Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

The Strategic Issues & International Relations Forum is a venue to discuss issues pertaining to India's security environment, her strategic outlook on global affairs and as well as the effect of international relations in the Indian Subcontinent. We request members to kindly stay within the mandate of this forum and keep their exchanges of views, on a civilised level, however vehemently any disagreement may be felt. All feedback regarding forum usage may be sent to the moderators using the Feedback Form or by clicking the Report Post Icon in any objectionable post for proper action. Please note that the views expressed by the Members and Moderators on these discussion boards are that of the individuals only and do not reflect the official policy or view of the Bharat-Rakshak.com Website. Copyright Violation is strictly prohibited and may result in revocation of your posting rights - please read the FAQ for full details. Users must also abide by the Forum Guidelines at all times.
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

Lalmohan wrote:the european project was always a french strategy to stop the germans going awol again. the idea was to lock in the germans into a tight embrace to france to avoid another catastrophic world war. this is not a 100 year problem, but probably a 1000 year one. the brits were therefore needed as a balancing act to stop it being entirely a german dominated franco-german project. the smaller countries (belgium, netherlands) were all very keen to have the stroppy brits around for exactly this purpose. outside the core western european countries, motivations are more diverse - and the further out you go the more complex it gets. none of them want the brits gone now either and 49% of brits don't want to go! over time as demographics changes it will be 60-70%+ who want to remain - or reapply.

britain is now screwed for 20-30 years and the die hard brexiters who for the most part yearn after days of empire and glory are going to be in for a big disappointment when they find that the 'commonwealth' has no interest in making them rich any more and are no longer compelled to do so
True that.

The latent resentments of the 'commonwealth' will now come to the fore and be expressed in no uncertain terms. This will include the canucks and the aussies who have been chaffing at the bit for some time now.

The britshits returned empty handed after May's visit to India with not even the merest hint of any deal.
yensoy
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2494
Joined: 29 May 2002 11:31
Location: USA

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by yensoy »

Why would EU want Britain in it now that it has shown strong intent to leave? If not today, it will happen tomorrow. Nobody wants to deal with uncertainty, do they?

May's visit to India is memorable because it happened at the time Modi was giving his "mitron..." speech. At that point nobody cared for May or her saree.
chola
BRF Oldie
Posts: 5136
Joined: 16 Dec 2002 12:31
Location: USA

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chola »

chetak wrote:
if a rampaging german state does come to pass once again, it will not/can not be stopped this time around.
Saar, it will rampage until it gets to Stalingrad.
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

chola wrote:
chetak wrote:
if a rampaging german state does come to pass once again, it will not/can not be stopped this time around.
Saar, it will rampage until it gets to Stalingrad.
no russia this time.

if push comes to shove, the huns will swallow europe and hold.

that's all they need.
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

yensoy wrote:Why would EU want Britain in it now that it has shown strong intent to leave? If not today, it will happen tomorrow. Nobody wants to deal with uncertainty, do they?

May's visit to India is memorable because it happened at the time Modi was giving his "mitron..." speech. At that point nobody cared for May or her saree.
correction, saar.

no one cares for britain or its delusions of grandeur.

its been reduced to a piddly first world state with a third world mentality and is now forced to practice appeasement politics to soothe the jehadis.

May was merely one convenient face.

whether in saree or trousers, they are not welcome anymore.

there are too many things done to us after 1947 that simply cannot be explained away anymore.

edwina is long gone as is that guy she led around by his err.... nose??.
panduranghari
BRF Oldie
Posts: 3781
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by panduranghari »

Suresh S wrote:I have no respect for indian soldiers(nor should any thinking Indian) who died in the first or second world wars or other wars for the britshit. At best they were mercenaries at worst traitors to mother India. Only soldiers that deserve our respect and remembrance are the unsung soldiers of the Indian National army under Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose or soldiers who died in 1857 and countless heroes like Bhagat singh, chandersekhar Azad who sacrificed their lives for our independence.
Presentism.
In literary and historical analysis, presentism is the anachronistic introduction of present-day ideas and perspectives into depictions or interpretations of the past.
Lalmohan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13262
Joined: 30 Dec 2005 18:28

