munna wrote:For an average Pakistani, India == N India and by default Indian Pop Music == Anu Malik brand copy items from bollywood-Hindi fare. India and Indi pop exists beyond the Hindi pop that has had some copy cats make money out of other people's produce (not just the neighbours). Use the linguistic depth of India to brow beat the argument.
Next time they repeat this tell them you do not listen to hindi-pop as you only like Tamil/Asamese/Bodo pop. Have done it and it works!

You should not do this. For too long we have retreated. Never give up the space, hang on tight to it. Why claim on you like Tamil/Bong/Assamese, why leave out the whole gamut of Hindi, Punjabi music just to piss em off?
First and foremost. The musical notes, the musical structure, notes, raagas are all Indian, 100% Hindu. The Sa-Re-Ga etc. is from the Vedas. The ragaas were given by Lord Shiva, Brahma etc. (Raag Durga, Raag Sri, Raag Bhairav, are all names of kuffaar devis & devtaas.) The beats, the drums, tall, the rythm is all Indian. The languages all Sanskrit based. Paki contribution to music is zilch, nada, cipher.
They had Bade Ghulam Ali Khan. He couldn't survive in TSP. (There are interesting stories w.r.t that.) He came to India and requested Indian citizenship; Morarji Desai arranged that. He was an outstanding singer, but all his miracles happened in India. Mohd. Rafi was a Punjabi, but stayed in India. No Paki contribution there. We had, what the Pakis call Mallika-e-Tarannum, Noorjehan. She stayed on in India for some time after partition and then left to become a TSP'ian. Her songs there are pathetic, downright poor quality. She was on OK singer to begin with, but became pathetic in TSP. They call her Mallika-e-Tarannum.
People often cite Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan---I have to be honest, he screams, he is out of taal, he is besura, and his singing style very dated. I just cannot standing his screams, although people state that they get religious visions when they listen to him.
That is all the sum total of TSP contributions.
Music is not compatible with jeeahad, nor is is compatible with the RoP. The Talibums treatment of music is well known.
Finally, please do not counter them. Tell them you wish them good luck in their musical pursuits.