Hari Seldon wrote:^^Am sure sanku ji will prove swapanda wrong.
He would know the inner workings of the sangh so much better than casual commentators like swapan da after all.
.
Actually I will, and this does not require any knowledge of Sangh at all, the article is fairly poor by Swapan Da's standards, and the self contradictions are obvious.
Let us see his points
I.
Swapan da wrote:verdict in Karnataka against the BJP had everything to do with the quality of administration, the venality of those associated with the party and the vengeful conduct of those who felt that they had been unjustly treated by a cabal that drew its power from Delhi. In short, it was a protest against bad governance and worse politics.
Interesting, a contradiction in the first statement its,
people responsible for the poor quality of administration + venality == vengeful conduct == Yeddurappa camp.
So what is Swapan Da saying, its ok to be venal and poor administrator as long as central BJP gives you free reign? For a right of center commentator with strong moral foundation that is particularly low.
Yeddurappa's antics were tolerated ONLY because he has a section of votes with him, so apparently, poor administration + venality + anti party activities are all justified if you can get 10% votes. Personally, I think if BJP is looking for such a deal, it may be better off merging directly with JD(S).
II.
Swapan wrote:First, even assuming that every vote for both the KJP and the BSR Congress (the outfit floated by the bent and beautiful of Bellary district) had gone in favour of a united BJP, the Congress would still have squeaked through, albeit not so conclusively. The fact, after all, remains that the Congress outpolled the combined votes of the BJP, KJP and BSR Congress by a whopping six per cent.
This is a particularly poor understanding displayed by Swapan da.
Lets see here
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home ... 997273.cms
Most early analyses have emphasized that BJP's vote share has declined by a whopping 13%, from 33.86% (2008) to 19.95% (2013). That is nearly as much as the combined vote-share gain of the KJP and BSRC. The KJP polled 9.84% and BSRC secured 2.69% of votes. As the 2008 election vote share of the undivided BJP included KJP and BSRC, one must first recognize that these political formations taken together have not lost vote-share in Karnataka. Hence, there has been no substantial shift in voter preferences for the Congress, JD(S) or BJP and its derivatives . It would be erroneous to interpret this mandate to be a decisive rejection of the BJP and its breakaway factions.
Even in 2008, Congress was ahead of BJP+KJP+BRS; Is it Swapan Da's case that the exact same vote division was acceptance of BJP in 2008 and its rejection in 2013?
Come on Swapan Da, you can do better than this.
III
The needless feud that resulted in Yeddyurappa walking out of the party he had helped build, resulted in the Mutually Assured Destruction of both the BJP and the KJP.
Umm, how did KJP get destroyed? It has polled impressive 10% in its first showing? And after arguing for ages that it was mismanagement of BJP and not the vote split, he now is saying that vote split in destroying both?
If you do a 360* rant, some points will certainly be valid, but the job of a political commentator is to tie it together in a coherent whole, an essay, not fall to pieces trying to connect contradictions.
So all in all, a fairly fairly poor piece, and I have only taken a stab at half of it. The other half is equally lousy.
=========================================================================
Also I do not get the "supporters" of BJP asking BJP to leave this or that to win--
1) First it was good that BJP left Hindutva on back burner to win.
2) Then it was ok to leave morality in terms of corruption to win.
3) Now it is also ok to say F off to governance to win.
So tell me again, is the greatest goal of supporters of BJP to make BJP into another INC and then declare victory for INC school of thought?
Heck INC school of thought is anyway winning in the country, the whole idea is that "surat badlni chahiye" (things should change)