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lalmohan »

yensoy wrote:Why would EU want Britain in it now that it has shown strong intent to leave?
this is highly debatable. the leavers are led by the far right faction in the tory party and other rightists including some extremists going all the way to white power kindred spirits to bannon and co. all have slightly different versions of the same delusion around white supremacy. some call it empire, some call it race. this group is a minority, but it has managed to excite the mangobrit, especially the older ones who are reeling from globalisation, multi-culturalism and free movement of funny foreigners. a lot of people voted because they wanted to protest about being poor, not because they actually wanted to leave

the country is starkly divided and throroughly confused. as I said - screwed for 20-30 years
souravB
BRFite
Posts: 630
Joined: 07 Jun 2018 13:52

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by souravB »

There is a movie made aptly named Brexit casting Benedict Cumberbatch as Dominic Cummings. Claiming it is based on interviews and factual proceedings. It actually very categorically said the exact points that Lalmohan ji said. There were MPs both from Right and Left who supported the movement. Maybe it's not the ideology but the mindset of the elites that propelled the movement.
For a fun watch please refer below why UK actually got into EU
yensoy
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2494
Joined: 29 May 2002 11:31
Location: USA

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by yensoy »

Lalmohan wrote:
yensoy wrote:Why would EU want Britain in it now that it has shown strong intent to leave?
this is highly debatable. the leavers are led by the far right faction in the tory party and other rightists including some extremists going all the way to white power kindred spirits to bannon and co. all have slightly different versions of the same delusion around white supremacy. some call it empire, some call it race. this group is a minority, but it has managed to excite the mangobrit, especially the older ones who are reeling from globalisation, multi-culturalism and free movement of funny foreigners. a lot of people voted because they wanted to protest about being poor, not because they actually wanted to leave

the country is starkly divided and throroughly confused. as I said - screwed for 20-30 years
Sir that still doesn't explain why EU would want to have a totally unreliable partner country - one whose commitment to the EU cause is highly doubtful and varying - in their midst. Like it or not, a union of the EU kind calls for sacrifices, openness and hard nosed decision making. I am surprised they are even entertaining the thought of letting a reluctant Britain stay on in their club. In fact this would be the time to up the pressure on the brits - guys if you want to continue in EU you need to join the Euro Zone. Even the greenest of liberals will find that hard to digest and work out a decent exit plan.
ArjunPandit
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4056
Joined: 29 Mar 2017 06:37

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by ArjunPandit »

came across just this while reading about may's india visit
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/may ... ests-1970s

Read, grasp and wait for the sins to catch up with the criminal
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

souravB wrote:There is a movie made aptly named Brexit casting Benedict Cumberbatch as Dominic Cummings. Claiming it is based on interviews and factual proceedings. It actually very categorically said the exact points that Lalmohan ji said. There were MPs both from Right and Left who supported the movement. Maybe it's not the ideology but the mindset of the elites that propelled the movement.
For a fun watch please refer below why UK actually got into EU
youtube]ZVYqB0uTKlE[/youtube
watch the movie Brexit if you can.

It makes some very interesting points and by extrapolation for India too.

One politico and his party have taken the lessons learned by companies like cambridge analytica and aggregateIQ to heart and are actively using it here and now. Regional parties have also followed the lead and are using foreign consultants of their own.

If such consultants are active in the Indian political arena, which admittedly, they are, then the CIA, intelligence agencies of BIF countries as well as the rolers and the ropers, FNGOs and shady influence peddlers like ford foundation, greenpeace and amnesty et al cannot be too far behind.

If anyone has doubts then plase hark back to the days of russia, KGB, IG, paid off and sold out politicians, cabinet ministers, pliant state govts and the Mitrokhin archives for a detailed blow by blow accounts of what the soviets were doing. This applies equally well to MI5/6, CIA, mossad as well as many other intelligence agencies

There are foreigners who are now actively involved in the Indian elections and helping out/guiding regional, as well as mainstream parties target voters with specific anti Modi messaging.

As long as whatsapp and twitter and gmail servers are based outside India, the GoI simply cannot prevent access to their databases of Indian citizens.

