16 policemen including Dy SP gunned down near Nagpur by Maoists...



I think reviving Tagore's humnaism is essential. I dont know about the older economic ideas. In the demise of the left the field should not be left open for soul harvesters of either kind to bring in Kingdom of God or Allah.OPED | Saturday, May 23, 2009 | Email | Print |
Road to Renaissance-2
Udayan Namboodiri
Can we be certain that May 16 was India's day of liberation from the Communist scourge? Much depends on how the Bengali clinches the bigger war ahead recalling the Tagore-Gandhi vision
October 20, 2007 had coincided with Maha Navami, the penultimate day of the Durga Puja festivities. It's a day when the celebrations reach a wistful peak. For, on the morrow, Bijoya Dashami, the Devi returns to her husband's abode, and it will be back to the daily grind for her people, the Bengalis.
I saw that year's merry- making through the prism of Singur, Nandigram, the Rizwanur incident and the ration shop scandal. Perhaps, I thought, the Devi had noticed a new pluck in the Bengali. Missing was the defeatism, gone was the self-flagellating Bengali reconciled to his predicament. In place was an unbelievable peasant-bhadraloke alliance to wage peaceful, democratic war on a criminal regime which, apart from destroying everything that was decent in Bengal over 30 years of deceit, terror and corruption, had also emasculated Bengal's ability to contribute substantively to the greater Indian good.
Last Saturday, May 16, we were vindicated. The CPI(M) and its allies were smashed in the Lok Sabha election; reduced to just 15 seats from a state they counted as their strategic depth in their anti-national crusade. The disaggregated results shows that the once-unconquerable alliance had trailed in 194 of the 294 Assembly segments. This, clearly, is the beginning of the end.
But it's not the time to strut about in malicious satisfaction. Forget the pipsqueaks who mocked the farmers of Singur on the afternoon of September 3, 2006 when they rose for the first time against the powerful Communist-Tata-Media triumvirate, filling every cell of the Bengali collective being with profound energy. Now is the time to prepare for not only the last battle which is officially programmed for April-May 2011, but also the years of reconstruction that would follow.
Before reconstructing Bengal's democracy, industry and agriculture, the Bengali mindset has to be recast in the modern mould. I now suggest the algorithm:
1. New Leftism:
Some people are frightened that the Left Front may be replaced by a 'Lefter' Front. Sunanda K. Datta-Ray wrote in The Pioneer this week that the new 'M' in CPI(M) may be 'Mamata'. By a series of historical accidents, India's Communists have come to hog the entire 'Left' space. It is forgotten that even the RSS, which the Communists condemn as 'rightist', has a Left-wing economic outlook which the late Dattopant Thengadi articulated through a powerful trade union movement. As for the CPI(M), it is guilty of everything but practicing socialism in Bengal. Under Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, the State has withdrawn the economic rights of the poor and has turned Bengal over to land grabbers and freebooters. Viewed from the perspective of the global economic slowdown, the Left (not Communism) has a new relevance in the 21st century. Barack Obama is nationalising banks. On December 10, 2008, Germany's finance minister Peer Steinbruck launched an outspoken attack on Britain's Thatcherite shibboleth of credit-financed growth. Everywhere else, yesterday's free marketers are re-learning their economics. So, why deny Mamata Banerjee's entitlement to seek the revitalisation of the original Leftist energy of Bengal.
Post May 16, the campaign of some Buddhajeebis (see Lookback for definition) to cast the anti-CPI(M) struggle in Maoist colours has become irrelevant. However, the essential Leftist core of the Bengali worldview, to which Rabindranath Tagore's humanism and Vivekananda-Aurbindo's spiritualism contributed much, remains unaffected by the CPI(M)-led 'Left Front's' distortion of the socialist dream.
Some time in the summer of 2007, Mamata Banerjee corrected a close associate who was going on and on about being "Baam Birodhi" (anti-Left). She said: "I think you should stick to CPM Birodhi (anti-CPM) because we need the Leftists on our side". Now we know what she meant. She was astute enough to realise that no election could be won in Bengal by excluding the real Leftist -- the non-Communist socialist.
2. Tagorean socialitarian ideal
"The Bengali will remember me on occasions both joyous and sad, my poetry and songs will fill their lives at all times". Bengalis uphold this famous truism in their daily lives, but in a mechanical, soulless sort of way. The greatest gems of Tagore are largely forgotten and, if recalled, could prove instructive to planning the great Bengal rebound. Not one word uttered by Mamata Banerjee in the anti-Singur or Nandigram struggle is actually original. Her Ma-Mati-Manush war cry is unconscious revivification of Tagore's appeal for harmony. In his letter to Kalimohan Ghosh from Berlin in 1930, Tagore rued the lack of harmony in the western model of economic planning. What was needed for India, Tagore stressed, was: "harmony between man and man, man and nature, city and village, science and society and society and state".
