Bharat Rakshak

Hari Sud

Vivek You are doing a very good job. Sadhanshu - stay out of it. Again Vivek, back to your reply. Here is what normally should have happened. When Delhi became target of Chinese bombers, within minutes the PM, the President, the Cabinet, important officials, immediately go to the underground command...

Hari Sud

When Chinese decided to attack Delhi, specific order came from the Chinese Prime Minister. That was not a land attack. It was an air attack. In India the armed forces command and control rests with the Prime Minister, cabinet with written order issued by the President. The latter is commander in chi...

Hari Sud

Defence Minister ordering an attack on Tibet, without checking with the Prime Minister and National Defence Council........Ha Ha Ha.

More fiction than possible realism.

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

Vivek

What about the battle of Twang?

By now, the Chinese tanks have reached the vicinity.

Hari

Hari Sud

Shankar Would you like to begin your long awaited Indo - US Conflict scenario of 2020. It will be fun. There is a need of this scenario as not much is known about nuclear war preparations. You being a high intellectual can visualize this possibility. Good Luck and begin as soon as possible. My sugge...

Hari Sud

Additional military minds like CalvinH are needed to make these battle scenarios a bit more sensible. Above, CalvinH raises good points. Till now, all scenarios have been win - win types in which India suffers some damage but inflicts a huge damage. Future battles will unlikely be that type. Again, ...

Hari Sud

Now the Vivek scenario is reaching far beyond any imagination. Till now everything was fine. But to assume that rail link to Twang in the future; highly unlikely in next 50 years. Terrain rises and falls 19,000 feet and 7000 feet. Railways do not do that kind of slope today or in the distant future....

Hari Sud

Bravo

The battle of Twang will be fought all over again.

Last time in 1962, Brigadier Hoshiar Singh lost the town and his life along with countless soldiers.

Let us see how it unfolds in the imaginaery scenario of Vivek.

Hari

Hari Sud

Shankar

Where about is the great fall in the Brahamaputra where the river drops close to 2000 feet. British always wished to find it and few National Geogrpahy teams in last 20 years went to locate it.

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

Guys Can you hold off on your stuff for a few days. Let Vivek, finish what he has started. It is likely to be a short missible war with horrific losses on both sides and ends in a draw with India having a slightly upper hand. All of you can fill in the blanks on any other possible scenario as soon a...

Hari Sud

Masterly scenario building;

Now Smerch is about to go into action. Before that UAV and target drones have been unleashed.

Good work.

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

ksmahesh Thank you. It is difficult to read the outcome of a major air battle in a little sentence, which you quoted. In fact it is a major IAF victory and a major Chinese defeat. It is to be stated like that. That is where the author should have elaborated. If I were Vievek, writing the next post, ...

Hari Sud

My error duly apologize.

Can somebody point me to the post where it is said that Chinese bombers are turning back.

Hari

Hari Sud

I withdraw. It is my mistake. I did not read about the fate of remaining bombers. That in itself is a victory for IAF.

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

Vivek

Stay out of discussion and explaining your previous post.

Stick with your own thinking process and continue with the next post.

There will be others in the BR community who will know enough to answere the questions.

Continue

Good Luck

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

These scenarios too good to be true. No bomber squadron ever takes off without a fighter escort ahead of it. In this case it is behind it. Very unlikely. Chinese will first target the ECM 707, before sending the bombers. All missiles hitting the target, that means that the Chinese pilots are dodos. ...

Hari Sud

Four down twenty more to go.

That is tall order for four mirages.

Some miisiles will reach Delhi, so hold on, there is lot more to come.

Hari

Hari Sud

Way too much to read and digest in Shankar's background notes.

Right now attention is focussed on inbound Chinese bombers, which have just cleared the Himalayas (last Vivek's Post) and as per Shankar, the new missile defence system.

Let us see how it plays out in next post of Vivek.

Hari

Hari Sud

Shankar All the above accounts is true but not always what really happened. A lot of officers after Hendersonbrooks inquiry started to tell their version. True that Thagla Ridge, even fall of Bomdila was a political failure. But military failed too. Chinese bypassed the Indian positions after Thagla...

Hari Sud

Thank you Shankar for information on Chusul.

Vivek continue - Good work.

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

Shankar Understood. Vivek's and prior to that your own were stories / dramas were presented in parts. The reader always waited for the next lot. It is fun, waiting for next, what? When an additional view point in thrown in and if it is a distraction then it does not help. Also the writer reads it, i...