Also "helping out" are people like jeff bezos and his outfit, along with another billionaire george soros who has been active in India since long with minority outfits, commie naxal gangs, urban naxals as well as offshore based religious outfits.

Their hold over the Indian media is pure evil in its enterprise as well as scale of reach and operation.

the rafale "campaign" is worthy of attention by outfits like cambridge analytica and aggregateIQ who are certainly operating in India in new avatars.

The single minded focus on Modi's unimpeachable integrty to damage it before the 2019 elections is BIF driven and political parties are complicit in this endeavor.

the princeling has also hired Steve Jarding.
Steve Jarding, Lecturer in Public Policy, is an American and international educator, lecturer, writer, and political consultant. He has taught at the Kennedy School since 2004 where his teaching has been recognized as "exemplary" by Kennedy School alumni, and where his course on campaign management has twice been nominated for the "Most Influential Course Award."

In addition to his teaching, Jarding is the founding partner and CEO of the international consulting company, SJB Strategies International which advises candidates and causes and offers communication training to presidents and prime ministers as well as other elected officials, business leaders, and political organizers around the world. He has lectured or consulted in over 25 countries in Asia, Africa, South America and Europe. In addition, over a 40 year career, Jarding has managed and worked on numerous statewide and national campaigns in the United States including an impressive list of winning US Senate and gubernatorial races. Jarding is co-author of the book, "Foxes in the Henhouse" published by Simon and Shuster in 2006 and the author of the "American" chapter on political advertising in the 2017 international textbook, “Handbook on Political Advertising”. He has also served as communications director and senior advisor to the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee in Washington, D.C. In 1996 Roll Call magazine named Jarding one of the "50 most influential" political people in Washington" and in 2002, The New York Times Magazine profiled Jarding as someone who wins races in places he is not supposed to win. In November 2012, the Financial Times of London profiled Jarding and his cutting edge methods of teaching campaign management techniques to students in America and around the world. Jarding has also been a Fellow at the Harvard Institute of Politics and a Fellow at the Congressional Studies Center at the University of Oklahoma where he received his Master’s Degree in Government. He holds a BA degree from the University of South Dakota.
Last edited by chetak on 16 Jan 2019 21:46, edited 1 time in total.
Lalmohan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13262
Joined: 30 Dec 2005 18:28

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lalmohan »

microtargeting and influencing opinion is the new game in town and social media fits it perfectly. both brexit and the great orange revolution in amreeka used these techniques to shape opinion and drive numbers. for example, I received a massive number of anti Islamic memes in my feeds in the run up to brexit (poor choice of target in me but...) all geared around creating fear of muslims and linking it to the need for brexit

overnight those messages disappeared... hmmm....
Lalmohan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13262
Joined: 30 Dec 2005 18:28

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lalmohan »

yensoyji - the UK within EU has not actually been all that unreliable to date. the UK has shaped over 80% of EU laws and plays a strong part in driving standards and protocols, particularly for financial services. there are some 'centres of excellence' that the others lack. sensing the opportunity some are moving fast - france for example is moving fast to try and capture the investment banking business from London back to paris... its a national strategic aim. also the UK is a big market for EU goods, especially german cars and machine tools, so disrupting that trade is in no one's interest (except for the old duffers who think india will buy british goods again)

the other contribution the Uk makes is defence and security especially the special relationship with America. only uk, france and Germany have the muscle and the germans are reluctant players, so Uk and france do most of the European heavy lifting. may has sought to buttress that part of the relationship outside the EU structure and the French and germans have already endorsed it, especially in the trumpian age where all bets are off

meanwhile the bear is growling in the scary dark places outside the reach of the camp fires...
rgosain
BRFite
Posts: 441
Joined: 10 Jan 2003 12:31

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by rgosain »

Chetak and Lalmohan your analyses are spot on and very comprehensive - should be disseminated more widely
It is a game that has been played before using the databases created by the Ford Foundation, however today's avatars have more tools to play with, and even the Chinese played their part in the collapse of the government in April 1999 just before Kargil. The election in 2004 was a colour revolution in all but name, and deja vu seems to be lurking around the corner.

