India -Singapore News and Discussion

The Strategic Issues & International Relations Forum is a venue to discuss issues pertaining to India's security environment, her strategic outlook on global affairs and as well as the effect of international relations in the Indian Subcontinent. We request members to kindly stay within the mandate of this forum and keep their exchanges of views, on a civilised level, however vehemently any disagreement may be felt. All feedback regarding forum usage may be sent to the moderators using the Feedback Form or by clicking the Report Post Icon in any objectionable post for proper action. Please note that the views expressed by the Members and Moderators on these discussion boards are that of the individuals only and do not reflect the official policy or view of the Bharat-Rakshak.com Website. Copyright Violation is strictly prohibited and may result in revocation of your posting rights - please read the FAQ for full details. Users must also abide by the Forum Guidelines at all times.
SSridhar
Forum Moderator
Posts: 25097
Joined: 05 May 2001 11:31
Location: Chennai

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by SSridhar »

Rapid & significant developments.

India, Singapore for increased activity in Strait of Malacca - Dinakar Peri, The Hindu
Singapore is keen on expanding maritime cooperation with India in the Malacca straits and the Andaman Sea, Defence Minister Dr. Ng Eng Hen said on Wednesday.

“We all recognise Strait of Malacca and the Indian ocean are key sea lanes of communication... I think I speak on behalf of both countries, we want to see more participation and activity in both Strait of Malacca and Andaman Sea,” he said at the joint press conference along with his Indian counterpart Nirmala Sitharaman after the second Defence Ministerial dialogue.

These comments are significant
as the Strait of Malacca is a critical choke point for global commerce and is seen by China as a vulnerability for its energy supplies.

Early this year, the Indian Navy has permanently deployed a frontline warship at the mouth of the straits to keep an eye on increasing Chinese movements in the Indian Ocean.

Dr. Ng said it makes sense for countries to cooperate not only to establish maritime security but to maintain freedom of navigation because “we know it is lifeline for economies”.


He also welcomed the Indian Navy to use their naval facilities for operational turnaround.

“I not only support but I would encourage the Indian Navy to visit Changi naval base more often. The bilateral naval agreement has a provision for mutual logistical support,” he stated.

This would allow greater Indian presence near the contested waters of South China Sea. {at both ends} The ministerial dialogue saw the conclusion of India-Singapore bilateral agreement for navy cooperation which will allow cooperation in maritime security, joint exercises, temporary deployments from each other’s naval facilities and mutual logistics support.{Another LEMOA?}


The two ministers also agreed to institutionalise naval engagements in the shared maritime space, including establishing maritime exercises with like-minded countries and ASEAN partners {Singapore will head the ASEAN in 2018} , a joint statement said.

“We will exercise and patrol in your waters as you do in ours. We try to economise and support each other,” Dr. Ng added.
SSridhar
Forum Moderator
Posts: 25097
Joined: 05 May 2001 11:31
Location: Chennai

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by SSridhar »

Eye on China, India and Singapore ink naval pact - Rajat Pandit, ToI
India and Singapore on Wednesday inked a naval pact to majorly crank up their maritime security cooperation with access to each other's bases, while reiterating the need for all to respect freedom of navigation and trade in international waters in the backdrop of China's aggressive and expansionist behavior in the Asia Pacific region.

The naval cooperation agreement to bolster maritime security, joint exercises, "temporary deployments from each other's naval facilities" and mutual logistics support was inked after the delegation-level talks between defence minister Nirmala Sitharaman and her Singapore counterpart Dr Ng Eng Hen here in the morning.

Easy access to the Singapore port, with refueling and berthing facilities, will serve to enhance the operational reach of Indian warships and aircraft east of the Malacca Strait, which is a critical choke point for China's ever-expanding energy supplies. It fits into India's overall "Act East" policy to deepen military ties with ASEAN countries like Singapore, Vietnam, Myanmar, Malaysia and Indonesia as a counter to China.

India, in turn, will provide naval practice and logistics facilities to Singapore, which will include live firing drills in the Andaman Sea, to add to similar services already being provided to the army and air force of the city-state for the last 10 years
, as was reported by TOI on Tuesday.

Appreciating India's "leading role" in the Indian Ocean Region, Dr Ng said Singapore would "encourage" more Indian warships to come its shores, help in further securing the sea lanes of communication towards the Andaman Sea and the Strait of Malacca, expand and institutionalize maritime exercises with like-minded regional and ASEAN partners.

"We want to see more participation, cooperation and activity in both the Strait of Malacca and the Andaman Sea," said Dr Ng, adding that it was crucial to join forces against terrorism, chemical, biological and radiological threats.