Hari Sud

Hello Shankar A good history lessen on Tibet occupation. I am missing the point in your post. Hari Sud (Note:- I know about Tibeteans streaming across the border in Lahul & Spiti in 1962. I was one of the NCC cadet from Chandigrah sent to Rohtang to escort supply trains (mules to be precise) and...

Hari Sud

Good work Vivek

What is your background on the subject matter.

You seemed to be well aware of latest technical details of a number of miliatry assets on both side of the border.

If you are still serving in the armed forces, then you need not disclose it.

Thanks

Hari Sud
Toronto

Hari Sud

Hello guys Vivek_Ahuja is dealing with a new angle i.e. China scenario. He is doing a good job. I like it. Shankar deals with Pakistan scenarios. He has in last two years enthralled the readers. I am his fan. If both of them post one after the other, it will be confusing. So in my opinion if Vivek c...

Hari Sud

vivek_ahuja Can I give you advice my friend. Never reply back the critics after you made your post. There is no need to explain your thought process. If somebody points an error in your post, then remember it for future. Otherwise you will spend needless time duelling with the readers. This BR site...

Hari Sud

Gentlemen I am nearing completion of Part 5 of Shankar's scenarios. It is a massive 180 page edit. I have only done the first edit. It took me three weeks. It is much better readable, but not yet at the same level as Part 2 was. Usually in a major edit job, it has to be done a few times. I am not pr...

Hari Sud

Gentlemen I am nearing completion of Part 5 of Shankar's scenarios. It is a massive 180 page edit. I have only done the first edit. It took me three weeks. It is much better readable, but not yet at the same level as Part 2 was. Usually in a major edit job, it has to be done a few times. I am not pr...

Hari Sud

Please e-mail me your request at:

hsud@rogers.com

Thank you

Hari Sud

Hari Sud

Gentlemen Edited version of Shankar's scenario Part 2 is ready. This version mantains sanctity of the Shankar's writing but has an added flavor of a bit more experienced writing and narration. Shankar has gone thru it and he likes it. Other parts are being worked on. Please sign up for your copy. Th...

Hari Sud

Hi Shankar

Why is the combined force invding Gawadr port.

In your posts in and around Nov 30th, Pakistani nuclear capability is completely destroyed. They are no longer any threat to anybody, hence why risk invasion of Gwadar.

Hari

Hari Sud

Vivek Ahuja

Good story line, but too long a post. I was lost in the verbage as paragraphs seemed longer than needed.

Strip some of the excess fat in the verbage and you have a good story line.

Hari Sud

Toronto

Hari Sud

Thank you Shankar

Hari

Hari Sud

Hello Shankar A reader few days back posted a suggestion that it is better for you to switch from scenarios in the immediate future to scenarios in about 10 years time. He backed up his suggestion that by that time, re-arming of India with e.g. LCA, MIG - 35/F-18/Eurofighter, Smerch, tracked artille...

Hari Sud

I have completely lost the above story.

Why were the Pakistani Mirages with nuclear bombs launched?

What was the provocation?

hari

Hari Sud

Acharya Tell me more about Lulu publishing. In an earlier post you had recommended to use this service for publishing. I wish to know more. Especially any copyright infrigement in case Shankar's BR scenarios are published. BR management keeps mantaining a deafening silence on the subject. We have to...

Hari Sud

Vivek_Ahuja

You are doing fine.

Just make your scenario a bit shorter to read.

Also deal with one subject only in one post. Otherwise it becomes too confusing and too much to remember.

Carry on!!!

Cheers

Hari Sud
Toronto

Hari Sud

Hello, Hello, Hello Rakesh, Ramana, Anybody of BR Management A portion of edit work with pictures and maps of Shankar's scenario is ready. It has to be posted for easy access somewhere in the BR website. It is the MS Word version. It runs into 75 pages. Shankar has read the edit draft. Please sugges...

Hari Sud

Guys Please do not fret about Shankar's writing. All thinkers and writers have the same problem. Tolstoy wrote and rewrote same passages many times and then hired others to recheck. Nehru when he wrote "Discovery Of India" asked his fellow inmates in the Ahmednagar Fort Prison like Pant, R...

Hari Sud

Hello Parshu

Shankar's writing of last three years are being edited for the English as you mentioned.

Just hold on for a little bit longer. Things will be a bit more orderly.

Thanks

Hari Sud
Toronto

Hari Sud

Forum Adminstrator Need a few directions A bunch of us are busy putting together all Shankar's scenarios. Once completed, what would you like us to do? Suggest, reserve space somewhere on this website that the text and the HTML version could be placed. I also wish you to recognise work done by all t...

Search found 183 matches