Right on cue comes the latest dog whistle and drain inspector's report courtesy of Al guardian and an outfit called Open doors which is sponsored by the CofE, the established church of the Uk.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/ ... port-finds

Lord Ahmad is the Uk minister for international religious freedom and is well known on this forum
https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers ... lth-office

RG still has a residence in Hampstead, and his one year diploma at Cambridge was paid for by DFID as a was of burnishing his credentials and is the same qualification given to rowers and sports-people who are not as intellectually gifted as the other Cantabrigians.

ps the Rafale drama is to keep the IAF under-resourced so that it cannot undertake Kargil type, or post 26/11 missions. The failure to deliver further M2000 or the Rafales even after Nov 2008 attests to this. Who benefits if the Rafale is cancelled?
ArjunPandit
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4056
Joined: 29 Mar 2017 06:37

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by ArjunPandit »

Lalmohan wrote:microtargeting and influencing opinion is the new game in town and social media fits it perfectly. both brexit and the great orange revolution in amreeka used these techniques to shape opinion and drive numbers. for example, I received a massive number of anti Islamic memes in my feeds in the run up to brexit (poor choice of target in me but...) all geared around creating fear of muslims and linking it to the need for brexit

overnight those messages disappeared... hmmm....
strangely, since my relaocation to london last month, I am getting messages on virtues of islam and even a convert to islam :rotfl: :rotfl: Those who know me on twitter would know better
Singha
BRF Oldie
Posts: 66601
Joined: 13 Aug 2004 19:42
Location: the grasshopper lies heavy

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Singha »

since the people of UK voted for brexit, what exactly is this vote in uk parliament all about?

why dont they just leave. what is the disagreement about in UK now?
ArjunPandit
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4056
Joined: 29 Mar 2017 06:37

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by ArjunPandit »

Lalmohan wrote: france for example is moving fast to try and capture the investment banking business from London back to paris... its a national strategic aim.
I know two large US banks have moved IB sales jobs from London to paris
Singha
BRF Oldie
Posts: 66601
Joined: 13 Aug 2004 19:42
Location: the grasshopper lies heavy

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Singha »

does brexit mean people from UK and vice versa will lose the visa free work permit within the EU?
Lisa
BRFite
Posts: 1729
Joined: 04 May 2008 11:25

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lisa »

Yes.
Lisa
BRFite
Posts: 1729
Joined: 04 May 2008 11:25

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lisa »

rgosain wrote:
Lord Ahmad is the Uk minister for international religious freedom and is well known on this forum
https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers ... lth-office

RG still has a residence in Hampstead, and his one year diploma at Cambridge was paid for by DFID as a was of burnishing his credentials and is the same qualification given to rowers and sports-people who are not as intellectually gifted as the other Cantabrigians.
You may be confusing Lord Ahmad for Lord Ahmed. RG does not have a house in Hampstead, he puts up with one of the Bachan brothers.
Last edited by Lisa on 16 Jan 2019 23:33, edited 1 time in total.
Lisa
BRFite
Posts: 1729
Joined: 04 May 2008 11:25

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lisa »

Singha wrote:since the people of UK voted for brexit, what exactly is this vote in uk parliament all about?

why dont they just leave. what is the disagreement about in UK now?
The UK would like to negotiate a free trade agreement prior to departure. The EU's demands for such a deal are unpalatable, eg (just one example) the European Court to have the right to impose its will on the UK. Parliament has decided that such caveats are unacceptable as they infringe upon the sovereignty of the nation and thus the failure in Parliament yesterday. May should though, succeed in a motion of no confidence today.
disha
BR Mainsite Crew
Posts: 8261
Joined: 03 Dec 2006 04:17
Location: gaganaviharin

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by disha »

Singha wrote:does brexit mean people from UK and vice versa will lose the visa free work permit within the EU?
Unless they are Irish. Or if I understand this mess, they are N. Irish.

Brexit in nutshell (as per me)

1. Britain wants to be part of EU for visa-free access to EU for its citizens.
2. Britain does *not* want to have the immigrants/refugees coming from EU, though they can advise the world on how to treat refugees.
3. Britain wants to take money from EU for its greater glory
4. Britain does *not* want to finance debt of PIIGS
5. Britain wants EU market (free trade to EU)
6. Britain does *not* want to be a market to EU (no free trade from EU)

When Britain joined EU, the people with *not*s were subdued. Now people with *not*s are vocal.

