When Rahul Gandhi said that he can't reveal more because "Unfortunately, I am a member of parliament", Jairam said he should say, "Unfortunately, for you, I am a member of parliament," which was audible
This guy is Zelensky of India. No wonder SoreAss and all the slaves want him in charge of India
The judgment holds that hereafter, and until such time as Parliament enacts a law contemplated under Article 324(2), appointments of the Chief Election Commissioner and election commissioners shall be made by the President on the advice of a committee consisting of the Prime Minister, the Leader of the Opposition of the Lok Sabha and in case no Leader of the Opposition is available, the Leader of the largest Opposition party in the Lok Sabha in terms of numerical strength, and the Chief Justice of India.
The judgment is questionable on several grounds. The Court erroneously locates the constitutional intent behind Article 324(2) in the Constituent Assembly debates, contrary to its plain language and settled principles of statutory interpretation, which posit that a speech made in the course of a legislative debate is at best indicative of the subjective intent of the speaker and cannot prevail over the plain words of a constitutional text.
{Key point. What's in the Constitution is that which matters not some windbag waxing eloquent in the Constituent Assembly. For the SCI to take recourse to speeches to derive intent is erroneous and is stretching the Court's powers.}
The language of the provision is self-explanatory and reads thus:
Article 324: “The Election Commission shall consist of the Chief Election Commissioner and such number of other Election Commissioners, if any, as the President may from time to time fix and the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and other election commissioners shall, subject to the provisions of any law made in that behalf by Parliament, be made by the President…”
To read the words “subject to the provision of any law to be made by Parliament” in Article 324(2), not as a parliamentary option but a constitutional command to Parliament to peremptorily enact a different stand-alone law, is a fraught exercise in stretched constitutionalism.
Indeed, the absence of law contemplated in Article 324 (2) for the last seven decades represents a conscious legislative rejection of a special law on a subject covered by the constitutional provision.
NGOs in India raked in Rs 88,882 cr from foreign donors in last 5 years. This incidentally coincides with the period — 2017-18 to 2021-22 — that witnessed a crackdown on NGOs allegedly violating FCRA & the Act being made more stringent.
$11 B - thts 15% of annual FDI in the country.
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 16 Mar 2023 22:50
by vijayk
A trial balloon by some Noble committee member about Nobel Prize for Mudi for all his world peace efforts
SC milords seems to be working hard to sow seeds of doubt and limit political/executive action. Toolkit directive?
They want to throw in innuendos and brickbats which can be used by BIF
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 17 Mar 2023 11:24
by Prem Kumar
In fact, the wokelord went so far as to say that they would declared the Shinde Govt formation as "unconstitutional", if the Thackeray/NCP Govt had agreed to take the Trust Vote (even if they lost). Because he thinks that the Governor acted in an unconstitutional way.
Recall the CEC over-reach. I had said, like many others, that the Govt would do nothing. It has panned out exactly as predicted. By doing nothing, they are emboldening the SC every day and the legislative/executive domain of operation, freedom of thought/action is steadily decreasing.
Hope they realize the danger and fight-back before it gets too ugly
A delegation of Congress leaders, led by former minister H C Mahadevappa, inspected the Bengaluru-Mysuru Express Highway for eight km from Siddalingapura near Mysuru, on Friday. They said that they found a few lacunae, including sub-standard barricades.
Notice the tone of the report. It is as if this group of Congress-folks were some auditing agencies who were sent there by the Ghandi-Nehru clan. They can report the 'lacunaes' to Shri. Pappu Ghandi who is now feeling unfortunate that he is an MP in Indian Parliament .
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 17 Mar 2023 17:06
by vijayk
SORO's organisation YUVA SHAKTI.
I know some ground level BJP workers. How can they fight this?
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 17 Mar 2023 18:58
by Manish_P
Sachin wrote:..
A delegation of Congress leaders, led by former minister H C Mahadevappa, inspected the Bengaluru-Mysuru Express Highway for eight km from Siddalingapura near Mysuru, on Friday. They said that they found a few lacunae, including sub-standard barricades.
Sachin ji, have you seen the video of the below 'activist' person (apparently she was in the news recently for assualting an actress in a park).
She is cribbing while driving on a smooth new Bengaluru Mysore Express Way and keeps saying it is OK-OK & not a good experience but in the end says she doesn't know why.... and yes she says that the road has a couple of blind-spots
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 17 Mar 2023 20:10
by vijayk
Any kannada folks here to help talk to BJP campaign teams in Bangalore about some of these Soreass issues and help them frame some of these topics?
SC milords seem to be working hard to sow seeds of doubt and limit political/executive action. Toolkit directive?
