Brando wrote:I do understand that this will be another DRDO "project" which like all others will promise the moon, the sun and even the stars. The final products as everybody is aware are not on par with what our neighbours will get off the shelf as it is. IF this were a science fair where effort counted maybe we would come out on top but there is no glory or gain in reinventing the wheel.
By that token, we shouldn't attempt anything, should we?
Look, that is what the projected force structure is all about. The Phalcons are being inducted because they are qualitatively superior to what all the current and near term projected enemy force structure will be. But the Embraers are also being inducted with the indigenous equipment to use the time while the IAF uses the Phalcons to gain experience and move forward. Its not an 'or' statement, but rather a 'and' statement that is required.
The IAF has to look at the current Phalcon induction as an interim measure while giving support for the growth of the local alternative.
The advantage there would be that the Australians themselves dont hold the keys to that closet. The Americans do and if we are to sniff the wind as it were the Americans wouldnt be too willing to hand that out to the Chinese anytime soon nor would they side with them over us as the Chinese pose a greater threat than we do to their hegemony. And the old maxim always holds; the enemy of an enemy is a friend.
But have you considered the fact that the Americans would simply refuse to the acquisition, or put sanctions on the supplies whenever they feel like it?
Also, have you considered the fact that the IAF might have in fact looked at the
Wedgetail and rejected it in preference of the Phalcon on techincal parameters like commonality of airframe, existence of the basic A-50 airframe to begin from and its relatively reliable sources as opposed to the US among other things?
These are questions that need to be thought out at any time anyone considers any such buys. I would trust the fact that the IAF has in fact done the same.