UlanBatori wrote:So the young lady has an American passport. Can she not apply for an OCI since (a) she is a daughter of Indian origin parents
US born kids to Indian ppt holders are not eligible for OCI. Only option is PIO.
So what is she missing by waiting until 18 to decide to become a FULL Indian citjen?
well, for one, she cannot go to the college i went to, except by NRI quota and NRI fees.
matrimc,
there is really no practical soln to the problem. i am not even looking for an immediate soln to my situation. i am never one to beat myself on what cannot be changed. all i wanted was to complain and whine about this in true brf fashion in a post or two. that all. i did not think i will get all sh1tted upon by people who do not even understand the issue and keep telling what i already know, but do not spend a minute to look at it from another angle.
and theo, please don't continue saying what everybody (including me) already knows.
You are claiming that because your daughter is inconvenienced the USA should change its 200+ year old citizenship system to suit your circumstance.
what's wrong with asking for a change to "200+ year old system of massa" ? is that such a crime? hasn't anything changed in USA for 200 years. or is something not allowed to be changed because it has crossed 200 years?
what is the real argument here? those who want it can keep it. those who want choice for their children, can defer it until minor becomes adult and reclaim/renounce.
is not the US all about freedom, choice blah blah.
and it took pages and pages to at least reach a point where it is agreed that i can at least claim to be inconvenienced about this situation.
After 2004, BOTH parents MUST be legal Indian citizens at birth for the child to get citizenship. No matter where the child is born. You think this is better?
better or worse is not even a question here. context man. context. stick to it.
people should be free to choose what is eligible for them and kids (up until kids get old enough to choose for themselves).
stop telling me i can go to india to give birth. i already know that. next you will be linking expedia.com to me.