shiv wrote: I just took that to the limit and thought of what a man with two Rupees might put into an LeT box and wondered if he was really doing that with great enthusiasm. Most of the time the information that I get exposed to tells me that a man who has only 2 Rupees - or for that matter a man who has only 20 Rupees is normally looking for more for himself because that money will last less than a day. Giving away even part of that that money "willingly" and "voluntarily" to "charity" is counter intuitive. And the fact that coercion occurs is documented.
The problem with this analysis is that it considers a snapshot and extrapolates the instantaneous image in that snapshot, backwards and forwards in time (when there's no basis for doing so.)
Consider the Paki abdul with only 2 Rupees to his name. I don't think he will balk at giving 1 Rupee to the LeT... in fact he might happily give both rupees to the LeT. Why? Because his economic condition is such that, a fortnight later when he has 0 Rupees... it is to JuD kitchens that he will take his family for free naan-kheema. What is he going to do with PKR 2.00 otherwise? Buy one glass of tea? What other investment is worth making, for him? Paki govt never cared about people like him and will never care. JuD provides schooling for his son, even if it as a Madrassa school... meals when his family is hungry... the protection of a "like-minded group" that provides a sense of security for the economically disempowered classes of any society. All he has to do in exchange is commit himself to the idea of Jihad against India. So why wouldn't he do it gladly?
But is it only poor Abduls who can thus be convinced to happily part with their money for jihad to kill Hindus? Not at all. We talk about the "growing middle class" of Pakistan... who are they, and how did they get there? Were they provided economic opportunity by the state policies of Pakistan? Of course not. Many of them, however, got their first loans to start a paan-beedi shop or buy a donkey from schemes run by JuD type groups. Why would they begrudge JuD/LeT a fair share of their earnings now? They have always received much better returns from these donations than they ever got from paying taxes to the Paki govt. Adopting the JuD's worldview and hatred of the Kafir is hardly a big deal to ask of them.
The point is, LeT/JuD sets a socio-economic agenda domestically within Pakistan, and provides the impetus at many levels of society to follow that agenda. The agenda is to provide funds and recruits for jihad so that green flag can fly over red fort. That can be achieved in many ways.
A certain percentage of Pakis, maybe small but growing with each successive generation of Madrassa graduates, happily follows the agenda and even proselytizes the agenda to others. They buy the hatred of Hindus and India hook line & sinker, and commit themselves physically and mentally to the cause.
A much larger percentage of Pakis goes along, maybe partially because of a vague notion that Hindus and India are bad, but mainly because JuD is fulfilling programs of social and economic upliftment which benefit them... a responsibility from which the Paki govt, RAPE and upper-middle classes have consciously abdicated themselves.
Between the first two categories you have an overwhelming majority of Pakis who fund the LeT without any coercion whatsoever. Coercion is only needed for the miniscule number of "principled" types who have (a) somehow stayed immune to 50 years of propaganda demonizing India and Hindus, (b) actually believe that terrorism in the cause of Jihad is worse than the "atrocities" it claims to address, and (c) are so committed to ideas a and b that they would happily forgo the social and economic benefits of the Tanzeem Welfare State.
How many Pakis are in that third category? Of these, how many will further be swayed by only the most passive forms of "coercion"... social ostracism and marginalization, etc. as opposed to a knife at the throat?
Seriously... you cannot "coerce" a large segment of the population, for a long period of time, to give away their money for jihad against India if this is against their will or sensibilities. That sentiment is part of a larger package offered by the JuD/LeT in the unchallenged agenda they set across a huge section of Pakistani society. The vast majority of poor and middle-class Pakis very happily participates in that agenda for one reason or the other, with no need for coercion.
And no amount of concessions like "FDI" or "electricity" to the RAPE... no amount of compromises on "Siachen, J&K and Sir Creek" to the TSPA, is going to make one bit of difference to this.