With Mars Orbiter Mission India set to rewrite space economics.
As part of Isro’s scaled up space programme, the country’s first interplanetary probe in a way is a statement to the world on India’s technological capability, skilled workforce, and frugal engineering, and hopes to show that it is a low-cost player in the high-cost exploration business. And there is a space economy in the making.
Just consider this. The Rs 450-crore (Rs 4.5 bn/$74 million) mission is being executed just 15 months after the government approved it in August 2012. The satellite is built by Indian scientists and engineers. It is being launched from Indian soil, using an indigenous rocket and will carry home-grown instruments to read the biochemistry of Mars. The 5 November blast-off is also significant as it marks the silver jubilee of the Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV). The spacecraft, once launched aboard the PSLV-c25 (PSLV XL), would go around the earth for about 25 days before embarking on a 300-day voyage to the Martian orbit where it is planned to reach in September 2014.
"About 85% of the goal is to demonstrate technological capabilities and gather inputs for future missions, 15 per cent is scientific objectives,
"If India manages to insert a fully operational spacecraft into the Mars orbit, that alone would be a tremendous achievement," says Emily Lakdawalla of The Planetary Society, a US-based organisation that advocates for space research and exploration.
The main challenge would be to see how the engines that propel the orbiter into the Martian atmosphere work after remaining silent for 300 days, and how the craft's insulation holds up on the voyage.
The Indian Space Research Organisation (Isro) said that filling of monomethyhydrazine into the fourth stage of Polar Satellite Launch Vehicle (PSLV) C25 for the Mars Orbiter Mission (MOM) has been completed.
Globally, there have been 51 missions to Mars till date. Of these, only 21 have been successful. This is enough indication of the complexity of such missions. This is India’s first interplanetary mission. We had to calibrate our hardware to withstand a territory not experienced before. Since there is a propagation delay of 20 minutes (one way) when we communicate with the spacecraft, because of its distance from Earth, the spacecraft has to be ‘intelligent’ enough to take care of itself during that period.
NPR's hack job reminding how India has poverty and bad infrastructure. Brings out the opposition of Madhavan Nair. K.Radhakrishnan argues well:
ISRO's Radhakrishnan says the agency's overall budget is 0.34 percent of the total national budget. He says the portion of the agency budget given to planetary exploration is 7 percent. And, he argues, such missions could "percolate to" applications like cyclone forecasting.
A good read, of course there is two lines of undernourishment and no toilets thingy.
Success would be a source of national pride for Indians, whose 2008 unmanned mission to the moon helped prove the existence of water in another leap forward, 39 years after Neil Armstrong set foot there.
It would also bolster the reputation of India, the land of the world's cheapest car, as a leader in low-cost innovation. The project was announced in August 2012 with a budget of only 4.5 billion rupees ($73 million).
He also defends ISRO and its 16,000-strong workforce against suggestions that New Delhi should not be spending on space when more than a third of all children are malnourished and half of Indians have no toilets.
"Space is one area right from the beginning that has been contributing to the development process of the country," he said, pointing to better weather forecasting for farmers and satellite communication networks
Instead of flying directly, the 350-tonne rocket will orbit earth for nearly a month, building up the necessary velocity to break free from the earth's gravitational pull.
Upendra Choudhury, an associate professor at Aligarh Muslim University who is an expert on India's ballistic missile programme, says the spending has also boosted national security.
genomak • 3 days ago −
Give a man a fish he will eat for a day. Teach a man to send a spaceship to Mars I'm sure he figured out how to fish along the way.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 03 Nov 2013 21:52
by Gerard
SwamyG wrote: One or two trolls as well.
More will emerge from the woodwork after launch. Also Chinese and Pakistanis pretending to be otherwise.
This mission, he insists, is different. “In the previous missions, satellite injections would take place after 20 minutes. This time, it will take place after more than 40 minutes. Also, since the temperature will fall drastically, thermal control features have been added.” The more than 16,000 employees of Isro, who have made the technological and scientific contributions to the mission are aware that even after the spacecraft is launched, the road ahead is dotted with challenges before it finally enters the Martian orbit on September 24, 2014. But the scientists are upbeat. “Every mission has a failure risk. That does not mean that you do not foray into it,” says Vijaya Sardhi, group director, programme management. Agrees Mylswamy Annadurai, the project director of the Chandrayaan-1 and Chandrayaan-2 missions: “We are all optimistic, but at the same time we are all praying that the mission meets its goals and objectives. Considering that there have been several missions to Mars but few have actually succeeded, we have to be careful.”
Many moons ahead
It’s a giant leap ahead from India’s 2008 moon mission. “You cannot compare the two. In Chandrayaan-1, we had to cover a distance of around 4 lakh km, the travel distance now is nearly 200 to 400 million km. Also, Chadrayaan-1 remained within the Earth’s sphere of influence all along. The Orbiter will move from the Earth’s sphere of influence to the Sun’s sphere of influence, and finally to Mar’s sphere of influence,” explains Annadurai.
"This is just a revolutionary step towards space invention," Associate Professor Upendra Lad at Department of Physics who studied at MSG Arts Commerce and Science College, told AA.
