Austin wrote:Sanku wrote:Nonsense Austin, SC has observed that it wants to chicken out. What is there to continue about that
Thats not the way I look at or most would look at it today.......SC observation is Fair and Just based on merit of the case. It was a mature judgement as well.
It clearly is a Red Letter day
What SC observation? There are tons of observation, that remark is quite vacuous.
Oh really, a scurrilous attack on character of Army chief is "high living" according to you?
I am really disappointed by lack of standards here.
To be honest i am more dissapointed by the General who dragged the GOI to the court ...i think he should have resigned and then taken the GOI to court but never mind he did what he thought was right.
What double standards Austin, you are standing for low lifes who attack the character of a good man, and after the vilification campgain during which people like you who did not say a word against the attack dog tactic -- you have the cheeks to say "why did Gen go to court"
Where was your sense of goodness when he was being pilloried before he went to court.
Sad Austin, very sad. Not expected from you. You have failed to live up to basic standards of fair play.
I think the only persons who are hurt by the judgement is one who had their Ego's crushed ( i am not referring this to you )
The problem Austin, that this is a ego issue for some sort of people who buy attack dogs. For others it is a matter of institutional behavior, of doing the right thing to a good man.
About morality and integrity.
WOrds which still mean a lot to some of us.
SC observation on Service DOB and Gen withdrawing petition makes it clear where the party stood before and where it stands now.
Oh no it does not -- I accuse you of putting words in SC's mouth.
Oh really, what about the remarks by KC Singh that Manmohan had personally ordered his attack dogs loose on a good general who stood up to his shengians.
I know you dont like the Congress but this is not MMS or Congress versus VKS issue ....MMS infact behaved in a very dignified manner on this case and have mentioned that court verdict will be accepted.
Sidestep. KC Singh said that Manmohan and congress have let loose their attack dogs. This is supported by a large number of people, do you call this dignfied behavior.
And of course Man mohan will accept the court verdict, does he have a choice, he was forced to accept Thomas verdict, the 2G verdict, in all the manners he gracefully accepted the verdict.
Kindly dont make a virtue of having something rammed down the throat.
I would says give verdict to the Govt where its due.
Yes, on its musharraf.
Well look at the SC observation on this matter and you will see what SC had to say on Service Record and why Army Chief had to withdraw its petition else SC would have given its judgement.
Yes, SC observed that it did not want to entertain the matter. That is very sad. They side stepped the issue.
. There has been no judgement. Isnt that obvious. They have said that they are not going to speak on date of birth since the General accepts he does not want to seek longer tenure so talking about date of birth is not relevant and the matter stays dismissed without listening.