Sitharaman, in turn, said the two countries had decided to expand overall defence ties and were "strongly committed" to boosting cooperation in tackling transnational security threats, especially terrorism.

The two countries also decided to renew the bilateral army pact, under which facilities are provided to Singapore for exercises of mechanized forces at Babina and artillery at Deolali ranges, when it ends next year.
The bilateral air force one, under which F-16 fighters from Singapore regularly exercise at the Kalaikunda airbase in West Bengal, was renewed for another five years in January this year.

Singapore's proposal to expand the "Code of Unplanned Encounters at Sea" to all ADMM-Plus (ASEAN Defence Ministers' Meeting-Plus) countries as well as to establish guidelines for air encounters between military aircraft in order to reduce the risk of miscalculations also figured in the discussions.

On regional security, the two countries reiterated the importance of maintaining maritime freedom of navigation in international waters, right of passage and overflight, unimpeded commerce and access to resources in accordance with the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea.
SSridhar
Forum Moderator
Posts: 25097
Joined: 05 May 2001 11:31
Location: Chennai

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by SSridhar »

Such a long journey: Merlion on the Ganges - Ravi Velloor, Straits Times
Watching Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong emerge swiftly from the official Mercedes-Benz limousine to an extended hand-clasp with Mr Narendra Modi, as the Indian leader waited for his guests at his nation's 69th Republic Day parade, it was impossible to escape a sense of wonderment at the long road Singapore and India have travelled to reach where they are today.

Mr Lee led the Asean delegation to New Delhi last week when India, in an unprecedented gesture, invited all 10 Asean heads of government to be guests of honour at its annual celebration to mark its creation as a republic in 1950, three years after winning independence from Britain.

While it was fortuitous that Singapore should be in the chair when New Delhi made this strong signal to South-east Asia, it was perhaps fitting that it should have been so. For no nation has been so enthusiastic a cheerleader of India's contemporary national story, or its deepening alliance with Asean, as the smallest nation in the grouping - Singapore.

A quarter century ago when then Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong began showing interest in the Indian growth story, following India's economic liberalisation of 1991, there were plenty of doubters on this island. The world, then in the thrall of the Asian Tigers, had little time for India. Neither did the Asian Tigers, themselves.

India's problems were legion. Periodic cycles of social strife, an inward-looking establishment and a reflexive distaste for free-market principles came to count for a near stagnation that was often dismissed derisively as the "Hindu rate of growth". Indian ministers visiting Singapore were often fobbed off with a cursory meeting with an obliging minister of state.

SINGAPORE SPRINGBOARD

Then, Mr Narasimha Rao, who unexpectedly rose to power in 1991 after the assassination of once-and-future PM Rajiv Gandhi, began to speak of a Look East Policy. Looking around, his gaze fell upon Singapore as the springboard for that effort. Unsurprisingly, given its track record of often being first to spot opportunity, it was tiny, Chinese-majority Singapore that was first off the mark.

In early 1993, then Minister George Yeo would lead a large Singapore delegation for a tour of India, and turn in a positive report to Cabinet.

Later that year, a bunch of Indian industrialists, gathered under the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) banner, arrived in Singapore to pitch the Indian growth story. Granted an appointment with then PM Goh, they found a keen-eared leader who, ending the meeting, asked what their evening plans were. Finding the delegation was at a loose end, he gathered a bunch of his ministers to share a meal with them. The rest is history.

Four months later, Mr Goh himself would be the chief guest at the 1994 Republic Day. As he departed for New Delhi, Mr Goh's comment that he hoped to "spark a mild India fever" would be heard around the world. It was the first significant endorsement of the India story from a respected global figure and Indians were delirious over it. Years later, Mr Goh would muse that he would not know at the time that his words would set off a Singapore fever in India.

Today, that "fever" has manifested itself in no less than 8,000 Indian companies locating themselves on the island, the largest foreign representation here. Indian tourists last year edged out Malaysians to take No. 3 spot on the island and more than 230 flights depart Singapore weekly for Indian cities, and the list grows by every half-year.

STRATEGIC BALANCE

Strategically, the two have a tight relationship. In 1988, when Mr George Yeo was director of joint operations and planning at the Ministry of Defence, he led a delegation to study India's tri-service National Defence Academy in Pune before settling on the design for a new Singapore Armed Forces Safti Military Institute. Six years later, the two would conduct their first anti-submarine warfare exercise, leading to a defence relationship so close that today, the SAF is the only foreign force allowed to train its artillery, infantry and air force in India on a semi-permanent basis. {In fact, when Singapore left the Malayan Federation in c. 1963, it aksed India to provide support for its armed forces which India refused at that time, after which it turned to Israel}

It is perhaps a measure of India's consideration to Singapore as both Asean chair and the coordinating country for Asean-China ties that New Delhi conspicuously avoided rolling out a float on Arunachal Pradesh, an Indian state claimed in its entirety by China, at this year's parade. Instead, there were floats from other north-eastern Indian states, some whose boundaries touch Myanmar. The broader message India sought to convey was of its peaceful rise, of tolerance, celebration of diversity and historic cultural and religious links with the region.

