WSJ - Magadha is rising again to claim its rightful place as a crossroads of nations....
India Journal: Is Goa killing its Golden Goose?
By Samita Sawardekar
The 2009 statistics recently released by the Tourism Ministry of India raised quite a few eyebrows. Goa was muscled out from the annual list of top 10 destinations for foreign tourists in India by Bihar. While the number of foreign tourists who visited Goa in 2009 grew by nearly 7% to 376,000, it was eclipsed by Bihar where the number grew by a whopping 22% to bring more than 423,000 foreign tourists.
The contrast is even starker when one considers that in 2001 Goa was visited by nearly 260,000 foreign tourists while Bihar barely had 85,700 foreign tourists.
While the fact that Bihar gets more foreign tourists than Goa may surprise many, the comparison with Kerala, which has a similar topography to Goa and also has identified tourism as a key industry, is more revealing. In 2001, Kerala attracted nearly 209,000 foreign visitors and now, this number has swelled to 548,000, a compounded annual growth rate in excess of 13%. Kerala’s growth is in sync with the national numbers, helping the state maintain its market share of foreign tourists at a consistent 4%.
Goa, on the other hand, has not keep pace and its market share over the past decade has dropped from 4.78% in 2001 to 2.75% in 2009.
To be sure, the former Portugese colony still is a favored destination. But tourists also are attracted by competing options to visit other states and alarmed by the growing images of crime, environmental deterioration and corruption in Goa.
So is Goa’s star waning among foreign tourists?
Goa is well positioned to be a tourist haven. The small state is blessed with a long coastline dotted with white sandy beaches, miles of placid backwaters and great swathes of emerald green rice fields bordered by gently swaying coconut trees. There are several holy temples and sacred churches, many of which are categorized as world heritage monuments. Panaji, the capital, is a charming European-style city with gardens, distinctive architecture and a lovely promenade along the Mandovi river. Best of all, Goa’s unique Indo-Portuguese culture and “sossegad” (loosely translated as laid back/live-and-let-live) approach to life is hugely appealing.
Tourism, which contributes over 13% of the state GDP, is the second largest sector after mining. It is estimated to generate 7% of the state’s employment and 7% of its tax revenues. A 10-year Tourism Master Plan was drafted in 2001 to focus on developing the economic potential of tourism and countering competition from other states and international destinations. The plan, however, was distinctly shortsighted as it ignored much of the accompanying ills of tourism and showed little vision. Further, long-term development needs of the state, including that of tourism, fell victim to local political upheavals.
The resultant disastrous impact is evident.
Indiscriminate tourism has resulted in severe environmental degradation with loss of mangroves, sand-dune erosion and tidal ingress reported across the state. It has also endangered local flora and fauna. Rapid and uncontrolled tourism concentrated on the coastal belt has also put severe pressure on land and civic infrastructure such as road, water, sewage, and garbage disposal. Large tourism projects have got preferential access to beach resources thereby reducing the area available to the local population.
Crime and corruption also hold sway over the state. A recent edition of India Today carried a cover story on how “Goa has become a fulcrum of world drug smuggling” run by the Russian mafia who blatantly operate in cahoots with politicians inside and outside the government.
The economic potential of tourism is undeniable and well documented. What Goa urgently needs is a massive clean-up operation to purge the rot across the system. It needs a long-term vision of sustainable tourism backed by ecologically and culturally sensitive policies and adequate investments in infrastructure. Most of all it needs strong political will and leadership with popular grass-root support pushing for change.
Goa’s ouster from the Top 10 is a red flag. If Goa can’t find a way to tackle the rot in its system it may well end up killing the goose that laid the golden egg.
Does Goa have a Nitish Kumar who can convert this crisis into an opportunity and turn the tide?