So, Bengalis must rediscover the economist in Rabindranath. His plan for erecting proud, self-sufficient villages anticipated even Mahatma Gandhi’s gram swaraj. "The villages in the country must be built up to be completely self-sufficient and able to supply all their own needs", Tagore wrote in The Cooperative Principles, 1928. In an address to volunteers who worked on his rural project in Sriniketan village in 1937, Tagore said: "We must so endeavour that the villages themselves gain the strength to working along with us. If I can free only one or two villages from the bonds of ignorance and weakness, there will be built, on a tiny scale, an ideal for the whole of India". This also formed the nucleus of Mahatma Gandhi's great economic theories, which the world today is finally acknowledging. The leitmotif of the anti-SEZ campaign should be to preserve the essential India, which both Tagore and Gandhi held, lives in her villages.
Tagore believed that the State must maintain the conditions necessary to promote good life and help the expression of those moral and spiritual aspirations of man which belongs to his higher nature. He also opposed the Communist principle of class struggle.
3. Environmentalism
Globalisation's heyday is over. The United Nations is in the process of evolving the "Green New Deal" under which national development plans would discard energy-intensive industrialisation leading to global warming. The new mantra is 'more jobs, more social profit, less pollution'. Singur and Nandigram will be recalled as the world's biggest environment struggles. To Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee, the environment is expendable. "Jobs first, progress lies in converting villages into cities", he said in a speech on the occasion of the golden jubilee of Ganashakti, the CPI(M)'s mouthpiece, in January 2007.
Bengal needs a 'green new deal' more than any other state. In the months to come, Bengali economic thinkers must evolve a sustainable development plan based on jute diversification, the proposals of the Bamboo Mission, food processing, floriculture and the small-is-beautiful model. After 15 years of Buddhadeb's suicidal Shilpayan (industrialisation), Bengal is the world's dumping ground of dangerous industries.
Conclusion: Aping the west is an old behaviorial disorder in Kolkata. The chattering Bengali, rolling off unidiomatic English in a funny accent has, thankfully, left Bengal and is busy think-tanking for other people's battles. The next Bengal renaissance must be home grown with the poorest Bengali's wholesome development at the centre.
-- The writer is author of Bengal's Night Without End (New Delhi, 2006) and Senior Editor, The Pioneer
And what did he say on ways to improve Military?brihaspati wrote:Tagore's main experiments in Sriniketan were about economic reforms - (1) microcredit (2) cooperative store (3) small scale and cottage industries - handlooms, pottery, you name it (3) cooperative agriculture and agrarian innovation.
Rahul Mehta wrote:And what did he say on ways to improve Military?brihaspati wrote:Tagore's main experiments in Sriniketan were about economic reforms - (1) microcredit (2) cooperative store (3) small scale and cottage industries - handlooms, pottery, you name it (3) cooperative agriculture and agrarian innovation.
If nothing, doesnt that prove that he was an intellectuals planted by West to misguide Indian youth? For if any person is worried about Nation, the two things he will NOT ignore is poverty reduction and improving Military. If Tagore refused to give details about Military can be improved, isnt he useless for modern day India?
Rahul M,brihaspati: Tagore's main experiments in Sriniketan were about economic reforms - (1) microcredit (2) cooperative store (3) small scale and cottage industries - handlooms, pottery, you name it (3) cooperative agriculture and agrarian innovation.
Rahul Mehta: And what did he say on ways to improve Military? if nothing, doesnt that prove that he was an intellectuals planted by West to misguide Indian youth? For if any person is worried about Nation, the two things he will NOT ignore is poverty reduction and improving Military. If Tagore refused to give details about (how) Military can be improved, isnt he useless for modern day India?
Rahul M:![]()
New Delhi, May 24: More than four lakh tribals have been displaced due to extremists activists by Maoists in various parts of India, a non-government organisation has claimed in its latest report.
"A total of 4,01,425 tribals have been displaced due to armed conflicts and ethnic conflicts across India," Asian Indegenous and Tribal People's Network (AITPN), which has special consultative status with the UN's Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC), claimed in its report.
"These displaced persons (tribals) have been living miserable lives without basic amenities including food, water, shelter, medical services, sanitation and livelihood opportunities," it added.