They want to throw in innuendos and brickbats which can be used by BIF
Please read the quoted arguments only.
The MVA lawyers don't want a trust vote.
SCI said UT himself had stated he lost the majority and didn't want a trust vote.
MVA lawyers and media are using inflammatory language.
Long back Bommai Judgment said floor test is the only legitimate path forward for settling questions of the majority.
UT himself resigned as he didn't want a floor test.
It is like Humpty Dumpty.
MVA sat on a wall.
MVA had a great fall.
All of Sonia's lawyers could not put together MVA back.
A delegation of Congress leaders, led by former minister H C Mahadevappa, inspected the Bengaluru-Mysuru Express Highway for eight km from Siddalingapura near Mysuru, on Friday. They said that they found a few lacunae, including sub-standard barricades.
Notice the tone of the report. It is as if this group of Congress-folks were some auditing agencies who were sent there by the Ghandi-Nehru clan. They can report the 'lacunaes' to Shri. Pappu Ghandi who is now feeling unfortunate that he is an MP in Indian Parliament .
Credit for what? Just starting the project as usual and sitting on it?
The Karnataka poltics modus operanid is like this.
1) The opposition forms a coalition and gets power.
2) They loot for one to two years and fall apart for the crooks don't want the others to get the CM chair((JDS_Kumaraswamy)
3) Then BJP comes to power and cleans up the mess for 3-4 years.
4) The Karnataka voters repeatedly give hung verdicts and the cycle repeats. You have the NOTARDs and city snakes who fall for single-issue grudges.
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 09:54
by Srutayus
I know some ground level BJP workers. How can they fight this?
By circulating these videos and making people aware of the acute danger. Soros and his tentacles are everywhere but not exactly hidden.
Remind them of who else he is funding.
Remind them of the desecration of the National Flag during Republic Day and the involvement of of groups funded by him.
How they insult our PM who has kept India developing fast during a time of Global mayhem.
There are Khalistan related groups whose leaders are connected with Open Society.
Quote what Khalistanis and leftists say about Hindus and how so many of them can be traced back to these same networks. This is all in the open.
Point out the destruction he has caused in other countries.
Make their blood boil. As this should.
I would not be surprised if the Soros network contacts reach into the Supreme Court. The way they move with urgency when organizations involving his network are involved is telling, even as millions of cases languish for decades.
NGOs in India raked in Rs 88,882 cr from foreign donors in last 5 years. This incidentally coincides with the period — 2017-18 to 2021-22 — that witnessed a crackdown on NGOs allegedly violating FCRA & the Act being made more stringent.
$11 B - thts 15% of annual FDI in the country.
Wow ! So much effort being made by western democracies to improve democracy and freedom in India. Their love for us will not stop until they colonise us once again.
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 14:17
by SRajesh
A question to legal experts:
What is the locus standi of the ICC arrest warrant against Prez Putin??
a. Can he be served the warrant in Russia ??
b. Can be arrested when he visits another country?? (even though he has diplomatic immunity)
c. Impact of this on G20 Summit-can India still send an invite to him??
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 14:20
by SRajesh
And given this experiment:
Can BIF's on the back of PeePeeSee Crapumentary go to ICC against NaMo??
Apart from G20 any major engagements for Namo before the 2024 elections??
Do we still have the UN (Gen Ass)meet this year??
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 15:06
by chetak
Rsatchi wrote:A question to legal experts:
What is the locus standi of the ICC arrest warrant against Prez Putin??
a. Can he be served the warrant in Russia ??
b. Can be arrested when he visits another country?? (even though he has diplomatic immunity)
c. Impact of this on G20 Summit-can India still send an invite to him??
Rsatchi ji,
not a legal expert, but................
who is going to arrest him
He always travels with legit and state provided heavily armed guards as is his sovereign right
It is his finger on the nuke button
no black/white/yellow joker can arrest him in India.
He travels with diplomatic immunity given him by the russian state, and in India he is under the sovereign protection of the Indian govt.
let them try and we will see
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 15:10
by Pratyush
Rsatchi wrote:A question to legal experts:
What is the locus standi of the ICC arrest warrant against Prez Putin??
a. Can he be served the warrant in Russia ??
b. Can be arrested when he visits another country?? (even though he has diplomatic immunity)
c. Impact of this on G20 Summit-can India still send an invite to him??
A) No No
C) Yes
As head of state Putin enjoys sovereign immunity. Any coercive action against him can only stand if Russia is defeated and occupied by the victor's.
It's meaningless in the absence of a total Russian capitulation.
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 15:15
by Pratyush
Rsatchi wrote:And given this experiment:
Can BIF's on the back of PeePeeSee Crapumentary go to ICC against NaMo??
