Search found 337 matches
- 29 Nov 2004 22:30
- Forum: Military Scenarios Archive
- Topic: Possible Indian Military Scenarios - Part I
- Replies: 317
- Views: 231767
- 25 Nov 2004 13:32
- Forum: Military Scenarios Archive
- Topic: Possible Indian Military Scenarios - Part I
- Replies: 317
- Views: 231767
- 23 Nov 2004 17:51
- Forum: Military Scenarios Archive
- Topic: Possible Indian Military Scenarios - Part I
- Replies: 317
- Views: 231767
someone like you or daulat or anyone else with better knowledge of small arms and CQB work could rewrite the part from where they enter the compound to make it better. :D fell free to kick some paki butt anytime. shurely saar, shum mishtake is there onlee? the only cqb i am familiar with is with la...
- 03 Nov 2004 23:47
- Forum: Military Issues Archive
- Topic: Failure of US technology - Lessons for Cold Start
- Replies: 47
- Views: 53236
wyu - the franco-prussian war would have been a full on war after the american civil war where a lot of technology was deployed (big guns, some rail mounted) and the prussians almost took paris. the boer war was more akin to a guerilla conflict with a powerful well organised (but badly led) army aga...
- 03 Nov 2004 21:39
- Forum: Military Issues Archive
- Topic: Failure of US technology - Lessons for Cold Start
- Replies: 47
- Views: 53236
enquoob - i think that whilst most of the horse back stuff was for pre-battle mobility, particularly for the strike controllers, there was atleast one engagement where the NA actually charged taliban t55's on horseback. the logic would be that in narrow valleys, tanks have limited movement and gun t...
- 03 Nov 2004 20:27
- Forum: Military Issues Archive
- Topic: Failure of US technology - Lessons for Cold Start
- Replies: 47
- Views: 53236
- 03 Nov 2004 14:25
- Forum: Military Issues Archive
- Topic: Failure of US technology - Lessons for Cold Start
- Replies: 47
- Views: 53236
pmangalik - you are not way of. what you describe is analogous to a very lean just-in-time production system that is heavily dependent on production information (and predictability) and the critical logistical chain. one screw up and the whole line goes down. expensive and messy. the comms will have...
- 03 Nov 2004 14:20
- Forum: Military Issues Archive
- Topic: Failure of US technology - Lessons for Cold Start
- Replies: 47
- Views: 53236
Rien - this is off topic, but a while ago I had found an article on the Polish lancers in 1939. <snip> btw - the Northern Alliance and US Spec. Forces very recently charged tanks in Afghanistan on horseback and won. They won? How on Earth is that possible? I don't see how any weaponry outside of a ...
- 03 Nov 2004 04:57
- Forum: Military Issues Archive
- Topic: Failure of US technology - Lessons for Cold Start
- Replies: 47
- Views: 53236
Rien - this is off topic, but a while ago I had found an article on the Polish lancers in 1939. They knew damn well they had no chance against the tanks, but they had no option, so went down fighting. They did launch several successful attacks against german infantry and support troops in the forest...
- 28 Oct 2004 03:49
- Forum: Nuclear Issues Archive
- Topic: Pakistan Nuclear Proliferation - 02 October 2004
- Replies: 321
- Views: 111664
Tim - i think Sunil explains my concept of 'extended deterence' desi style pretty well. i don't think its about actual deterence, but the threat of a threat - just enough to deter Pakistan from thinking itself to be too big for its boots. the US doesn't believe Iran to be rational, but they are - th...
- 27 Oct 2004 12:24
- Forum: Nuclear Issues Archive
- Topic: Pakistan Nuclear Proliferation - 02 October 2004
- Replies: 321
- Views: 111664
i think that the Iranians are pragmatic - IMO they really do not fear nuclear attack from Israel or indeed the US, even the most rabid neo-con will opt for conventional war with Iran. No - the real worry for the Iranians is the Sunni-Shia divide and the role that a nuclear armed Pakistan might play....
- 27 Oct 2004 02:39
- Forum: Nuclear Issues Archive
- Topic: Pakistan Nuclear Proliferation - 02 October 2004
- Replies: 321
- Views: 111664
daulat, Hvve you read the writings of an expert on Shia-Sunni relations called Vali Nasr? He postulates that the Shia are on the rise and Iraqi Shias would give a boost to Arab Shiaism. And that would cause backlash from the Sunni leadership. no - but i am familar with the concept ;) KSA and other ...
