Atmavik wrote:While we see frustration in other threads some amazing work is going on in Railways . We can see huge excitement for Vande bharat trains as they are rolled out
@Vsunder saab why is edfc single stack as compared to double of wdfc? Googling did not help
There are three reasons this happened. People if at all only talk of one. The three reasons are
1. Historical 2. Nature of the Freight carried by EDFC 3. The downgrading of Kolkata port.
1. Historical
The History of Railway electrification in India appears a bit in the article I wrote elsewhere, which is attached to the end of this post with a tongue in cheek title. I urge you to read that article. To summarize a bit what I say in that article is that true Railway electrification began in Eastern India in 1958-1959 with 25 kv AC traction. No doubt 1500V DC existed in the Mumbai area but 25kV which became the standard for IR started on Eastern Railway to better evacauate coal from mines and ore in the Dhanbad--Asansol belt and supply steel plants in Durgapur. This area saw rapid electrification at a rate seen by no other zone. So quickly masts were erected at standard height around 5m. You can gauge this by the fact that ER, SER, East Coast Railway attained 100% electrification so quickly when the Government went in for 100% electrification.
Now what does this mean.
It means that all the feeder lines to the EDFC were already electrified with masts set at standard 5.5m height. Now let us look at the other side. Gujarat, Khambahat, Rajasthan was a maze of single lined MG, NG tracks. Delhi to Ahmedabad was a MG track in the 1990s. Slowly they got gauge converted. Then when the DFCs were mooted and the policy of 100% electrification accepted in the last 10 years all these lines to ports, the feeder lines to the WDFC got electrified from scratch and could be built to double stack container traffic standards. Look today to Western Railway, stands at 73% electrification and Northwestern Railway at 60% electrification. These are the WDFC feeders and they are still a work in progress. If Eastern railway had minimal electrification you could build the feeders to high mast standards today. But to change all the extensive network of electrification in the East to high mast so all feeders can bring in double stack container is just prohibitive in terms of cost.
The feeder lines for the WDFC are all in Gujarat, none in MH which does have all standard height OHE. The last feeder line going South on the WDFC is Hazira port near Surat. Hazira is petrochemicals and so does not need high mast. Then there no ports south of Hazira till the line ends at JNPT which needs thus no feeder. A port has been proposed at Palghar in MH, but since WDFC is passing so close to the coast here, a short feeder at high mast can be easily built. Maersk for example paid some of the cost to build high mast OHE from Pipavav port to Surendranagar to connect to WR double tracks to Sanand and the WDFC. Now they run Pratigya Express with a guaranteed 55 hour transit time from Delhi NCR to Pipavav via the WDFC.
2. Nature of the Freight The EDFC mainly carries, Coal, Ore, Stones, Fertilizer and Ore. That is bulk goods. So the need to be equipped to carry double stack containers is not that great and so again the need to modify existing electric traction equipment is minimal.
3. Kolkata Port Kolkata port has fast lost its significance as a container port. Haldia is there with Petrochemicals which does not require double stacked containers and Paradip in Orissa is suurounded by a network of lines equipped with standard height OHE. Thus again the feeder lines from Paradip to the EDFC cannot transport containers that are double stacked.
Again I think a decision has been taken due to the non-cooperative nature of the Mamata Banerjee govt. and increasing effort to complete the Land acquisition process in WB, Land acquisition being a state subject, the EDFC will be terminated just inside the WB border at Bandel and will not terminate at Dankuni 100km away.
This should not be taken lightly. Uddhav Thackeray came close to derailing the WDFC with zero help in acquiring land in the Vaitarna--JNPT section. Even today 5 patches of land totaling 1.73km between Vaitarna and JNPT is holding up this last section and the completion date is pushed to June 2024 due to a combination of poor performance by Tata and its Japanese collaborator Mitsui(JICA had insisted that Indian firms have to work in tandem with a Japanese firm on the WDFC, so L&T and Sojitz for example who are doing Rewari to Makarpura and Dadri to Rewari) and this LA issue.
OK Here is the article I wrote, which explains the history a bit more of Railway electrification in India. There were pictures that went with the article. On the original page where the article appeared, the pictures are there. They were taken by me at the Rail Museum in Chanakyapuri in New Delhi.
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Why do Electric Loco Pilots(Drivers) Speak French on Indian Railways??
Well not quite, but indeed they use French terms. Before that a bit of History. Electric locomotives were introduced onto Indian Railways in the Mumbai area in 1929 with 1500Volts DC(Direct Current) locomotives manufactured by the Swiss locomotive works and Vulcan loco works. These locomotives had long snouts in front of them and were called "Crocodiles" in Europe and "Khekhada(crabs)" by the local railwaymen in the Mumbai area. Kalyan electric loco shed was the first electric loco shed in India, housing these 1500V DC(Direct Current) locos. Remarkably these crocodiles were still visible doing shunting duties in the Mumbai area till the early 2000s and DC power remained in the Mumbai area till 2015 when finally it gave way to all AC (Alternating Current)power.
Here is a picture I took of a crocodile on display at the Indian Railway museum in Chanakyapuri, New Delhi. It is the first crocodile to be commissioned. The loco is named after Sir Leslie Wilson a Governor of Mumbai and the GIP emblazoned on the livery stands for The Great Indian Peninsular Railway, the forerunner of Central Railway CR today.
