Bharat Rakshak

shiv

Shiv, WHY SIR WILLIAM JONES GOT IT ALL WRONG, OR JONES’ ROLE IN HOW TO ESTABLISH LANGUAGE FAMILIES http://ehu.eus/ojs/index.php/ASJU/article/viewFile/4384/4329 A more accurate take on the history of linguistics. Thanks Arun. I have seen this one earlier One of the reasons why I think linguistics ha...

shiv

In the few weeks that he was in communication with me all that Vagheesh said was that there are steppe genes in India and that supports language spread. He is not interested in anything else. Mohammad is the Prophet and Allah is god and balls to what anyone else says. Amazing full circle science has...

shiv

tsarkar wrote: The left skid is broken and resting next to the rear MAWS.

True. Just noticed that

shiv

http://indiafacts.org/aryan-invasion-myth-21st-century-science-debunks-19th-century-indology/ The obvious retort is that those papers are invalidated by newer findings, that is the way science works , etc. etc. So what is the case here? The case is highlighted in red. That is most definitely not th...

shiv

I gave very similar arguments to my relatives and friends with lot of emotions . They are saying I have become a Hindu fundamentalist. If another person have come to the exact same conclusions as me than either I am right or both me and shiv are mad and "Hindu fundamentalists". make your ...

shiv

A series of short opinion pieces
https://theprint.in/talk-point/20-years ... r/57493/#4

shiv

We Indians are too science heavy and that is beginning to show. Our rishis are science people and we ignore the effect that the humanities have had on western science. We do this at out own peril. There is a great sentence that I can take from csaurabh's link above: https://mediocrityrulz.wordpress....

shiv

And third, we conclude that Early Bronze Age steppe pastoralists did not migrate into South Asia but that genetic evidence fits better with the Indo Iranian IE languages being brought to the region by descendants of Late Bronze Age steppe pastoralists ." Don't know how they can state the under...

shiv

I see Western academia on a losing wicket in the long term. I worry about certain aspects of that - for example I admire the advances in aerodynamics, materials and engineering that have come from the west and would hate to see all that slide into the slow degeneration that I see creeping over weste...

shiv

Good news. Vagheesh has blocked me on Twitter. The IE reference is fake but if he removes that steppe-IE ref his paper is destroyed. To that extent I am a mortal enemy of his paper :rotfl: Good Sorry to say "I told you so" Shiv. Vagheesh (and more importantly his handlers) have gleaned en...

shiv

Good news. Vagheesh has blocked me on Twitter. The IE reference is fake but if he removes that steppe-IE ref his paper is destroyed. To that extent I am a mortal enemy of his paper

Good

shiv

About the Rudra incident: https://twitter.com/rahulsinghx/status/993154080657862657 My sources say dust kicked up, brown out conditions. And while carrying out sit down, extra pressure came on one skid. If you brighten that dark image of the helo from the back you can see that the left skid has sunk...

shiv

"super radar" sounds like marketing language

shiv

Bunkum Feku language rode horse from steppe theory gets a kick in the teeth https://twitter.com/IndianInterest/status/994580418006536192 We find no evidence of steppe ancestry in Bronze Age Anatolia from when Indo-European languages are attested there." In other words, Reich et al.'s claim that...

shiv

Would you know how come all humans are descended from africans and yet our languages have no memory of an african homeland? Would the ASI/ANI authors know the answer to this? This is easy. We don't remember our African homeland just like we don't recall our steppe-fathers' homeland. But brain memor...

shiv

^^Do you see how linguistic mchods know next to nothing about so many languages but they simply include them among IE or cook up and "reconstruct" them to fit them into IE. The biggest and fake-est reconstructions have been done Using Sanskrit. We have been taken for a ride too long. They ...

shiv

Arun - specially for you, From Beekes Comparative Indo European Linguistics https://archive.org/details/ComparativeIndoEuropeanLinguistics Luwic Seven languages are more closely related to each other, the Luwic languages. Cuneiform Luwian is known from some 200 pieces of clay tablet from the Boğazkö...

shiv

And I am sure you have heard linguists pompously declare that physical proof or "attestation' is required for languages . Even Vagheesh declared how Greek and other European languages are attested. OK then let there be no varying standards set by linguists. There is no "attestation" o...

shiv

Some stuff on Phrygians: http://www.maravot.com/Phrygian.html Interesting how all those peoples mentioned in the above ramble remembered that they came from somewhere else. The other thing is that the amount of language evidence available is very small. Just fragments You can see a hint of that in ...

