Re: Indo-Israel: News and Discussion
Posted: 05 Nov 2009 15:33
Israel tension begins again http://www.world-check.com/articles/200 ... justment-/
Consortium of Indian Defence Websites
https://forums.bharat-rakshak.com/
Concerns are growing in Israel's government over the possibility of a unilateral Palestinian declaration of independence within the 1967 borders, a move which could potentially be recognized by the United Nations Security Council.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu recently asked the administration of U.S. President Barack Obama to veto any such proposal, after reports reached Jerusalem of support for such a declaration from major European Union countries, and apparently also certain U.S. officials.
The reports indicated that Palestinian Prime Minister Salam Fayyad has reached a secret understanding with the Obama administration over U.S. recognition of an independent Palestinian state. Such recognition would likely transform any Israeli presence across the Green Line, even in Jerusalem, into an illegal incursion to which the Palestinians would be entitled to engage in measures of self-defense.
absolutely not fine, unless they operate with explicit knowledge and permission of GOI and its agencies. do you think if the reverse happened israel, or any other govt for that matter would have allowed R&AW to operate in that country ?Ananya wrote:what is wrong with that they are not acting against India , they are acting agant some Jihadist which perfectly fine
This is the ambassador of the islamic republic of palestine. He's probably also stated before that Mossad was responsible for 9/11, 26/11, Ford Edsel, malfunctioning wardrobes, Jacko, Jackie-O,........ You get the drift.shyamd wrote:‘Mossad’ active in India too: Palestine Ambassador
Twocircles dot net is an islamic propaganda site, not to be taken seriously but helps to understand what and how the indian muslims think.shyamd wrote:‘Mossad’ active in India too: Palestine Ambassador
Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.anuj wrote:Twocircles dot net is an islamic propaganda site, not to be taken seriously but helps to understand what and how the indian muslims think.shyamd wrote:‘Mossad’ active in India too: Palestine Ambassador
May I ask what you mean by this?Dhiman wrote: Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.
Same questionasprinzl wrote:May I ask what you mean by this?Dhiman wrote: Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.
Avram
asprinzl wrote:May I ask what you mean by this?Dhiman wrote: Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.
Avram
Have you counted the number of Arab members of the Knesset? Or looked at how many of them are openly critical of Israel?Dhiman wrote:Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.
Muslims in India and Israel, at least you got the spirit of their existence in both countries right . Same spirit ought to be applied in any discussion about their domicile in any other civilized society. Consciously or subcosciously, all thinking people knows deep down that only way to recognize the problem is full fledged separation between Kuffar and Krafties.[/quote][/quote]Prem wrote:[quote="Dhiman]Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.
Avram,asprinzl wrote:May I ask what you mean by this?Dhiman wrote: Good to know, but the fact remains that Muslims in India are still allowed to think unlike in Israel.
Avram
Dhiman, Could you explain how Israel is forcefully converting people of other religions qnd how is it a inhuman state ? Is it because they are simply trying to survive in a cesspool of terrorists and crazy sheikh's who do nothing but fire rockets at Israel or blow themselves in public.Dhiman wrote:
If you bracket Israel and Pakistan, I would understand that because both are religious, fanatical, and inhumane states that either kick out people belonging to a particular religion and/or forcefully convert them. India on the other hand is neither a religious state, nor fanatical, and nor inhumane. We don't kick out people based on their religious affiliations, render them stateless, treat them as third-class citizens, or give free citizenship to non-citizens of particular religious groups to replace those who have been kicked out. Personally I find it offensive that any Indian would see some kind of a moral lesson out of what is going on in Israel. In fact what is going on in Israel is a lesson in what not to do.
Personally, I have absolutely zero interst in either Israeli or Pakistani views, however your views regarding some sort of a full-fledged separation are a complete antithesis to what India has been about over the last 60 years, what Indian freedom movement and partition was about, and infact what 10,000 years of Indian history has shown. Rest assured you know it as well as I do that your views are in extreme minority not just now but over the overall course of Indian history and highly offensive in many ways.
Thanks, but lets not feed such delusional behavior by responding to it. Nothing works better than ignoring such crass ignorance (or worse!).VikasRaina wrote:
Dhiman, Could you explain how Israel is forcefully converting people of other religions qnd how is it a inhuman state ? .......