About 1.2 lakh members of Gutti Koya tribes of Bastar and Bijapur districts of Chhattisgarh fled to Andhra Pradesh's Khammam between January to June last year to escape violence by the Maoists and the Salwa Judum activists, the report said.
But, these benefits were later withdrawn by the Andhra Pradesh government soon after Maoists killed more than 30 Greyhound personnel in an ambush at Chitrakonda reservoir in Orissa on June 29 last year and police accused Gutti Koya tribals of being supporters of the Maoists, the report said.
Warangal/Hyderabad, May 24 : Maoists in Andhra Pradesh suffered a jolt today with top Naxal leader Patel Sudhakar Reddy, allegedly involved in several cases including a bid on the life of former chief minister N Chandrababu Naidu, and another cadre being killed in an encounter with police near here.
Sudhakar Reddy, a member of the central committee of CPI-Maoists, and Venkataiah were killed in the Lavella forest area in Tadwai Mandal of Warangal district about 6 am, Warangal SP V C Sajjanar said.
Reddy, a native of Kurthirao Cheruvu in Mahabubnagar district, was allegedly involved in the bid on the life of Naidu at Tirupati in 2003 and killings of then home minister A Madhava Reddy in 2000 and also senior IPS officers K S Vyas and Umesh Chandra. (MORE)
http://www.umeshchandra.orgzeenews wrote: Reddy, a native of Kurthirao Cheruvu in Mahabubnagar district, was allegedly involved in the bid on the life of Naidu at Tirupati in 2003 and killings of then home minister A Madhava Reddy in 2000 and also senior IPS officers K S Vyas and Umesh Chandra. (MORE)
From twitter of binayak sen supporter :derkonig wrote:Misscarriage of justice: Naxal terrorist Binayak Sen is granted bail by SC.
justice rajinder sachar is also appearing on behalf of binayak.
then the hearing starts...case number 13 being heard now. It will take another 20 min to start hearing of binayak's bail plea
judge did not even want to hear prosecution lawyer! dismissed him in one sentence 'bail granted'
Have always said, respect for judiciary aside that one person on the vacation bench is truly out of his mind.binayak will be released in raipur today on personal bond.
Is Sen a terrorist or just a non-violent sympathizer?derkonig wrote:Misscarriage of justice: Naxal terrorist Binayak Sen is granted bail by SC.
I wonder how much of this speedy justice is due to the emboldening of EJ forces after the national elections.AjayKK wrote:judge did not even want to hear prosecution lawyer! dismissed him in one sentence 'bail granted'Fast justice indeed.
Note how the article portrays Binayak Sen is a simple doctor just working for the poor people. Also note how Prasanna Zore has the original letter that he has posted up.... when was the last time Rediff put up original letters?After spending 22 months in prison, human rights activist Dr Binayak Sen was granted bail by the Supreme Court on Monday.
I hope he does'nt make such statements in the formal judgement (a written document)sum wrote:Not that his judgements are wrong, but he seems to blurt out some horrible things in the final judgement.
political correctness is simply a sweetened word for hypocrisy, when the bias is towards the *ahem* correct side.shiv wrote:
Does "Bharat-Rakshak" need this hypocritical bias?
Yeah.............so ??ravi_ku wrote:Raji
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCarthyism
raji wrote:Shiv,
Just a factual correction. Communism is not illegal in the US. .
and my responseravi_ku wrote:Shiv, we are moving OT and I could not find a better place, I am posting my reply in the whines thread.
http://forums.bharat-rakshak.com/viewto ... 41#p678141
Well..more efforts to divide Mother India. I hope her sons that are in positions of power are not ostriches.When the engineer came to this sylvan southwestern corner of West Bengal in May, his estimate for rebuilding a canal was Rs 2 crore. The government didn’t call him. The villagers didn’t call him. The man from Jadavpur University — an institution known for its engineering department — was called in by Maoists to this sylvan land of 1,100 villages where a seminal change is unfolding in the way India’s most-powerful and long-lived extremist movement works.
Here across a 1,000-sq-km area bordering Orissa in West Midnapore district, the Maoists over the last eight months have quietly unleashed new weapons in their battle against the Indian state: drinking water, irrigation, roads and health care.
Carefully shielded from the public eye, the Hindustan Times found India’s second “liberated zone”, a Maoist-run state within a state where development for more than 2 lakh people is unfolding at a pace not seen in 30 years of Left rule.
The paper here refers to "People's Daily"...The paper described as “wishful thinking” that “gratitude for India’s restraint” in joining the “ring around China” established by the United States and Japan would see China deferring to Indian demands on territorial disputes.