ASPuar wrote:The issue is very much so, that how can you ask the army officer to give up his orderly, when others will not?
Sir, were'nt you earlier saying that Army is all okay to stop the practise of
Sahayak and that it was MoD civilian staff who will through the spanner in the works? And I guess this was one thing which you wished
chackojoseph to check up.
I would reiterate my stand that professionaly trained people (be it police, army or even a railway gang man) should NOT be employed in the capacity of personal servant. Especially at the homes of the senior officers, with no one to see what work is getting allocated to them.
Sachin in the interim is the first to pounce on the sahayak issue, (even though turns out it wasnt true), but he will forgive any number of IPS officers who have their constables clean their toilets at home.
Can you show me one post of mine in which I have supported the IPS officers in keeping the police constables as Orderlies/Sahayaks?
anjan wrote:Given the setting of the incident I was confused by the leap of faith taken in immediately assigning the blame without a full incident report.
I go by media reports. Sorry, the media may have it own negative aspects. But I for sure would not take a stand that Army is 100% perfect, and the remaining folks in the country are 100% bad, corrupt people. I for sure, am not going to see any official report in this case, because I am not authorised to.
It's especially interesting coming from a person who spends his time strenuously defending the police and asking people not to draw general conclusions based on the conduct of a few.
I am talking about a system which can be misused. Others have also shared their own observations on this misuse. No one has said that every Army officer misuses the system. But there are folks who do it. So either chuck out the system, or bring in more checks and balances which can be verified.
Any way I am happy to see that discussion on
Sahayaks have become more in the lines of
"The IPS wallahs have umpteen, why cant the Army wallahs have a few".