital recently. He stayed with him there. But the same man was a part of the conspiracy that planted a bomb in the civil hospital. They have no remorse. They dispute the idea of nationalism."
This speaks for itself. I cannot put my anger and outrage in words. :x
When asked repeatedly why these men would stay on in Gujarat after the blasts, one Gujarat police officer says, "None of them thought the police would ever catch them. Even if they are caught they thought it would be for political reasons. Blasts after blasts took place in India and nobody was arrested, so they became brazen."

"The media may like to write what they want on the entire issue of Indian terrorism," he says. "But for us the lesson is simple. A few people in India are interpreting the Quran wrongly and interpreting the concept of jihad crookedly. We have to be careful and alert against them."

The last line is pretty much sums up the issue.
Philip
BRF Oldie
Posts: 21538
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Philip »

If R&AW isn't doing HUMINT these days,it then explains why we are in s*it street when it comes to detecting cross-border terrorism and foreign agents and their operations in India! HUMINT is also vital,as one cannot simply rely upon Tech-int for info.Assymetrical warfare as being practised by AlQ and others,have seen how cell phones and other electronic communications are being intercepted and decoded by the US,etc.Some outfits are reported to have returned to "pigeon post".In any case,worldwide HUMINT is still being seen as the key source of quality info.Remember Aldrich Ames,the Walker brothers,and the most devastating of all,Hansen? Here is some fascinating intel. news.

1.Legendary Communist era spy savior died in Germany

Wolfgang Vogel, a lawyer in Communist East Germany who became a wealthy man in the Cold War by opening cracks in the Berlin Wall to swap captured spies and release political prisoners, died Thursday, August 21, at the age of 82, The International Herald Tribune reports.
His second wife and former assistant, Helga, said he died after a long illness in Schliersee, the lakeside resort in the Bavarian Alps where they went to live after the wall came down in 1989 and Germany reunified a year later.
For three decades preceding reunification, Vogel was an operator who could pull strings in Moscow as effectively as in Washington, useful to each side because he was trusted by the other. He was taken into the confidence of Chancellor Helmut Schmidt of West Germany and into that of Erich Honecker, the Communist leader in East Berlin.
Vogel's first spy-swapping case began in 1959, when he represented an East German woman who said she was the wife of Rudolf Ivanovich Abel, a Soviet spy imprisoned in the United States.
Three years later, negotiations resulted in the exchange of Abel for the captured U.S. U-2 spy plane pilot Francis Gary Powers outside Berlin.
In later years, Vogel often materialized out of the mists at German border crossing points, his wife at the wheel of their gold-colored Mercedes, for spy swaps, releases of political prisoners - 33,755 in all - and family reunifications for 215,019 people, their freedom bought from Communists by the West German government under Vogel's auspices.
The trade brought in $2.4 billion in western currency, needed in East Berlin; Vogel also got annual payments of more than $200,000 from the West Germans.
It was to Vogel that ordinary East German citizens would turn for permission to emigrate, obtainable, he told them, if they had private property to sell to buyers whom he would find, for a fee.
Vogel saw himself as a humanitarian, and his last negotiations were to help thousands of East Germans in West German embassies in Prague and Warsaw make their way to freedom as their regime was collapsing. But all his influence came from his connections with the East German Staatssicherheit, the Stasi security service, and his usefulness came to an end when the agency did.
After reunification, his Stasi links left him open to accusations of extortion, profiteering and tax evasion that culminated in his arrest and later conviction in a state court in Berlin in 1996 on five counts of blackmail. He appealed; Germany's highest court found in his favor in 1998 on two of the cases, and prosecutors agreed to drop the others. But he and his lawyers agreed not to contest a separate conviction for perjury and falsely swearing to an affidavit, and his legal career was over.
When he passed the equivalent of the bar exam in 1949, Vogel was apprenticed to a senior judge and followed him to the East German Justice Ministry in Berlin in 1952. But when the judge fled to West Berlin after the anti-communist uprisings of 1953 and asked Vogel to join him, the Stasi found out and ensnared the young lawyer in its coils.
He went along as a collaborator, but soon his ambitious Stasi controller, Heinz Volpert, saw that this ingratiating young man could serve larger state interests if he was allowed to set up as an independent lawyer who could work in both East and West Berlin. Captain (later Colonel) Volpert closed Vogel's "secret collaborator" file in 1957.
Though Vogel's Stasi connections continued well after 1957, he maintained that he was never a secret informer after that. "My paths were not white and not black; they had to be gray," he said.