Yes they can. But India is not a part of the ICC. The Indian judiciary has already given it's verdict on the topic. The ICC award can only be enforced when India is defeated and occupied.
Rsatchi wrote:
Apart from G20 any major engagements for Namo before the 2024 elections??
Do we still have the UN (Gen Ass)meet this year??
It's immaterial what Modi has to do before the next elections.
General Assembly meets every year.
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 16:34
by Lisa
Rsatchi wrote:A question to legal experts:
What is the locus standi of the ICC arrest warrant against Prez Putin??
a. Can he be served the warrant in Russia ??
b. Can be arrested when he visits another country?? (even though he has diplomatic immunity)
c. Impact of this on G20 Summit-can India still send an invite to him??
All these questions are mute. Russia is not a member of the ICC. End Off.
All these shenanigans are opium for the masses - look Putin has committed mass murder etc.....
By circulating these videos and making people aware of the acute danger. Soros and his tentacles are everywhere but not exactly hidden.
Remind them of who else he is funding.
Remind them of the desecration of the National Flag during Republic Day and the involvement of of groups funded by him.
How they insult our PM who has kept India developing fast during a time of Global mayhem.
There are Khalistan related groups whose leaders are connected with Open Society.
Quote what Khalistanis and leftists say about Hindus and how so many of them can be traced back to these same networks. This is all in the open.
Point out the destruction he has caused in other countries.
Make their blood boil. As this should.
I would not be surprised if the Soros network contacts reach into the Supreme Court. The way they move with urgency when organizations involving his network are involved is telling, even as millions of cases languish for decades.
Let me introduce a couple of terms:
Open Society and entities associated with it: Soros Parivar
A member of any of those organizations: Sorosi
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 18 Mar 2023 19:59
by Manish_P
Srutayus wrote:
By circulating these videos and making people aware of the acute danger. Soros and his tentacles are everywhere but not exactly hidden.
Remind them of who else he is funding.
...
They are aware of decade old lies/propaganda of the scums oof the Soreass gangs. They are aware of the narrative. They will strike so hard against these scums when time comes. Like banning any companies from doing business in India. They are patient and always thinking
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 19 Mar 2023 05:02
by krithivas
As the Indian FM said, The Indian election season has definitely started in the US with NYT b&m-ing about Indian public opinion. He’s the World’s Most Popular Leader. Beware. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/18/opin ... india.html
PM speech at India Today conclave.
Few veiled political jibes but a lot of positivity, accomplishment, achievement and insight.
What's amazing is his command over facts that he can reel off without prompts or hesitations. He is easily the world's best orator!
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 19 Mar 2023 14:33
by Cyrano
I saw there was a teleprompter, but NaMo might not be using it to read line by line. Perhaps bullet points.
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 19 Mar 2023 22:17
by SRajesh
https://indianexpress.com/article/polit ... s-8506611/
This is interesting
And if really true then left /Congress combo May face trouble in 2024
Wonder if this is due to the PFI/SDPI/LEFT hand in hand in love jihad on large scale
Re: Road to the 2024 Elections in India-1
Posted: 19 Mar 2023 23:18
by chetak
Rsatchi wrote:https://indianexpress.com/article/polit ... s-8506611/
This is interesting
And if really true then left /Congress combo May face trouble in 2024
Wonder if this is due to the PFI/SDPI/LEFT hand in hand in love jihad on large scale
This is fickle and overtly transactional and an open solicitation. It cannot be sustained even in the short to medium term because they will ask for an MSP like legislation to protect their interests on a permenent basis.
There will be a large number who will not agree with him because many of their ilk are out in other states on what is politely describable as conversion cabals
The community is far too educated to vote like a bunch of sheep.
no different from when the dravidians hand out sarees, pressure cookers, stoves, and teevees...
Many will take the money, vote where they want, and some may even visit the confessional in exchange for three hail marys
For their votes, they will choose the candidate and paint him/her in BJP colors. This is fickle and overtly transactional and an open solicitation. It cannot be sustained even in the short to medium term because they will ask for an MSP like legislation to protect their interests on a permenent basis.
There will be a large number who will not agree with him because many of their ilk are out in other states on what is politely describable as conversion cabals
The community is far too educated to vote like a bunch of sheep.
no different from when the dravidians hand out sarees, pressure cookers, stoves, and teevees...
Many will take the money, vote where they want, and some may even visit the confessional in exchange for three hail marys
For their votes, they will tactically choose the candidate and paint him/her in BJP colors. There was already one such trojan horse guy, sangliana in KAR, as an example and it was not a happy experience.