- 27 Oct 2004 02:24
- Forum: Nuclear Issues Archive
- Topic: Pakistan Nuclear Proliferation - 02 October 2004
- Replies: 321
- Views: 111664
is the strategic agreement between India and Iran basically putting Iran under Indian nuclear protection if Paks or Saudis (can you tell the difference) do some misadventuring? Or atleast a signal in that direction? and actually iran is not really developing anything (anyway - it is years from weapo...
- 26 Oct 2004 21:41
- Forum: Nuclear Issues Archive
- Topic: Pakistan Nuclear Proliferation - 02 October 2004
- Replies: 321
- Views: 111664
Ramana i maintain that mushy and xerox-bhai were running a double scam. they were selling the ummah-bomb concept to win ummah-brownie points, but also selling dubious kit to make money on the side. where required, they sold bomb designs (libya) to impress. they concluded that the customers would nev...
- 15 Oct 2004 19:59
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise SINDEX: IAF and RSAF
- Replies: 144
- Views: 105723
shiv - i agree with you 400% onlee, however i was getting increasingly hacked off with esteemed colleagues ranting on and on about pilot failure, ground crew failure blah blah - all dhimmi style failures of short dark rice eating IAF onlee and so wanted to present some plausible mechanical failure s...
- 15 Oct 2004 19:26
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise SINDEX: IAF and RSAF
- Replies: 144
- Views: 105723
from the news reports it sounds like the following happened 1. at some point close to lift off, something drastic happened to the nosewheel 2. debris from the nose wheel flew off, probably got sucked into engine immediately and started causing serious problems 3. pilots judged that safest thing to d...
- 15 Oct 2004 15:31
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise SINDEX: IAF and RSAF
- Replies: 144
- Views: 105723
- 14 Oct 2004 16:30
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise SINDEX: IAF and RSAF
- Replies: 144
- Views: 105723
i didn't give an excuse - i gave a reason. the tests you are talking about are not routine, they are done during more exhaustive investigations and not on the line. the type of problem may also be a new one, and the procedures may not include looking for it - because no one knows what it is as yet. ...
- 14 Oct 2004 12:40
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise SINDEX: IAF and RSAF
- Replies: 144
- Views: 105723
it does'nt speak well for the ground staff at all. period. the very fact that a couple before this one had suffered from landing gear problems meant that the Mirages should have been inspected thoroughly. after all, these are among the most expensive fighters in the IAF inventory. no excuses can be...
- 13 Oct 2004 12:53
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise SINDEX: IAF and RSAF
- Replies: 144
- Views: 105723
If anyone has the AFM (or other) accident report - can they run a quick analysis on M2000 crashes? Has there been a recent upsurge? if bolt corrosion is a problem - it may be Indian conditions that make it worse than in other countries. a combination of 20 years of monsoons and lots of (takeoff and ...
- 06 Aug 2004 13:19
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
the 100 guns concept is not straightforward. if you have pre-located guns with enough stores to keep going thats one scenario, but you're losing many tactical advantages. if you dynamically cluster the guns as per need, then the logistics chain is complex. i dread to think how much transport and 'fe...
- 05 Aug 2004 18:42
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise Co-operative Cope Thunder
- Replies: 201
- Views: 130634
- 27 Jul 2004 12:58
- Forum: The Kargil Archive
- Topic: Kargil Revisited - II
- Replies: 181
- Views: 140085
Re: Kargil Revisited - Thread 3
Originally posted by Gerard: [QB "Clinton came as close as I had ever seen to blowing up in a meeting with a foreign leader," Finally Clinton threw in the big punch. He said he would call the press and lay the entire blame for failure of the meeting on Pakistan, and for good measure add t...
- 20 Jul 2004 12:59
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
One option for the IAF is to go the US/USSR route of tactical air and strategic air forces tac-air can be organised as per the army commands and be locked in to supporting each theatre, with 'swing capacity' to redeploy against other theatres as the situation warrants. strat-air, say the M2k(N-equiv...
- 19 Jul 2004 10:29
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
- Replies: 124
- Views: 100776
Re: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
midas c of g is not an issue, fuel would be moved around to balance out, and the automatic trim would kick in to keep the midas steady. i cannot imagine that something as big as the midas will not have auto trim
- 16 Jul 2004 16:36
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
- Replies: 124
- Views: 100776
Re: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
smaller span a/c like jags could be adversely affected by the wake turbulence from the midas, hence centreline position may not be an option for them. larger span a/c like the Su30's can probably manage ok on the probes question - someone was saying recently about French tankers having different fee...