When asked about the amount of money India is spending on this mission – estimated at $70 million - given the abject poverty in India and the number of Indians living under the below poverty line, he dismissed the comparison.
"It’s foolhardy to evaluate this mission in terms of extravagant space spending and growing poverty. One never knows the impact and future gain of the mission," he asserted.
Mujahid Ansari, assistant professor at the department of chemistry, AIT College of Arts, Commerce and Science, agrees.
"There may not be any immediate gain of Mars mission as space exploration is a time-consuming process," he told AA, dismissing the unwarranted criticism of the space mission.
"Bringing in the poverty politics into science, technology and space exploration is a reflection of a sick and hypocritical mind," Ansari insisted.
He cited the recent coal allocation scam in India where the Comptroller and Auditor General put the loss to public exchequer at $28 billion.
"Did anybody raise and compare India’s poverty when CAG tabled its report in Indian parliament stating $28 billion loss?" Ansari fumed.
When asked whether India’s mission to Mars is a desire to beat China, Ansari dismissed the suggestions.
"It is purely driven by science and nothing else. If in doing so, India overtakes China in space exploration, why make a fuss about it?" he said.
Some experts believe that MOM focuses more on technological than scientific objectives but Ansari disagrees.
"It is harmonious balance between technology and science. MOM will not only demonstrate the capability to enter Mars orbit but it will also search for methane in the Martian atmosphere," he argued.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 03 Nov 2013 23:56
by SwamyG
Methinks, ISRO makes great rockets, satellites and missions. But bad websites So if you cannot get the pages to load properly and view the trajectory, here is it. I have seen the original image on ISRO's website some time back.
LAP is an absorption cell photometer, intended for studying the escape processes of the upper atmosphere as well as water from Mars based on the relative abundance of deuterium and hydrogen in the Martian upper atmosphere.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 04 Nov 2013 04:51
by Bade
Methane Sensor for Mars
As the name suggests, this payload is designed to measure the Methane content-based on the reflected solar radiation-in the Martian atmosphere and also to map its sources.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 04 Nov 2013 04:52
by Bade
Mars Color Camera (MCC)
MCC captures RGB images and information about the features and composition of the Martian surface. MCC images will be useful to monitor the dynamic events and also the weather on Mars. It will also be used for probing the two moons of Mars – Phobos & Deimos. It also provides the context information for other science payloads on-board ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission spacecraft.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 04 Nov 2013 04:56
by Bade
Shri S Arunan (Centre), Project Director of ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission Spacecraft explaining details to Dr. K Radhakrishnan, Chairman
succeed across all these steps, you need the very best rocket scientists, computer programmers, artificial intelligence experts, planetary geophysicists, radar and long-range communications engineers, physicists, chemists, material scientists, metallurgists and dozens of other specialists in many disciplines, working as one. If even one of them is not at the very top of their game, the mission could end in failure.So yes, Mangalyaan is a long shot, but success would mean that India has acheived a level of cutting-edge scientific and technological capabilities previously present in only three scientific communities. It would become a fantastic case study and calling card for investing in India's high-tech industries and education. Emily Lakdawalla, a scientist and blogger at the Planetary Society, addresses the question about funding space research while fighting poverty more directly:"...there's an error in the question. It assumes that there is a fixed quantity of wealth in India, and that stopping investment in high-tech industry would mean more money for the poor. Wealth doesn't work that way; there is not a fixed quantity of it. The technology India is developing for this mission has direct commercial applications, generating economic activity that will increase the nation's overall wealth. And I think that backers of India's space program believe that achieving a successful mission to Mars would increase confidence in India's technological prowess and therefore the flow of investment money. To be seen in the company of the U.S. and China and Europe would have to stimulate such investment."
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 04 Nov 2013 12:22
by Neshant
Lets hope it goes well.
The stress the Project Director is under for this to succeed must be enormous.
Antariksh Bhavan, the heavily fortified headquarters of Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) on New BEL Road in Bangalore has been abuzz with a series of activities ahead of India's big-ticket Mars Mission. Located on the first floor is the office of ISRO Chairman Dr Koppillil Radhakrishnan, who was at the door to welcome the Talkathon crew. When told that the interview will be hovering around 'the Man behind the Mars movement and not the much-talked about Mangalyaan,' RK quickly got into mission mode. “You see, I am a simple person. I will be happy to share whatever you want to know,” he said. Further, while explaining the template of the Talkathon interview series, RK said: “Although I hail from Irinjalakuda (Thrissur district in Kerala), I am more a Bangalorean now. It's an affair of over 22 years. I have sweet memories of this great city.” Excerpts.
Unlike the previous PSLV missions, which lasted about 18 minutes to put remote sensing satellites into orbit, the flight duration of PSLV-C25 will last a suspenseful 43 minutes before the rocket’s fourth stage puts the spacecraft into orbit. “This is the speciality of the mission,” said B. Jayakumar, Vehicle Director. As Mr. Jayakumar and R. Hutton, Associate Vehicle Director, stood a couple of hundred metres in front of the Mobile Service Tower encasing the four-stage PSLV-C25 on October 30, they asserted that “the PSLV is a rain-proof vehicle.”