Post independence, in 1958, the Govt. of India (GOI) approached SNCF(Societe Nationale des Chemin de Fer) the French National rail carrier for advice on future electrification of Indian railways. Wisely SNCF advised GOI to run AC powered electric locos which will run on 25,000 volts(25 kilo volts, 25kv). AC powered locos have superior tractive ability and are ideal to haul heavy freight laden with coal from the Jharia coalmines around Dhanbad on the Grand Chord, connecting Asansol and Mughalsarai now Deen Dayal Upadhyay Jn.(DDU) Thus Eastern Railway became the first railway zone where electrification started with 25kv AC. In 1959 a short section, Howrah to Seoraphuli on the Howrah--Bardhaman(Burdwan) line saw EMU, suburban passenger train units operational and the electric network spread on the Grand Chord to DDU from Howrah and over time to Kanpur and Delhi by 1976. It is now understandable why French terminology began to permeate operational manuals on Indian railways and became the lingo loco pilots used and still use on Indian railways. The early electric AC locomotives from 1959 onwards were Hitachi, Japanese built locos before Chittaranjan Loco works started building Indian variants.
Now that we have the history of AC(alternating current) traction, let us understand a bit the mechanics of how an AC electric loco runs and then we will understand the French words loco pilots use on Indian Railways. First power is manufactured at a power station and to minimize the loss of electricity by heat while sending it down a wire, it is sent at 132,000 volts to a substation along the tracks. These substations trackside are called TSSs or traction substations in railway parlance. Here the voltage is stepped down to 25,000 volts from 132,000volts and fed into the overhead wires from which the locos draw their power via the long pole like structures on the roof of a loco called a Pantograph. Now there is a serious problem. Current from a power station is sent as 3 phase or naively over 3 wires. But look, the loco makes contact with only ONE overhead wire. So there is a strange situation. Think of a person being pulled and only pulled in one direction. The person will be unbalanced. So if current is drawn from only one phase, there will be a serious mismatch at the power station and the generators will be damaged. Current has to be drawn UNIFORMLY from all three wires uniformly or else the entire grid will collapse leading to chaos. So how is this done? It is done by what are called NEUTRAL SECTIONS. Sections of the track are divided into 40km sections. Wire 1 feeds Section 1, Wire 2 feeds Section2 and Wire 3 feeds section 3. So the Load on the power station equipment is UNIFORM. But wait you cannot connect Section 1 with Section 2 and so on, you will have a massive short circuit. So what is done is that these sections are isolated from each other with a short length of about 10m of insulated material so that electricity of each phase never leaks into an adjacent section.
So when an electric loco is moving along on Indian Railways the assistant loco pilot (ALP) usually who has the responsibility of watching for all track side signs, caution warnings etc will suddenly see the sign of this diamond on a blue background.
This means that a Neutral section(separating wire 1 from wire 2 say) is approaching and is 500m away and he will warn the pilot by saying "Neutral Section 500m". At that point, the loco pilo and ALP will start shutting down, the blower units on the Loco(that keep the electronics cool, like the little fan on your laptop that starts up when your laptop gets too hot), they will also lower the Pantograph so that it ceases making contact with the overhead wire and the loco now essentially has no power being supplied to it, and is coasting on its own momentum. They will also pass a second sign of a Red diamond on a white background similar to the one displayed in my attachment with 250m written underneath, that means the loco is 250 m away from the Neutral section and is further warning to the drivers to get their act together. Soon they will see the sign in the middle of my attachment. When it is seen, the ALP will call out "DJ open" and that Voila is the French word, which means
Disjoncteur open or in English, Circuit Breaker open. Perhaps the French loco pilot says
Disjoncteur ouvert. This tells the loco pilot that the ALP has thrown the circuit breakers open. This act really and truly disconnects the loco from the electric network and completely isolates it from any power source. Now the loco is a dead shell hurtling along. Next comes the last sign in my attachment, which means the loco is past the neutral section and now truly in a section which is being powered by Wire 2. Now the ALP will say "DJ Closed" or
Disjoncteur closed, so the circuit breakers will be closed, the pantograph raised, blowers and electronics turned on and the loco again begins to draw power from the overhead wires and the process has to be repeated after 40km when one hits the next section and you have to cross a neutral section.
So the Indian electric loco pilot does not know Disjoncteur but DJ is just that and a reminder of the SNCF/French influence on training manuals in the 1959 era when the French developed and wrote the manuals for electric train drivers on Indian Railways, and so the French terminology and Francophone speak on Indian railways.
Of course there is a very small possibility that the loco stops in a neutral section. Then help is needed to push the train underneath wires that have electricity flowing through it. This is a very rare event.
DC operated trains still exist. Many of the metros Kanpur, Bangalore etc are powered by 750 volt DC power, that the train picks up through a third rail running parallel to the tracks. Third rail systems are easy to maintain than overhead wire systems and DC powered trains accelerate quicker than AC ones, and so are ideal for Metro operations where load is not important but quick starting and accelerating is paramount for Metro trains.