brar_w wrote:Barath wrote:As a newish multi-role it was good enough to replace the F14 of Top Gun fame and a couple of others.
If all that wasn't there or in the pipeline, and if the threat were still as severe..the F/A-18E/F would not have replaced the F-14. The Naval ATF (F-22N) would have.
The Navy fought tooth and nail to get their own stealth attack fighter A-12/flying dorito and rejected the naval atf f22-n. And the F18 E/f was the hurried replacement for that disaster.
The F22N was rejected in favor of the F14, because it was too expensive , too optimized as as interceptor/air superiority and because the projected gross weight after modification and navalization (including beefing up landing structures etc ) was high
https://www.globalsecurity.org/military ... t/natf.htm
Aircraft do replace others on flight decks and in hangars, and to varied extent in missions.
The F14 had a bombcat variation see action
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/ ... raft-33296
It's not as if the F14 served no other purpose except interception at long range with the aim-54 Phoenix of Soviet bombers trying to take out the carrier .
It's just that that particular mission was it's specialty and one that the US had no real need for after the collapse of the Soviet Union.
The f14 was growing long in the tooth and swing wing was always a maintenance issue. But if the F18 E/f were inadequate, you would have seen new build F14-d and later variants continue.
Really, some of the other emotional mud slinging at the F18 E/F serves no useful purpose, compared to a cool and professional evaluation of its pro, con and suitability for your mission and context. It's not that the F18 E/F had no problems (eg wing droop in development)
The long range interception of heavy bombers is not a role that exists in india.
A multi-role aircraft is not only the international trend, it is what is appropriate for india.
And while the F18 E/F has never been top dog as an air superiority fighter, that isn't the only role either. As a platform and system of systems, and especially with the F18G and upgrades through 2030+ ,it performs quite decently - enough for consideration.