arshyam wrote:This author criticized Uri for not being "humane" (whatever the heck that means), and the glowing recommendation for Raazi implies that it was more humane. I hadn't watched Raazi, and was considering watching it on streaming. But with this ringing positive endorsement, I will most probably give it a miss, and save 2 hours of my time now.
Flawed logic, Raazi is an excellent movie in it's own right, and worth a watch.
And while I don't agree with her (I also don't want to be too harsh on her since she is a teenager, still forming her opinions, and reviewing it from a clearly stated feminist perspective on a feminist site rather than a mainstream media outlet) she does make some good points on a purely movie-making level. Uri has some of the best realistic action scenes ever seen in a bollywood war movie, certainly a huge step up than previous ones, but it is the non-action scenes that lack realism and are let down by farcical scenes like the fanciful drone idea and the high ranking paki general being injected with truth serum by a housewife! I think that is the next area to improve on in order to get to the level of top-grade movies of the genre like zero dark thirty etc. This was one of the rare openly jingoistic movies in a long time and that is why audiences including me enjoyed it. However it doesn't mean that it was completely perfect or can't improve or be criticized, especially in the context of a film critic's review.