Hari Seldon wrote:
Its a real politik world out there. Everyone out there is practicing, refining, honing, perfecting deception 24x7 out there. No?
JMTs of course.
I disagree.
The art of practicing deception is best left to the professionals. When amateurs do it, more often than not they end up deceiving themselves.
A Henry Kissinger or K. Subrahmanyan is being paid to think 24X7 about how to advance his country's national interest and screw over any existing or potential adversary that stands in his country's path. They live and breathe this stuff. The public statements and articles in which they speak in equivocal, reasonable terms are an occasional "aside" for them. Their real perspective is the stuff that their bread and butter is made of, so they will never lose sight of it.
It isn't the same for amateurs, and however seriously we may take ourselves, the fact remains that 99.9% of BRF-ites are (national security) amateurs onlee. We have other things to worry about most of the time. As it is, in the outside world we have to watch what we say... here at least, we should have the freedom to speak our minds.
If this place too becomes a haven of political correctness, we risk deluding ourselves (until the next Mumbai or whatever) as to the real nature of the Pakistanis. Worse, we risk deluding other well-intentioned newcomers who read our oh-so-reasonable posts about the poor Pakis dying in the floods, conveying the underlying impression that "they are like us onlee." After all, if we feel sorry for these vermin dying in the floods, isn't it a short jump from there to feeling sorry for their being killed by Jihadis, illustrating that "Pakistan is also a victim of terrorism?" Lies repeated often enough become the "truth", and it takes a professional liar to stay ahead of that game.
Also: there is a space in any polity for the Henry Kissingers, and a space for the Tea Parties as well. BOTH serve a purpose.
BRF falls somewhere in between these... a Tea Party more intellectually sound and analytically gifted than any FOX News Jacksonian rage-fest could be, but for all that we are amateurs.