Search found 13 matches

by john chen
05 Dec 2002 20:09
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

To ATUL:
ATUL, I have questions to ask you. Please go to the new thread in the "Strategic Issues and International Relations" folder, titled as "India, China and Tibet". Thanks.
by john chen
04 Dec 2002 03:38
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

To chalukya and S.M Nair,
Please read www.tibet-china.org carefully. You can find answers there.

To S.M Nair,
Please read my articles pasted above. I have made it clear from the begining.
I can not talk abut this topic in this thread any more as requested by Ramana.
by john chen
03 Dec 2002 04:32
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

Hi,Manavendra,
Sorry to reply late. I am not a lama bhudist. I don't think he is living bhuda at all. I do not agree with china's policy to ban dalai's picture if this ban is really existed.
by john chen
03 Dec 2002 03:21
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

To Chalukya: First of all Mr Chen let me argue what historical claim China has over Tibet, Xinjiang, Inner Mongolia and Manchuria? Please refer to the site : http://www.paulnoll.com/China/Dynasty/history-maps-dynasty.html First of all, the maps are not accurate. In Han and Tang dynasties, the chines...
by john chen
03 Dec 2002 02:31
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

To chalukya: I am sorry that I made a mistake. There are only 9 countries signed land border dispute with china. Pakistan is not included. China/pakistan border is only a temporary one without any legal valid. It has to be talked again. All border agreements with former soviet countries was talked a...
by john chen
03 Dec 2002 01:40
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

India's democracy is superiorer than china's authorative. Howoever, china did not oppress minorities. They will be ok as long as they do not agitate independence. China's authorative local government in minority region did better than that of indians' in improving people's living standard, education...
by john chen
03 Dec 2002 01:11
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

Hi, Rajeev, Now that we have questioned China's occupation of several lands, its treatment of ethnic minorities, and its claims over Taiwan and Tibet, you have taken refuge in legalese. The land dispute between china and india is a legral problem instead of a moral problem. I in was in leagalism fro...
by john chen
02 Dec 2002 21:27
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

There are so many questions. I have no time to answer all of them. I can only answer the most important questions. First of all, I want to emphasize that the scientific way of thinking is a must even if we are not talking about science. To talk here, you’d better have a clear logic like a lawy...
by john chen
02 Dec 2002 06:11
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

To make this problem clear, we have to make a difference between some definitions. Both British India and India government recognized china has suzerainty instead of sovereignty on west tibet before 1950. The problem is what is the definition of suzerainty? What is the difference between it and sove...
by john chen
02 Dec 2002 04:07
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

My history is not so good, but it is my belief that the chinese claim on tibet is revenge!!!
Dear Mr. Shalav,
With a basic scientific way of thinking, I will never believe without proof. You suppose china is evil and take it as truth without prove it. I hope most indians are not like you.
by john chen
02 Dec 2002 03:53
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

First of all, can you enlighten us on what the claim of China is on Tibet? Once you vacate your forcible occupation of Tibet, and allow Tibet to be independent again, there will be no boundary dispute between China and India. You see, China does not have a border with India, Tibet does. Hello Rajee...
by john chen
02 Dec 2002 03:34
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

Unfortunately china has been unable to resolve its dispute with Taiwan too! Just like India has been unable to solve its disputes with Pakistan. I don't feel this is an appropriate comparison. India and all other countries recognize Pakistan as an independent country. India's confilct with Pakistan...
by john chen
02 Dec 2002 00:52
Forum: Military History Archive
Topic: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War
Replies: 224
Views: 57541

Re: Remembering a War: The 1962 Indo-China War

I am a chinese. Do you indians want to resolve the border conflict with china on the ground of justice? or you just want to beat china and occupy the land according to your will even if the land did not belong to you at all? If your answer is the latter, I have nothing to talk with you. But I want t...

Go to advanced search