- 07 Jul 2004 13:05
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
wyu - good points as always. I personally would like to see a discussion on UN peace keeping operations and how to make them successful. When I have some head space I'll start a new thread! Also, could forum members point to any analyses of Indian Operations in Sierra Leone and any comparisons to Rw...
- 06 Jul 2004 22:13
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Exercise Co-operative Cope Thunder
- Replies: 201
- Views: 130634
Re: Exercise Co-operative Cope Thunder
i am guessing that alternate routes would be hyderabad --> singapore(?) --> surabaya (landing rights?) --> (many storms) --> manila --> taipei (bad bad bad and big detour around China) --> seoul/tokyo (more storms) --> vladivostock --> elmendorf quite possibly a longer detour compared to the Europea...
- 06 Jul 2004 12:20
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
wyu - appreciate your insights on rwanda. this is way off topic, so lets park it here, but i agree - the whole episode is utterly shameful for the international community. dallaire himself comes in for (unfair?) criticism - he talks of lack of mandate and no interest from the security council... any...
- 05 Jul 2004 20:17
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
wyu - not sure about the belgians in rwanda as an example, as far as i recall, those poor buggers were out on a limb, no one could have helped them. not even the rest of the contingent... (happy to be corrected) as a contrast, read linda polman's account of a tanzanian company (UN) manning a refugee...
- 02 Jul 2004 17:23
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
well Niranjan, we need then to distinguish between strategic punitive action and tactical. In the latter, we destroy posts, perhaps slightly larger bases. for this only SF and arty are required. perhaps not all that different to today. for the former, we need something more devastating, like trappin...
- 02 Jul 2004 16:48
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
So, the IA with large manpower and some of the networking capability could operate a slightly different model, where command can be devolved partially, where firepower can be coordinated lower down and where the unit could work to a partially preassigned plan (not totally fluid) in the same way as S...
- 30 Jun 2004 21:29
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
- Replies: 124
- Views: 100776
Re: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
the PLAAF can focus a core of high quality opposition and the rest of the 'peasant airforce' can make an awful mess by being up there in vast numbers with their pitchforks to unhorse the knights...
- 30 Jun 2004 16:52
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
Niranjan Rao CS goes beyond that. "Safegaurd" has been re-defined as if we need to we will cross the border and do whatever it takes as long as the nuclear threshold is not crossed. CS is more than a military "response". It puts a lot of pressure on countries (like Japan) to pre...
- 30 Jun 2004 16:48
- Forum: The Kargil Archive
- Topic: Kargil Revisited - II
- Replies: 181
- Views: 140085
Re: Kargil Revisited - Thread 3
niranjan rao's prethink concept is important, shift to cold start thread? (see my point there)
- 30 Jun 2004 16:45
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: Cold Start: An analysis
- Replies: 277
- Views: 147947
Re: Cold Start: An analysis
Originally posted by wyu: This modification is radical ... for the Americans but the British and Canadians have been doing this for a very long time. Essentially, there is a push downwards from brgiade to battalion as the main combat echelon. is that because of the increased lethality of weapons de...
- 29 Jun 2004 21:10
- Forum: The Kargil Archive
- Topic: Kargil Revisited - II
- Replies: 181
- Views: 140085
Re: Kargil Revisited - Thread 3
Originally posted by ramana: I recall reading somewhere that there was a mutual 150km air exclusion zone near the LOC. I believe that wont be honored anymore. IMHumbleO there should be IAF redlines, on crossing which anything 150km of the LOC in that direction is fair game. i suggest the threshold ...
- 29 Jun 2004 20:28
- Forum: The Kargil Archive
- Topic: Kargil Revisited - II
- Replies: 181
- Views: 140085
Re: Kargil Revisited - Thread 3
can we reasonably conclude that in future cold start/response to kargils, we would automatically involve an air component to any response and not dither about the escalation problem?
- 29 Jun 2004 18:00
- Forum: Military Exercises Archive
- Topic: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
- Replies: 124
- Views: 100776
Re: IAF Jaguars & IL-78s in Italy
drogue fairings have soft edges since there is bound to be some banging around. lots of wake turbulence behind the tanker. wouldn't surprise me if things hit now and again
- 29 Jun 2004 16:36
- Forum: The Kargil Archive
- Topic: Kargil Revisited - II
- Replies: 181
- Views: 140085
Re: Kargil Revisited - Thread 3
does not surprise me that guard was let down. we are too trusting onlee. this is why abv has not forgiven muskrat