I have no interest in preaching the word, but if someone tells me that we are supposed to draw some kind of moral lessons from Israel as to how to deal with our own minor social conflicts, I completely disagree with that and even find any thinking along those lines offensive. These guys have been in a virtual state of civil war ever since Israel came into being and India is nowhere near the same case.VikasRaina wrote: Lets not ride the moral horse here and sit on high moral pedestal and preach the world. If separation based upon religion was such a anti-thesis to Indian psyche, Wonder from where did 37 crore people on the left and right flank of India appeared.
Incorrect, both are religious state and both were established primarily for members of a particular religion and that is one of the major source of problems in both cases. Irrespective of any modern (or western) notions of "separation of church and state", the concept that members of one religion (or one religion) has priority over other is exactly opposite of what Indian history and value system has shown.Any statement which puts Israel and Bakistan in the same category loses its credibility and is no better than troll-ish behavior.
So you mean to tell me that Indians (or Hindus in particular) haven't faced insurmountable odds for existence. In fact, given that India is the only culture in world which has had complete cultural continuity, I think we have done a better job than anyone else and so I don't see any reason to change our age old survival and growth techniques as opposed to Israeli's who are embroiled in a non-ending quagmire ever since their existence.They have faced unsurmountable odds for their existence in last 60 years and made sure that their enemies would never wipe them off the map. Thats one lesson for starters we should learn from them.
Sure we can learn some of their security techniques as in how to reinforce a fence, etc, but I don't see any possibility of learning any lessons what-so-ever when it comes to deal with social issues, social conflicts, treatment of minorities, setting social policies, or anything related to society as a whole and specially not a second partition of either people, land, or resources.
You have zero interest in Israeli or Pakistani view but when same Pakistani explode bombs and kill Indians (& now Jews too) all over the world, Their Views and thought process become important.
don't mind me saying it but you also seem to have zero knowledge to go with it.I have absolutely zero interst in either Israeli or Pakistani views
Oh well, I guess all the people with knowledge are busy fighting and keeping scores in mid-east of who kicked out who how many thousands or hundreds years ago how many times, so who am I to speakRahul M wrote:dhiman, you will save yourself a lot of embarrassment if you read up a little on the formation of the modern state of israel. at the moment your comments are simply dripping of ignorance on this issue.don't mind me saying it but you also seem to have zero knowledge to go with it.I have absolutely zero interst in either Israeli or Pakistani views
Sadler, I have nothing against Dhiman, but statements which show ignorance (atleast from my POV) need to be challenged and rebutted. Letting folks do Israeli equal equal with Pakis or Hamas / Hezbollah terrorists does not help the cause of this battle against violence and terrorism.Sadler wrote:Thanks, but lets not feed such delusional behavior by responding to it. Nothing works better than ignoring such crass ignorance (or worse!).VikasRaina wrote:
Dhiman, Could you explain how Israel is forcefully converting people of other religions qnd how is it a inhuman state ? .......
India, Israel to ramp up military ties
TNN 10 December 2009, 02:26am IST
NEW DELHI: India and Israel have decided to further bolster their already expansive military ties, especially in areas like joint R&D defence projects, counter-terrorism and intelligence-sharing.
This came after visiting Israeli Defence Forces chief of general staff Lt-General Gabi Ashkenazi met national security advisor M K Narayanan, Army chief General Deepak Kapoor, IAF chief Air Chief Marshal P V Naik and Navy chief Admiral Nirmal Verma on Wednesday. .....................
TOI
Dixitji,Karan Dixit wrote:Dhiman,
First of all I do not believe Israel is as bad as you are making it out to be. But let us assume for the argument's sake that Israel is bad. But one thing is clear and cannot be disputed - Israelis have been a good friend to India. They have always provided us with moral and diplomatic support in our hours or crisis.
So, the question you need to ask yourself is this:
Is this a wise thing to demonize a good friend who always stands by you in your hour of need?
My answer is no.
Stop this juvenile behavior. It is not necessary.Dhiman wrote:Do you want me to get banned
I asked a question in response to a direct query. What part of it did you find juvenile?anuj wrote:Stop this juvenile behavior. It is not necessary.Dhiman wrote:Do you want me to get banned
The question is, do you want to get banned? if you continue to behave in this manner then I will most certainly ban you without any second thoughts.Dhiman wrote: Do you want me to get banned
Sir,archan wrote:The question is, do you want to get banned? if you continue to behave in this manner then I will most certainly ban you without any second thoughts.Dhiman wrote: Do you want me to get banned
Take your gabbar singh humor with that smart-assed attitude elsewhere. Do not disrupt threads.
OWW... And he pulls out the "Im the victim" card.Dhiman wrote:its my view of indo-israeli relationship that is causing problem here.