2.Legendary Soviet spy died at the age of 101

A Soviet spy code-named "Zephyr" who worked undercover with his wife in Europe and the United States for more than a quarter of a century has died at 101, Russia's foreign intelligence agency (SVR) said, Reuters reported.
The agency issued a glowing tribute to spy Mikhail Mukasei, whose death comes at a time when Russia's tense relations with the West and its conflict with Georgia are prompting many observers to draw parallels with the Cold War.
Mukasei operated with his wife Elizaveta as an undercover team in an unnamed "West European country" from the 1950s until their return to Moscow in 1977, the agency said on its Internet site www.svr.gov.ru.
"Their active work was as illegal operatives. The geographic operations of the Mukaseis were very extensive: They performed tasks for the motherland on several continents," the SVR tribute said.
Earlier, during the Second World War, under the cover of the Soviet vice-consul in Los Angeles, Mukasei gathered "highly valued" information linked to Japan's wartime threat to the Soviet Union, the SVR said.

3.Revelations of the CIA's secret terror links,carrying out terror strikes supposedly by leftists in Italy.

NATO's Cold War secret armies researched in a new book
At a time when experts are debating whether NATO is suited to deal with the global “war on terror”, new research suggests that the alliance’s own secret history has links to terrorism.
The following report written by Daniele Ganser is based on excerpts from his newly released book, “NATO’s Secret Armies. Operation Gladio and Terrorism in Western Europe”, released this week by Frank Cass in London. Report was published today by Macedonia Online website.
The book describes NATO’s clandestine operations during the Cold War. The research was prompted by a story that made world headlines in 1990 but quickly disappeared, ensuring that even today, NATO’s secret armies remain just that - secret.
Until now, a full investigation of NATO’s secret armies had not been carried out - a task that Ganser has taken on single-handedly and quite successfully.
In Italy, on 3 August 1990, then-prime minister Giulio Andreotti confirmed the existence of a secret army code-named “Gladio” - the Latin word for “sword” - within the state. His testimony before the Senate subcommittee investigating terrorism in Italy sent shockwaves through the Italian parliament and the public, as speculation arose that the secret army had possibly manipulated Italian politics through acts of terrorism.
Andreotti revealed that the secret Gladio army had been hidden within the Defense Ministry as a subsection of the military secret service, SISMI. General Vito Miceli, a former director of the Italian military secret service, could hardly believe that Andreotti had lifted the secret, and protested: "I have gone to prison because I did not want to reveal the existence of this super secret organization. And now Andreotti comes along and tells it to parliament!" According to a document compiled by the Italian military secret service in 1959, the secret armies had a two-fold strategic purpose: firstly, to operate as a so-called “stay-behind” group in the case of a Soviet invasion and to carry out a guerrilla war in occupied territories; secondly, to carry out domestic operations in case of “emergency situations”.
The military secret services’ perceptions of what constituted an “emergency” was well defined in Cold War Italy and focused on the increasing strength of the Italian Communist and the Socialist parties, both of which were tasked with weakening NATO “from within”. Felice Casson, an Italian judge who during his investigations into right-wing terrorism had first discovered the secret Gladio army and had forced Andreotti to take a stand, found that the secret army had linked up with right-wing terrorists in order to confront “emergency situations”. The terrorists, supplied by the secret army, carried out bomb attacks in public places, blamed them on the Italian left, and were thereafter protected from prosecution by the military secret service. "You had to attack civilians, the people, women, children, innocent people, unknown people far removed from any political game,” right-wing terrorist Vincezo Vinciguerra explained the so-called “strategy of tension” to Casson.
“The reason was quite simple. They were supposed to force these people, the Italian public, to turn to the state to ask for greater security. This is the political logic that lies behind all the massacres and the bombings which remain unpunished, because the state cannot convict itself or declare itself responsible for what happened."
How strongly NATO and US intelligence backed and supported the use of terror in Italy in order to discredit the political left during the Cold War remains subject of ongoing research. General Gerardo Serravalle, who had commanded the Italian Gladio secret army from 1971 to 1974, confirmed that the secret army “could pass from a defensive, post-invasion logic, to one of attack, of civil war”.
The Italian Senate chose to be more explicit and concluded in its investigation in 2000: "Those massacres, those bombs, those military actions had been organized or promoted or supported by men inside Italian state institutions and, as has been discovered more recently, by men linked to the structures of United States intelligence." Ever since the discovery of the secret NATO armies in 1990, research into stay-behind armies has progressed only very slowly, due to very limited access to primary documents and the refusal of both NATO and the CIA to comment. On 5 November 1990, a NATO spokesman told an inquisitive press: "NATO has never contemplated guerrilla war or clandestine operations”.
