RajeshA wrote:
I do agree, that USA and India's interests could coincide against PRC.
It is however important that we keep our independent policy, and it is important that we also publicly demonstrate of independence of policy.
Agree. no issues on this.
India's immediate interest should be an integration of PoK within India, without getting too bruised up.
By raking up the issue of PoK through Selig Harrison, it seems USA would want India to mobilize and take over PoK. USA also realizes that it would be a uphill task for India, trying to ward off both TSP and PRC at the same time. So either USA simply wants India to lean more towards USA for geopolitics, which we should carefully think over; or the USA is willing to really pitch in militarily and help India get control of PoK, in which case we should show interest. Military support would probably be in terms of aerial troop and hardware transport, but most importantly by pinning down China in the Pacific through a massive naval deployment. That can be in response to some crisis created by North Korea for example.
Best case would be if both North Korea and PoK simultaneously fall to South Korea/America and India respectively
.
It is too simplistic to be realistically possible. IMHO it is not childs play.
Sure uncle wants India to wake up and see dragon in its full glory.
USA wants India to take on PRC, but military option will not work because uncle will not go full extent.
China is no pushover. It can destroy both also. Not to forget the new clear power. Uncle cannot even handle tinpot powers like Iran/NoKo( compared to china onlee).
Why should it give leverage to India vs china. What will uncle gain in this. Remember china is not a superpower. It has numerous faultlines. India is one of them to box china in its place. Giving military option is not childs play nor will it be offered.
India has to work hard diplomatically over a period of time. It is too early to even think of in military terms.
US will drop hints of its encouragement all along the way and India should latch on to it. India was hardly on the radar screen of uncle. When its economy started to improve suddenly people started to notice it. So India has something to offer in the long run hence the interest.
Uncle willing to work around new clear deal, weapons economy integration, media propaganda, security council helping India thru its influence in world politics.
It will ask India to do its bidding in certain issues in return for its support. India should give if it is in sync with its stated nationalist goals. if not excuse itself diplomatically.
Meanwhile India should go about and develop close relations with as many countries as possible. It should improve its defences. It should keep its powder dry and battle ready.
Develop economy and living standards of its people. Let Indians know their core interests like saying that J&K complete is our land. Reduce DIEs and SLIMEs in our people.Others like Tibetans were driven out of their land by the brutal suppression by china etc.
Living standards, economy and military should go hand in hand. One cannot be think of it as one after another.
So India should put the question very directly: What are the Americans willing to commit to the project of confining China to East Asia, how far are they willing to go to ensure a duopoly in Asia?
USA will not give in black or white terms nor do India will say it so.
It all diplomacy in grey and dull colours which will happen over a period of time.
Both will test each other in relation to each other keeping their cards close to their chest. Remember both do not trust each other completely because of the history.It is a long one over years.
USA is the reigning superpower by a long shot. China is way far behind and India still further behind.
USA looks for least cost option of containing china and one of them is India which will do it on its own right. USA will gently prod India in certain directions to get the maximum benefit. India will also get the benefits due to it.
As long as both of them have something in common this will continue with hopes of checkmating the dragon.