Britain is now a "banana republic" and neither has "bananas" nor is a "republic". In fact, that entire UK is a conundrum. It came together only because others were divided (france/germany in europe) and only because it could loot the colonies.
Lalmohan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13262
Joined: 30 Dec 2005 18:28

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lalmohan »

Singha wrote:since the people of UK voted for brexit, what exactly is this vote in uk parliament all about?

why dont they just leave. what is the disagreement about in UK now?
basically a vast range of laws, regulations, standards, agreements, protocols will become invalid the moment Britain exits the EU. all of them have to be re-negotiated and re-agreed in order for the normal economic, trade, defence, security, financial, pharmaceutical, transport, etc., etc., systems to work. without this agreement being in place the simple friction of not having a set of agreed rules will start to break down the functioning of all these things.

simple example - components of cars made in Europe may transit through 4 or 5 countries and cross the English channel 2-3 times before the car is finished. each time the goods cross the uk border they will have to be treated as though they have come from china or the US and be subject to customs inspections and duties, etc. this will basically blow up half the car manufacturers that have plants in the UK (Toyota, Honda, Nissan, Ford, BMW, JLR...) or those in Europe that have components sourced in the UK

similar issues exist in every single industry

also things like the France-UK electricity sharing agreement will become void (I am told) and therefore there will be no recourse if france decides to divert its power production away from the UK grid to somewhere else, etc., etc.

multiply all these by a 100 and you get close to the chaos that the UK is currently heading for
screwed for 20-30 years

may had agreed a deal with the EU that would allow uk to ease out of this model and move to a new model - but within 2 years. parliament is fighting over exiting now (without any agreement) or exiting in a different way (not yet defined) but presumably to buy more time to renegotiate everything with the EU
Singha
BRF Oldie
Posts: 66601
Joined: 13 Aug 2004 19:42
Location: the grasshopper lies heavy

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Singha »

but the EU single market and currency (which uk did not join) is only from 2002 ie 16 years old. things worked fine before that and will now too. UK did not honour the schengen visa for dark skinned people - they retained their own visa incl transit visa of heathrow.

no FTA, but they will survive. a bit of a recession maybe for some time.

the black money flows that funnel into london will remain intact. no other place can offer so much luxury, privacy, investment options, realty and protection from extradition, whether in or out of EU. i dont see sinic, indic or russian money leaving london. infact with more laissez faire policies more money might come.
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

Singha wrote:but the EU single market and currency (which uk did not join) is only from 2002 ie 16 years old. things worked fine before that and will now too. UK did not honour the schengen visa for dark skinned people - they retained their own visa incl transit visa of heathrow.

no FTA, but they will survive. a bit of a recession maybe for some time.

the black money flows that funnel into london will remain intact. no other place can offer so much luxury, privacy, investment options, realty and protection from extradition, whether in or out of EU.
its a growth industry by itself.

extremely well managed and very discretely advertised, mostly by satisfied "customers" and that too by word of mouth.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by UlanBatori »

OT but couldn't resist
Who benefits if the Rafale is cancelled?
Putin, pure and simple. After Syria campaign, there is no doubt about resilience and sortie-rates of newer RuAF craft. Could probably get 3 times as many planes plus Make in India, and do it much faster than frogland acquisition with all their prima donna stunts.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by UlanBatori »

Mays survives no-confidence vote 325-306. So now what? BREXIT yes, terms presented so far no, but they don't want a no-deal BREXIT either.

Why would Mays want a "no-deal BREXIT"?
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

UlanBatori wrote:OT but couldn't resist
Who benefits if the Rafale is cancelled?
Putin, pure and simple. After Syria campaign, there is no doubt about resilience and sortie-rates of newer RuAF craft. Could probably get 3 times as many planes plus Make in India, and do it much faster than frogland acquisition with all their prima donna stunts.
the britshits and the amerikis are waiting in the wings for their cue and both have axes to grind as well as wares to sell.

