"Tama aseet, tamasaa goodhamagre!"
Someone mentioned this Vedic phrase in strategic forum. This reminded me of this great speech I heard longtime back. All translation errors are mine…
In this world we come across two groups of people and thought processes. The first group claims that everything exists, and the second group claims everything to be non-existent.
The group of people that proclaims that everything seen in this universe is truth are Dwaitas. There are many types of Dwaitas viz., Vishistadwaita, Bhavadwaita, Suddhadwiata, Jainism, Buddhism, Sikhism, Charwaka, Taoism, Zoroastriansim, Muhhammadism, Confuciusism, and all other religions including Hindusim (as a religion).
There are two sub-groups in this Dwaita group – Astikas and Nastikas. Buddhism, Jainism, and Charwaka are Nastika darshanas because they do not accept the existence of God. And Dwista, Vishistadwaita, Nyaya, Vaisheshika, Sankhya, Yoga, Purvamimansa are Astika darshanas because they accept the existence of God.
Naastika Darshanas say “Sarvam Sunyam (everything is non-existent)”. The very inclusion of Sarvam (everything that is known and unknon) itself defeats this thought process. How can one say what that is known is non-existent and how can one say what he doesn’t know about (unknon) is non-existent?
Aastika Darshanas say “Sarvam Satyam” (everything is existent). What in this Jagat (universe) is Satyam? Everything that exists is going thru evolution and is getting destroyed and recreated. So what is Satyam in this universe?
On the other hand, Advaita states that “God is Satyam” (God is truth). Then who is God? The answer is “Satyam, Jnanam, Anantham” (Truth, Knowledge, and Infinite). Sanatana Dharma (the knowledge aspect of Hindu religion) including Vedas, Upanishads and Puranas explain this very Advaita concept in different forms and planes of awareness.
Let us explore it further –
What exists in night? Night means darkness. In this darkness, everything that is visible in the daytime disappears. All the objects that appear to be truth in Dwaita world disappear in nighttime. This defeats the logic “Sarvam Satyam”. But you “know” (are aware) that that world is not visible. So “You” exist even when nothing (visible) exists, thus destroying the argument “Sarvam Sunyam”, because “You” are part of that Sarvam.
Let us assume you have a dream in sleep. You are aware of your dream, even if you are not aware of my dream. What do you see in the dream? Do they (the objects in your dream) exist or non-existent? How can you see non-existent objects? Can you see someone who is going to be born after 100 years? So you may not be aware of something that exists, but you can never see (aware of) something that is non-existent.
So what you see in your dream really exist? How can you explain what you see in the dreams? One can say “What you see in dreams appear to exist in the dreams”. So who/what is that “appears to be existing”?
You see rivers, mountains, forests, cities, people, animals and many other objects in your dreams. What is making all these objects appear to exist? It is your consciousness only because nothing exists other than you consciousness in your dream. It is your consciousness that is manifesting all these objects in your dream. In your dream you are aware of the object, observation, and observer separately, even though all these three (object, observation, and observer) are YOU (your consciousness). It is just that your consciousness is externalized in your dream. Once you awake from dream you are aware that all that you (observer) saw/experienced (object and observation) are not separate from you.
This brings us to the Vedic saying “Tama Aseet, Tamasaa Goodhamagre!” (Tama Aseet = Darkness existed, Tamasa Goodhamagre = In that darkness even greater darkness exists)
One can understand the darkness that exists. But what greater darkness that exists in the darkness?
Do an experiment. In the morning try to see the Sun with naked eyes. After looking at the Sun for 20-30 seconds (possible without hurting eyes), divert your gaze to your surroundings. Whatever that existed (was seen by your eyes) before disappears and your eyes see only darkness. When your eyes see a great light, in that glow everything else appears as darkness. In reality you should be able to see the visible world even more clearly in the presence of increased illumination, but that appears not to be the case. We can see this illustrations in Mahabharata. When Bhagavan Krishna showed his viswaroopa (koti surya samaprabha = radiance equivalent to 10 million suns), the audience saw great light followed by total darkness. Our eye retina can see only a certain amount of light, beyond which everything becomes darkness. This is the “tamasa goodhamagre”. That goodhamagre tamasa is Shiva. In his presence, everything else is total darkness.
How to see that “Shiva tattva”? Like discussed about as long as you are dreaming (sub-conscious state) you see everything you see in the dream separate from yourself. You are aware of the truth (that everything you see in your dream are not separate from yourself) only when you are awake from that dream. It is all same between the states of dream and awake, the same rivers, oceans, hills, problems, people, prejudices and so on. You have the same ignorance (samsara) in both dream and awake state. The mind that is perceiving things in awaken state is also the same mind that is experience things in dream state. The only difference between these states of consciousness is that only in awaken state you can gain knowledge, which doesn’t exist in the dreamy state. In awaken state you can approach a teacher and achieve knowledge (because knowledge is communicable).