shiv

I have come to the conclusion that Comparative Linguistics is one of the most worthless things to have developed in 200 years. They have done nothing other than create dense, unreadable texts and have proven nothing, have explained nothing without cooking up facts of using circular logic. In the lo...

shiv

I have come to the conclusion that Comparative Linguistics is one of the most worthless things to have developed in 200 years. They have done nothing other than create dense, unreadable texts and have proven nothing, have explained nothing without cooking up facts of using circular logic. In the lon...

shiv

I had a basic question that perhaps someone can educate me on. What was the Steppe area and civilization like? Seems like they were nomads and not very civilized and didn't do agriculture or have rivers/coastline etc. Like Mongolians in Mongolia. So how could a very complex language like the mother...

shiv

On the absence of the Saraswati: https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Indo-Eurasian_research/conversations/messages/17571 When the river that flowed along the Ghagghar-Hakra channel was mountain-fed, it was the Sutlej flowing along this course, there was no Sutlej river. Then the Sutlej switched ove...

shiv

Shiv, how much do "Avestan" and Sanskrit differ, e.g., compared to Hindi Brij Bhasha and Khariboli dialects? (Khariboli = "standard" Hindi, Brij Bhasha examples: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braj_Bhasha#Basic_Phrases_of_the_Brij_Bhasha_(Sample_sentences) ) Arun - I cannot claim...

shiv

Total and complete fabrication of history by mary Boyce in her work on "Indo-Iranian" fakeology

shiv

Lies made up by Anthropologist turned Historian David Anthony in his book "Horse, wheel and language" to connect Steppe with Rig Veda

shiv

One consistent tactic used by AIT is to diss any information that people dig up form India that shows up AIT. Is it so difficult to dig up dirt about philologists, linguists and their faking? It is not. The reason why no Indian argues against software development or microchips is that they are based...

shiv

I will deliberately link again all my articles questioning the PADA of AIT "PADA" = PIE, Aryan, Dravidian, Avestan The 4 Hoaxes That Made Sanskrit “Come” To India http://www.swatantramag.in/?p=2087 Aryans And Dravidians: An Invention Of Racist Nineteenth Century Scholars https://swarajyama...

shiv

The same guy appeared on Twitter and I had a long series of Tweets telling him what I thought Oh Boy, I think Italian AITwalla. I think I have run into him multiple times ...a long time ago. What is funny about his post is that while he reaches exactly opposite conclusion (namely - Grand Sarasvati ...

shiv

https://twitter.com/subnut/status/992225310451134466 Retired Submariner - Vice Adm Arun Mumar Singh about Spratlys Arun Kumar Singh ‏ @subnut 31m31 minutes ago Fiery Cross Reef, Subi Reef, Mischief Reef in Spratly islands, maybe "unsinkable aircraft carriers", but they can be "defange...

shiv

Files related to Iron age and Iron in Rig Veda. Use as needed
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1X2AIf ... J6izAkXeaz
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1xxIEx ... P2PEcDPda6
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1ECCfE ... xJRWzURmWh

shiv

I have a warning to offer. Shiv, A-Gupta, Hiranyareta, and others who are engaging all kinds of people on Twitter these days. At great length and in great detail. I understand the temptation to engage these AIT-wallahs directly at the first opportunity that appears (Twitter). It can seem empowering...

shiv

A_Gupta wrote:On the absence of the Saraswati:
https://groups.yahoo.com/neo/groups/Ind ... ages/17571

The same guy appeared on Twitter and I had a long series of Tweets telling him what I thought

shiv

I must add to this. When confronted with a smashed aircraft in a million pieces, no flight data recorder and a dead pilot the pieces are reassembled to look for any detectable issues and correlated with communications, radar data if any and weather. If nothing else is found it becomes pilot error. ...

shiv

My new article
P.I.E. or LIE: Why Linguistics Is Not A Science

shiv

Singha wrote:Avro vulcan is a giant

Check A-5 Vigilante - carried borne

shiv

From what I recollect from MOD statement from official COI most of Mig crashes are related to pilot error. I must add to this. When confronted with a smashed aircraft in a million pieces, no flight data recorder and a dead pilot the pieces are reassembled to look for any detectable issues and corre...

shiv

Here is how our history is cooked up for us coolies. This is Mary Boyce on exactly what steppe migrants were doing while heading to India. She mentions Veda so she must be a scholar

shiv

Arun did you see Vagheesh's reply regarding Y haplotype?

shiv

Relative sizes. Tejas is there
https://twitter.com/CcibChris/status/991582135466315776

Search found 34082 matches