In fact, they may be the among the covert drivers in an otherwise very public and vicious rafale modi smear campaign.
IndraD
BRF Oldie
Posts: 9335
Joined: 26 Dec 2008 15:38
Location: भारत का निश्चेत गगन

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by IndraD »

Singha wrote:since the people of UK voted for brexit, what exactly is this vote in uk parliament all about?

why dont they just leave. what is the disagreement about in UK now?
too many traction groups saar in parliament
some working for EU
some working for themselves
very few for UK .
52% opted out but 48% opted in.
no one knows how will this pan out,
now there r five options again

-election
-referendum
-no deal
-another deal (renegotiation)
-another vote of no confidence

its very chaotic & complex more than Indrani murder case.
kindly note from Indian subcontinent to Europe & US everyone taking vicarious pleasure in UK going down spiral. Absolutely no sympathies.
IndraD
BRF Oldie
Posts: 9335
Joined: 26 Dec 2008 15:38
Location: भारत का निश्चेत गगन

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by IndraD »

Image
what happens now
g.sarkar
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4382
Joined: 09 Jul 2005 12:22
Location: MERCED, California

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by g.sarkar »

yensoy wrote:Why would EU want Britain in it now that it has shown strong intent to leave? If not today, it will happen tomorrow. Nobody wants to deal with uncertainty, do they?
May's visit to India is memorable because it happened at the time Modi was giving his "mitron..." speech. At that point nobody cared for May or her saree.
UK's departure should not be seen in isolation. If EU makes it painless and profitable, UK's departure may encourage Portugal, Italy, Greece, Spain etc to leave when the going gets tough. UK will be made into an example of the disadvantages of a departure.
Gautam
Suraj
Forum Moderator
Posts: 15043
Joined: 20 Jan 2002 12:31

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Suraj »

Singha wrote:since the people of UK voted for brexit, what exactly is this vote in uk parliament all about?

why dont they just leave. what is the disagreement about in UK now?
The issues:

Freedom of Movement
* UK wants to stop freedom of movement between UK and rest of EU, which means EU folks cannot move to and work in UK freely
* But UK and Eire both want to keep RI-NI border open (Good Friday Agreement)
* Eire is part of EU, UK wants out, i.e. NI would be out.
* But NI does NOT want out of EU, and neither does Scotland (SNP are all remainers)
* Paradox: UK wants RI/NI border open and closed simultaneously - open to Irish/UK folks, closed to EU folks. Impossible because border is open and Eire supports freedom of movement with rest of EU.
* Could UK give up NI to fix this ? That's a practical answer but
a) NI is a political atoot ang, and DUP (NI nationalists) are keeping this Tory govt afloat.
b) there will be blood

Visa / Movement
* No visas for EU folks wanting to work in UK or vice versa right now.
* This will change - UK doesn't want to offer this to EU nationals, but wants easy access to EU for themselves.

Trade and Business
* There's a vast collection of standardization agreements intra EU that enables sourcing within the EU area hasslefree.
* UK does not want EU imposed standardization and wants to do things its way.
* But UK still wants hassle free interface to business with EU

There are options like Norway, Switzerland and Turkey models, but they all come with baggage:
Norway Model: simplest, but contradicts major Brexit redlines - requires freedom of movement and subject to EU regulation.
Swiss/Turkish models: possible, but takes FAR more time than 2 years.
Just-another-country: follows WTO based system like anyone else outside EU.
Philip
BRF Oldie
Posts: 21538
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: India

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Philip »

The Irish border issue should be dealt with in the same manner as was agreed upon for the Hong Kong handover." One country, two systems", for a limited period, say the same 50 years.But hardline Brexiteers feel that this will be a backdoor entrance for the EU .
May's govt. staggers on but is fatally weakened by the chaos within her own party.Calls for a second referendum are growing apace.The best soap- opera political farce for a century. The Brits do produce some of the best comedy shows ever!
vera_k
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4000
Joined: 20 Nov 2006 13:45

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by vera_k »

The UK can be the equivalent of Pakistan to the EU. Although it would be a peaceful coexistence.