Similarly when you awake from your current state of consciousness, you will realize that whatever your mind perceiving as separate items such as the four-dimensional world, your experiences and prejudices in this current state of consciousness are not different from yourself.
This is what “Mantra Pushpam” says…
Yopam puspam veda
Puspavan prajavan pasuvan bhavati
Candramava Apam puspam
Puspavan, Prajavan pasuman bhavati
Ya Evam Veda
Yopa mayatanam Veda
Ayatanam bhavati.
He who understands the flowers of water,
He becomes the possessor of flowers, children and cattle.
Moon is the flower of the water,
He who understands this fact,
He becomes the possessor of flowers, children and cattle.
He who knows the source of water,
Becomes established in himself,
…
The state of consciousness that doesn’t separate all these three (object, observation, and observer) aspect is called Shiva-sthiti. Shiva-sthiti is where the consciousness is aware of this advaita state. In Shiva-Dhyana there is no externality; as all senses (smell, touch, taste, hear, see, mind, and intellect) are internalized. In this state of consciousness nothing exists beyond that consciousness. When one is in this state, even when they see this world, it appears as a reflection of him similar to how you see (know) yourself in the mirror standing in front of it. Thus
"Uttishtata, jaagratha, prapya varan nibodhata"
(Uttishtata = Arise, Jagratha = awake, Prapya Varaan = By approaching and achieving a Guru, Nobodhata = know thyself)
This is the concept of Shiva-Raatri (Shiva's night). One is awake when the whole world sleeps. This is Jaagarana (staying awake throughout night). Here in the darkness, there is nothing to see (externally) except myself. To achieve the state of consciousness required to see the truth, one need to sharpen one’s senses. That is where Upavaasa (fasting) comes. One is fasting (internalizing by controlling) one’s senses even in a state of abundance. To achieve the Shiva’s state (Shiva = Auspicious state of consciousness) , one needs Shiva’s kindness. That is why we worship Shiva on Shiva-Raatri.
When asked “Kutasya Advaita Shiva?”
(Kutaha = How, Shivah = Shiva, Advaita = is the one God consciousness?)
Adi Shankara replied that “Nana bhootam prudhaktvam anyasya anyasmaat yatra drishtvam, tatra, Asshivam bhavet.”
(Yatra = Where, nana bhootam = all things and live beings in this world, Dristvam = are seen as, Prudhaktvam = separated, Anyasya Anasyat = from each other, tatra = There, Asshivam = non-auspiciousness, Bhavet = results).
Where everything becomes equal and one, then it becomes Shivam (auspiciousness). When everything became one, you do not exist from the system separately. Even when there are infinite (separated in space and time) waves in the ocean, how can any one wave stay separate from the ocean?
From here, I drift into civilizational aspect…
This, in my opinion, is the fundamental building block of our Indic civilization. In this system of civilization each individual lives, acts, and experiences as part of the whole system, not separate from it. That is why the Indic system doesn’t see/value the exploitation of the rest of the world (living and non-living) as a purposeful exercise. What is the purpose of exploiting one part by another one in such interdependent system?
That brings us to the concept of service. One thinking that he is helping/serving others brings back the concept of separation (nana bhootam prudhaktvam) into society. The concept of service in Indic civilization suggests one helping himself thru others.
The hand brings the food to the mouth. The mouth chews it and pushes it to the next part. The digestive system absorbs the energy/essence from the food and pushes it further. The waste processing system (Liver and Kidneys) distills the final extracts and pushes the waste out of the system. The mind oversees the entire process and enjoys the whole process with the use of various senses. Who is exploiting whom and who is serving whom in this system? This is the structure of Pursha. From this Purusha’s head came Brahmana, Vaisya, Kshatriya, and Shudra. Who can live without the others? This is the varna (interdependent) system Vedic knowledge defines and established in our Indic society. This is what Brihaspati-ji was suggesting in the strategy threads.
Only such a civilization can have this type of prayer (This should be our national prayer, IMHO)
Swasti prajabhya paripala yantam (May good happen to the whole humanity)
Nyayena margena maheem maheesah (May the rulers provide justice to everyone)
Go-Brahmanebhyah shubhamastu nityam (May the knowledgeable and non-knowledgeable "animal system" be happy)
Lokah samastah sukhino bhavantu. (May the entire world live happily)
Kale varshantu parjanyah (May the clouds give rains on a timely manner)
prithivi sashya shalini (May the earth produce abundantly)
Deshoyam kshoba rahitah (May there be no draughts in the nation)
Brahmana santu nirbhaya (May the people live without fear)
Om shanti shanti shantihi (Aum = in past, present, and future let there be peace, peace, peace)