Besides the 43-minute flight, yet another mission speciality is the 25-minute coasting phase between the third stage burn-outand the fourth stage ignition. A third speciality is that it is only 37seconds after the fourth stage burn-out that the spacecraft will be injected into orbit.
V. Seshagiri Rao, Associate Director, SDSC, said several ground stations, including two ship-borne radars in the South Pacific Ocean, would track the vehicle and its positional information would be received every 100 milliseconds.
Haresh bhai, as you yourself have said, that article you've shared, amounts to what can described as a troll article
Perhaps our purpose would be best served if, from here onwards, we restrict our discussions & share contents in this thread only if related to the Scientific & possibly [non-trollish] Geo-political aspects of this mission
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 04 Nov 2013 20:51
by vishvak
Yes suggesting article from gutter inspectors to be moved to Indo-UK thread if its OK. Its a kind of trend by UK commentators is why Indo-UK thread.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 00:40
by SaiK
We should also think about next generation data routers as default networking device on all space missions (programmable from Earth). Also there should be more investments on nuclear fuel like russkies and khaans. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_in_space
These two are vital for future deep space.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 02:57
by member_27808
Haresh wrote:And here we go folks, the poison from the British media has started flowing...........
I think you are being a bit thin skinned and overly sensitive.
I read the article and found it positive. For example, it states "India, as well known for its endemic poverty and hunger as for its technological prowess, has used research in space and elsewhere to help solve problems at home, from gauging water levels in underground aquifers to predicting cataclysmic storms and floods."
This is not vitriol. However, the headline is unfortunate but, I understand headlines are written by editors and its job, in this case being an online pub., is to attract attention and comments.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 02:58
by KJo
Does India still receive British aid????
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 03:11
by Suraj
Please stop derailing this thread by posting articles that provide NOTHING by way of constructive criticism or analysis of this program. The Daily Mail is a sensationalist tabloid. If at all necessary, post it in the Benis thread and mock it liberally there.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 03:47
by SwamyG
From ISRO's website....
Second Stage (PS2) Propellant filling commenced.
Mobile Service Tower (MST) withdrawal upto 50m is completed.
In Haresh's defence, it is just not the foreign tabloid that are asking the questions. In almost every article, even in Indian ones, a scientist or two is forced to ponder on the condition of India. I think it is even some Indians who are asking such questions.
The technologies developed in building India's Mars Orbiter can be incorporated in other satellites the country would build saving costs and increasing performance, say Indian space scientists.
Speaking to IANS, scientists at the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) said the self corrective programmes incorporated in the orbiter, miniaturisation of components, cold starting of the orbiter engine after a gap of 300 days and other things can be incorporated in remote sensing and communication satellites that are built by India.
"The huge autonomy given to the space craft to fend for itself without human intervention from the ground, miniaturisation of components and other technologies can be incorporated in other satellites that India builds," A.S. Kiran Kumar, director at ISRO's Space Application Centre said.
"This is the first time in the world that anybody has realised a spacecraft like this in 15 months flat. If all the systems we have built works successfully, then we can say that India is one of the top nations in building satellites," S. Arunan, project director, Mars Oribiter Mission said
In addition, the space craft has been programmed to self diagnose and take corrective actions on its own. Normally people on the ground stations give commands to the satellites on corrective actions.
Queried about the benefits of these technologies, Arunan said: "These can be incorporated in our remote sensing/earth observation and communication satellites."
The MOM will chalk up some firsts in the history of Mars exploration, too. It is the first mission to be launched into an elliptical Earth orbit. Space agencies like the Nasa and the ESA prefer a straight flight trajectory out to Mars. Besides, it is the first Mars mission to use a light booster like the PSLV
And the mission has been realised at an incredibly low budget: its Rs. 450-crore price tag is less than 0.01% of India’s annual budget, making it the cheapest ever to head for Mars. The Nasa, the ESA and Japan’s JAXA spend several times more. In comparison, Nasa’s new Mars mission, MAVEN, scheduled for launch November 18, took almost six years to fabricate, and cost more than 10 times. “Isro’s budget for 2010 happens to be our highest ever. And it’s just 3% of Nasa’s budget for the year 2010,” adds Radhakrishnan. So science apart, the MOM’s success will certainly give an enormous boost to Isro’s standing in the global launch business, promoting investor confidence.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 05:20
by sanjaykumar
Please just let's get that thing into earth orbit first. I had not realised the complexity of orbital mechanics involved in Martian orbit capture.
Re: Mangalyaan : ISRO's Mars Orbiter Mission
Posted: 05 Nov 2013 05:42
by sourab_c
Haresh wrote:And here we go folks, the poison from the British media has started flowing...........
Reading some of the comments, it is a clear case of khujli and a desperate attempt to preserve their pride in the 21st century. They are clearly frustrated with how things are in the UK and so are finding ANYTHING to put us down. I wouldn't worry about them.
“First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, and then you win.”