Brexit will be messy given the deadline imposed by EU rules. If the EU is flexible about the deadline, then perhaps things can be unwound over time. If not, then both sides should get on with it. The global economy is still growing, so a few years of disruption in the UK/EU will not be as much of a problem compared to splitting during a recessionary time.
la.khan
BRFite
Posts: 468
Joined: 15 Aug 2016 05:02

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by la.khan »

Singha wrote:since the people of UK voted for brexit, what exactly is this vote in uk parliament all about?

why dont they just leave. what is the disagreement about in UK now?
From my limited understanding of the situation, after Brexit, British government started negotiating the terms of separation with Brussels@EU. After months of haggling/wrangling between London & Brussels, PM May arrived at a deal, presented the deal for UK parliament's approval. This was resoundingly defeated (230 votes).

So, as of now, UK is leaving Europe, on 29th March, with no clear understanding on matters of customs, immigration, defence etc. London & Brussels may agree to a mutually agreeable later date, give themselves another 18-24 months.

Looking at Europe, I thank God that we had SVP to complete integration of Indian states in a few months 8)
Lalmohan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13262
Joined: 30 Dec 2005 18:28

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lalmohan »

Suraj - good explanation of the irish border issue. this is the biggest IED in the whole process - may's agreement has largely foundered on this question

as you say, there will be blood, violence is always simmering just under the surface in NI

vera_k: time is problematic. an indefinite timeline encourages the others. Italy under the salvini government will be keen to be next, and the Italian economy is big enough to be a problem. no one cares about the greeks

re free movement: the mangobrit is fine with free movement (Spanish holidays!) as long as it doesn't mean that poles and Romanians come freely to the UK. in terms of context - there are more polish people in the UK now than all sub-continentals put together and they have come within 10-15 years as opposed to 50 years for brown folks. never mind that they work low paid jobs and pay taxes but they are seen to be a problem by the mangobrits. frankly if it weren't for the east Europeans, large swathes of the low paid service economy would grind to a stand still

there isn't one reason for the brexit vote - there are multiple. and there are no good solutions that please everyone

the way out maybe to agree to be in the customs union and the basic infrastructure agreements, pull out of single market (and free movement) and then spend 10 years negotiating everything else. but even this is a problem for the rabid right ("swivel eyed loons" as Cameron called them)
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

Lalmohan wrote:Suraj - good explanation of the irish border issue. this is the biggest IED in the whole process - may's agreement has largely foundered on this question

as you say, there will be blood, violence is always simmering just under the surface in NI

vera_k: time is problematic. an indefinite timeline encourages the others. Italy under the salvini government will be keen to be next, and the Italian economy is big enough to be a problem. no one cares about the greeks

re free movement: the mangobrit is fine with free movement (Spanish holidays!) as long as it doesn't mean that poles and Romanians come freely to the UK. in terms of context - there are more polish people in the UK now than all sub-continentals put together and they have come within 10-15 years as opposed to 50 years for brown folks. never mind that they work low paid jobs and pay taxes but they are seen to be a problem by the mangobrits. frankly if it weren't for the east Europeans, large swathes of the low paid service economy would grind to a stand still

there isn't one reason for the brexit vote - there are multiple. and there are no good solutions that please everyone

the way out maybe to agree to be in the customs union and the basic infrastructure agreements, pull out of single market (and free movement) and then spend 10 years negotiating everything else. but even this is a problem for the rabid right ("swivel eyed loons" as Cameron called them)

Sirji,

The britshits are in no position to cherry pick their terms and they will very simply have to take what the EU thrusts down their throats.

the EU, as was pointed out earlier, is fighting a battle for its own survival.

If the britshits get off easy, the PIGS will follow next, as surely as night follows the day, so the EU is making huge obstacles and putting impossible conditions for the brexit.

For the EU, it is essentially an existential crisis, a vital question of their own future, as well as a huge increase in the running costs of the union because a few will have to carry the many. This is something that the "few" simply cannot afford as it will seriously and adversely their quality of life, social safety nets and their privileged positions in the world, their memberships of great institutions of economic and military influence and especially membership of the security council and their clout in the UN and their say in world affairs.