The next day, NATO officials admitted that the previous day’s denial had been false, adding that the alliance would not comment on matters of military secrecy. On 7 November, NATO’s highest military official in Europe, Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR) US General John Galvin, together with NATO’s highest civilian official, Secretary-General Manfred Wörner, briefed NATO ambassadors behind closed doors. "Since this is a secret organization, I wouldn't expect too many questions to be answered,” reasoned a senior NATO diplomat, who wished to remain unnamed. “If there were any links to terrorist organizations, that sort of information would be buried very deep indeed.” Former CIA director William Colby confirmed in his memoirs that setting up the secret armies in Western Europe had been “a major program” for the CIA. The project started after World War II in total secrecy, and access to information was limited “to the smallest possible coterie of the most reliable people, in Washington, in NATO” and in the countries concerned. Yet when in Italy in 1990 former CIA director Admiral Stansfield Turner was questioned on television on Gladio, he strictly refused to answer any questions on the sensitive issue, and as the interviewer insisted with respect for the terror victims, Stansfield angrily ripped off his microphone and shouted: "I said, no questions about Gladio!", whereafter the interview was over.
If there had been a Soviet invasion, the secret anti-communist soldiers would have operated behind enemy lines, strengthening and setting up local resistance movements in enemy-held territory, evacuating shot down pilots, and sabotaging the supply lines and production centers of occupation forces. Upon discovery of the secret armies, the European Parliament responded with harsh criticism, suspecting it to have been involved in manipulation and terror operations. “This Europe will have no future,” Italian representative Falqui opened the debate, “if it is not founded on truth, on the full transparency of its institutions in regard to the dark plots against democracy that have turned upside down the history, even in recent times, of many European states.” Falqui insisted that “there will be no future, ladies and gentlemen, if we do not remove the idea of having lived in a kind of double state - one open and democratic, the other clandestine and reactionary. That is why we want to know what and how many "Gladio" networks there have been in recent years in the Member States of the European Community." The majority of EU parliamentarians followed Falqui, and in a special resolution on 22 November 1990 made it clear that the EU “protests vigorously at the assumption by certain US military personnel at SHAPE and in NATO of the right to encourage the establishment in Europe of a clandestine intelligence and operation network”, calling for a “a full investigation into the nature, structure, aims, and all other aspects of these clandestine organizations or any splinter groups, their use for illegal interference in the internal political affairs of the countries concerned, and the problem of terrorism in Europe”.
Only the parliaments in Italy, Switzerland, and Belgium had formed a special commission to investigate the national secret army, and after months or even years of research, presented a public report. Building on this data and secondary sources from numerous European countries, “NATO’s Secret Armies” confirms for the first time that the secret networks spread across Western Europe, with great details on networks in Germany, France, Spain, Portugal, Holland, Luxemburg, Belgium, Denmark, Norway, Italy, Greece, and Turkey, as well as the strategic planning of Britain and the US. The stay-behind armies were coordinated on an international level by the so-called Allied Clandestine Committee (ACC) and the Clandestine Planning Committee (CPC), linked to NATO’s Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers Europe (SHAPE). And they used cover names such as “Absalon” in Denmark, “P26” in Switzerland, “ROC” in Norway or “SDRA8” in Belgium. Interestingly, large differences existed from country to country. In some nations the secret armies became a source of terror, while in others they remained a prudent precaution.
In Turkey, the “Counter-Guerrilla” was involved in domestic terror and torture operations against the Kurds, while in Greece, the “LOK” took part in the 1967 military coup d’état to prevent a Socialist government. In Spain, the secret army was used to prop up the fascist dictatorship of Franco, and in Germany, right-wing terrorists used the explosives of the secret army in the 1980 terror attack in Munich. In other countries, including Denmark, Norway, and Luxemburg, the secret soldiers prepared for the eventual occupation of their home country and never engaged in domestic terror or manipulation. In the context of the ongoing so-called war on terror, the Gladio data promotes the sobering insight that governments in the West have sacrificed the life of innocent citizens and covered up acts of terrorism in order to manipulate the population.
Allegations that NATO, the Pentagon, MI6, the CIA, and European intelligence services were linked to terror, coups d’état, and torture in Europe are obviously of an extremely sensitive nature, and future research is needed in the field. In the absence of an official investigation by NATO or the EU, ongoing international research into terrorism is about to tackle this difficult task, the first step of which I hope to have promisingly taken with “NATO’s Secret Armies”.
Dr Daniele Ganser is a Senior Researcher at the Center for Security Studies at the ETH in Zurich. For more information on the topic, compare the research of the Center of Security Studies (CSS) at ETH Zurich.