Years ago, Mr Lee Kuan Yew said that without India, there would be no South-east Asia, only a Greater China and that while India, or Asean, may not count for too much on the global stage, together they could be a counterweight to China. Perhaps that is the reason that Singapore began pushing for a larger Indian role in the region carrying Asean, always happy to see a balance of forces, along with it.

That hand-holding saw Mr Goh Chok Tong proposing full Dialogue Partner status for India during an informal meeting of the 1994 Asean Summit, and New Delhi becoming Asean's fifth Dialogue Partner the following year. When Asean planned the first East Asia Summit in 2005, it was Singapore that midwifed Indian participation at the inaugural, prevailing over the views of some who thought it was premature for India to be at the table. {That was China which opposed us} Typically for Singapore, it conveyed that happy news to New Delhi without fanfare - a mere two-line e-mailed message of confirmation handed to the relevant desk in New Delhi by an embassy official.

Over the years, India's ties with Asean have expanded to as many as 30 platforms for cooperation, including an annual leaders summit and seven ministerial dialogues. In addition, India participates actively in Asean-led platforms, such as the Asean Regional Forum and the Asean Defence Ministers Meeting Plus. A significant bend in the road is expected in the relationship when PM Modi delivers the keynote address at this year's Shangri-La Dialogue, the first time an Indian leader has got the privilege.

India's strategic engagement with Asean is set to tighten; it is building up its half of the Andaman chain of islands as a significant defence outpost, something that will make it virtually a South-east Asian power. And there is reason to expect that its ties with two significant Asean militaries - Vietnam and Indonesia - are poised to intensify.

For the first three years of his rule, Mr Modi's advice to his foreign office was to not show its hand overmuch. Last week in New Delhi, I got the distinct impression that India was ready for a bigger profile in East Asia and more importantly, sensed that the sentiment was reciprocated.


UNFINISHED BUSINESS

Thus, the Asean-India Commemorative Summit held last week in New Delhi was based on the theme of "shared values, common destiny". The Delhi Declaration issued at the summit's end encompasses a vision that stretches from cooperation in maritime affairs and tackling natural disasters to preserving the common heritage and ensuring the rule of law in matters of navigation and overflight.

That said, there is much unfinished business between India and Asean. For one thing, while India's ties with peninsular Asean are strengthening by the day, there is significant work to be done by New Delhi to build similar linkages to both maritime, and continental Asean, particularly the CLMV states (Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar and Vietnam).

The elephantine issue is trade. At its current pace of growth, there is simply no chance of Asean-India bilateral trade touching the targeted US$200 billion ($263 billion) by 2022. But, for trade to get a push, Asean may need to pay some heed to India's plaint that there must also be give on Asean's side when it comes to services, an area where India enjoys some competitive advantages, before it can sign on to a "comprehensive" economic partnership agreement.

Notably, the Delhi Declaration does speak of a "comprehensive" accord. In the interests of pushing the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) through, it may be well worth seeing if at least a part of the Indian demands could be met. Likewise, it is in India's interest to drop its reservations over RCEP and view it from the prism of the larger strategic picture.

It is important to keep India onside for another reason. Some sections of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) are talking of extending the quadrilateral security talks - which group the US, Japan, Australia and India - to trade and investment. That effectively, would shut out China - and Asean - while offering the US and Japan unfettered access to the vast Indian market.

While this is mere talk for now, it would fly in the face of New Delhi's commitment to honour Asean centrality in the evolving regional architecture.


A decade and a half ago, when Singapore was in the throes of the tortuously negotiated Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement with India, then Trade Minister Yeo's advice to his team was to stay patient - "Like the Ganges, India will ultimately find its way to the sea".

But the times are changing and the strategic sands of Asia shift by the minute. Both India, and Asean, must realise they cannot afford to move to cosmic rhythms any more. And it perhaps falls to the Merlion to nudge the process along.
JTull
BRF Oldie
Posts: 3128
Joined: 18 Jul 2001 11:31

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by JTull »

Wonder when desi journos will write such articles that touch on past, present and future with under-currents of strategic vision.
chola
BRF Oldie
Posts: 5136
Joined: 16 Dec 2002 12:31
Location: USA

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by chola »

JTull wrote:Wonder when desi journos will write such articles that touch on past, present and future with under-currents of strategic vision.
Ravi is about as desi a name as you can get. lol.