The question of the viability of recent EU entrants as well as the older freeloaders and easy riders and their ability to pay their fair share and their capacity to share looming burdens in terms of immigrants, defense, a standing EU army as they are seriously contemplating, among other things.

In the medium term, brexit will cause the collapse of NATO as the amerikis will inevitably pull out. It will also become a protestant catholic tug of war like it was in the recent centuries gone by and the center of military power, as well as economic mass, will shift towards the protestant lot. The vatican will be greatly diminished in stature, reach, as well as their covert influence in global affairs.

china and mother russia will precipitate another great game while India will tamely watch and sit this one out too.

The whole problem was actually precipitated when the poles, in their hundreds of thousands, moved into the UK by right guaranteed by the EU, grabbing all the low end jobs leaving the white britshit underclass jittery and this already simmering discontent also spread to the immigrant populace from countries like pak and beediland, africans, war zone refugees who inevitably voted leave, catching the white mid to upper class britshits completely off guard.

This resentment of immigrants is a long standing issue with the white britshit underclass which also resented the flood of the early immigrants from India, pak, beediland and africa in the decades gone by.

At least the Indians, have, by and large, largely managed to claw their way up the food chain by the dint of education and focussed hard work and the inherent desire to escape the dole and make a better future for themselves.

Whereas, all the rest of the immigrants have mostly continued to remain on the dole, clogging up services like the NHS, swamping public housing, breeding like rabbits and giving rise to social unrest, political and militant religious extremism, while putting huge pressure on the expensive security services and the already meager police budgets.

the britshit whites feel impotent, exploited, overwhelmed, robbed and abandoned by their society which has increasingly turned towards vote bank politics to woo minority votes and almost ignoring the poor among the whites.

Someone very smart saw the chance and engineered a social coup, possibly as a warning to the govt, but failed to consider the possible catastrophic economic and disruptive consequences.

The leave verdict came about solely due to the laissez-faire and laid back attitude of the unconcerned middle and upper classes.
Last edited by chetak on 17 Jan 2019 17:07, edited 1 time in total.
Lalmohan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13262
Joined: 30 Dec 2005 18:28

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by Lalmohan »

^^^ good analysis, I would add that a few helping nudges from outside moved the result towards a definitive outcome. not just the UK, but the west is going to be set back thanks to this referendum - for quite some time. the inherent weaknesses when prodded, caused a failure
remains to be seen if it will be catastrophic yet or not, but failure it is
chetak
BRF Oldie
Posts: 32387
Joined: 16 May 2008 12:00

Re: Indo-UK News & Discussions- June 2017

Post by chetak »

Lalmohan wrote:^^^ good analysis, I would add that a few helping nudges from outside moved the result towards a definitive outcome. not just the UK, but the west is going to be set back thanks to this referendum - for quite some time. the inherent weaknesses when prodded, caused a failure
remains to be seen if it will be catastrophic yet or not, but failure it is
Lalmohan ji,

Undoubtedly, the voters were "nudged" as you so rightly point out.

Some entities like cambridge analytica and aggregateIQ, to name just two among the commonly known possible first movers as also the many clones spawned by this new and disruptive methodology of voter reorientation to serve specifically targeted objectives were among the nudgers.

Then again, what if the even more dangerous specialized niche players, operating from the shadows, like intelligence agencies with such capabilities who can target voters by the systematized disorganization of their currently held viewpoints and then reassemble their versions of reality by subtly manipulating the similarity in difference and the difference in similarity to make them true believers in whatever cause such entities are paid or ideologically motivated to impel.

All this begs the question: who exactly did this and why??

Looking at the stupendous scale of the potential damage likely to be caused, I would lean towards either russia or china. They could be among the biggest beneficiaries if brexit without a good deal came to pass.

BTW, you know better than me, that intelligence agencies are always the angel investors in such dual use and disruptive technologies.

Also, their "connect" with academia is legendary.

Their ability see the (mis)use of such targeted voter manipulation is unrivaled as are the similar abilities of FNGOs,

Ever wonder about how the congis stormed back to power in 2004 or the sweeping aapi "victory" in the dilli elections??
Post Reply