4.Georgian spy to be sentenced to 20 years in Russian prison

A Russian army officer accused of spying for Georgia has been arrested in the Stavropol region. The news comes one a week after Russian intelligence announced it had uncovered a Georgian spy network that was allegedly planning terrorist attacks in Russia.
Army officer Mikhail Khachidze, an ethnic Georgian, is being investigated for state treason, Russian news agencies reported, citing a statement from the Federal Security Service (FSB). Details regarding his apprehension were not disclosed.
According to the FSB, Khachidze began working for Georgian intelligence on Georgian territory in 2007. Then, while stationed in a Russian Army unit in the North Caucasus region Khachidze allegedly "gathered secret information about Russian armed forces, the military capabilities of Russian units, and his fellow servicemen."
He is being charged under Article 275 of the Criminal Code (state treason), which is punishable by between 12 and 20 years in prison.
The announcement came just days after FSB Chief Alexander Bortnikov said that Georgian intelligence were planning a series of terrorist attacks in the North Caucasus region - a volatile area of Russian provinces separated from Georgia in the south by the Caucasus Mountains.
Earlier, the FSB had apprehended nine Georgian members of an alleged terror cell that included a member of Georgian intelligence identified as ‘Kherkeladze.' Bortnikov informed Russian officials that Kherkeladze was working on Russian territory and directing a group of other agents. In footage broadcast on Russian television, Kherkeladze is shown confessing that he occupied a high-placed position in Georgia's military intelligence unit. It is alleged he entered Russia on a Russian passport earlier this year with orders to gather intelligence on Russia's military forces, as well as South Ossetia's President Eduard Kokoity. Another suspect, Alexander Khachirov, was shown on state television confessing to planning to blow up a mine on Russian territory in June.
The nine intelligence agents were most likely detained at different times over the summer, while the announcement was made in wake of Georgia's attack on South Ossetia's Tskhinvali and Russia's punitive counter-offensive, which ended last week.
Georgian authorities are denying the espionage and terrorism allegations. Georgian Interior Ministry Chief Shota Utiashvili was reported as saying the accusations are meant to justify the presence of Russian forces on Georgian soil.

Excerpts from http://www.axisglobe.com/article.asp?article=1628
ASPuar
BRFite
Posts: 1538
Joined: 07 Feb 2001 12:31
Location: Republic of India

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by ASPuar »

@RahulM: Check mail, please.
Rahul M
Forum Moderator
Posts: 17169
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 21:09
Location: Skies over BRFATA
Contact:

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Rahul M »

got it boss, thanks.
Inder Sharma
BRFite
Posts: 135
Joined: 18 May 2006 14:35

Re: Intelligence & National Security Discussion

Post by Inder Sharma »

edited.
check mail.
Rahul.
Locked