But I understand your point. You mean a desi still living in Bharat.
SSridhar
Forum Moderator
Posts: 25097
Joined: 05 May 2001 11:31
Location: Chennai

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by SSridhar »

India, Singapore agree to deepen economic and defence ties - PTI
Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his Singaporean counterpart Lee Hsien Loong today agreed to deepen the bilateral economic ties and build on defence cooperation as they called for a peaceful, open, and friendly maritime environment in the Indo-Pacific region.

The two leaders also witnessed an exchange of Memorandums of Understanding in numerous fields, including the training of public service officials, cyber security, narcotics control and logistics cooperation between the two navies.


Prime Minister Modi that the strategic partnership between India and Singapore has stood the test of time in real sense.

"We have been able to conclude successfully the second review of Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement but we agreed this is not just our target and goal but this only means to an end," Modi said in a joint press statement after holding wide-ranging discussions with Lee.

"Our officials will soon begin discussions on upgrading and reforming this agreement," he added.

He hailed the close defence cooperation between the two countries and welcomed the completion of the logistics agreement between the two navies.

"In the coming times, dealing with cyber security and extremism and terrorism will be important areas of our cooperation," the prime minister said.


Modi and Lee also exchanged views on the regional and global challenges and reiterated their principled position on maritime security and expressed commitment to 'Rules Based' Order. The two leaders also agreed on the need to maintain an open, stable and fair international trade regime.

"We also agreed for a peaceful, open, and friendly maritime environment in the Indo-Pacific region," Modi said.

On his part, Lee said the bilateral defence ties have grown stronger.

"Our defence ties have strengthened, our navies have signed an agreement today on logistics cooperation and will also celebrate 25th anniversary of annual Singapore-India maritime bilateral exercise this year," Lee said.


Modi said Singapore has always been a source of foreign direct investment for India and also investments in foreign countries. It has also been a favourite destination for Indian investments abroad, he added.

"I am happy to note that Indian companies use Singapore as a spring board for not only this country but for the entire ASEAN region. For Singaporean companies, as India develops, opportunities are coming up," he said.

Recalling his meeting with CEOs yesterday, Modi said he was happy to see that top executives of many important companies looking at India with confidence.

Modi said the air traffic between India and Singapore is growing rapidly and both countries will enter into a new 'Air Service Agreement' soon.

He said the international launch of RuPay, BHIM and UPI based remittance app in Singapore yesterday represented Digital India initiative and the renewed partnership between the two sides.

Lee said Indian tourists will be able to use their RuPay cards for electronic payments at Changi airport and selected operators across Singapore.

Modi, who arrived here yesterday on the last leg of his three-nation visit, earlier made a courtesy call on President Halimah Yacob after a welcome ceremony at the Istana where he was given a guard of honour.

"Prime Minister Modi was accorded a ceremonial welcome on his arrival at Istana - Presidential Palace of Singapore. Millennia old ties now powered by partnership in innovation and technology," Ministry of External Affairs Spokesperson Raveesh Kumar tweeted.

Modi and Yacob exchanged views to strengthen bilateral relations and explored further cooperation in the flagship initiatives of the government.

"Close ties rooted in commercial, cultural and people to people links. Prime Minister Modi called on President of Singapore Halimah Yacob," Kumar said.
Neshant
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4852
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by Neshant »

SSridhar wrote:India, Singapore agree to deepen economic and defence ties
China has been trying to overthrow the govt of Singapore since the mid 60s to setup a Thailand type quazi-dictatorship aligned to their interests.

Lee Kwan Yew managed to steer his country through that mess aligning instead with US/UK/Australia.
He jailed a shitload of Communist party goons China was trying to instigate to formulate a "revolution".

He begged Philippines not to close down the USN's base at Subic Bay knowing what the implications of that would be.
The Filipinos foolishly did so anyways.
That was the only force that kept China's expansion in check.
Once that was gone, the whole region has been paying the price ever since.
SSridhar
Forum Moderator
Posts: 25097
Joined: 05 May 2001 11:31
Location: Chennai

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by SSridhar »

The China-Singapore relationship has been strained in the last year and a half or so.
chola
BRF Oldie
Posts: 5136
Joined: 16 Dec 2002 12:31
Location: USA

Re: India -Singapore News and Discussion

Post by chola »

SSridhar wrote:The China-Singapore relationship has been strained in the last year and a half or so.
Singapore is 70% chinese. Don’t read any more into this. It’ll be like our “strategic partnership” with Iran at Chabahar which is now being offered on a plate to the chinis.

PLAN itself uses the Changi on its way into the IOR as well as the USN. Changi is a warm moist place for every hard and long vessel full of seaman.
Post Reply