Singha wrote:thats because a lot of people like maids and labourers who got ac now are still too gullible and impressionable to come into the formal banking system.
they keep it under the bed in a tin box or worse contribute all savings every month to chit funds.
time and again I have tried to explain to our maid the benefits of having some fixed deposit, some saving a/c but she keeps on putting all her money in chit fund.
Theo_Fidel wrote:+1
Chit fund is essentially a lottery ticket right. Though you are guaranteed a minimum payback.
It is also possible a lot of accounts were just benami. IIRC there were incentives to open them so some fat cat has collected the loot and has now abandoned the accounts.
It seems to me that the Chit Funds are much less of a scam than the banks.
Chit Funds seem to work on a principle that people think banks work on.
Chit funds use the 'savings deposit' to lend money to people. The only difference is that there is no interest which is charged. So, Chit funds are better than the deposit banks which lend money.
What do chit funds do?
In chit funds, a group of people come together and pool their resources over a period of time. The ones who need it will take it while the others wait for their turn. The problem in this scheme is that those who have already used their turn may not want to fund the others. This happens once in a while and this is when the problem starts because if even a few rotten eggs do such a thing, then the whole chit fund might get into a problem specially if its a small group.
The advantage in this system is that there is no interest rates. Its a nice scheme if the state provide it legality and structure it.
However, the modern banks are a totally different beast. Thanks to fractional banking, they can simply create money out of thin air.
I think chit funds are the way forward rather than the modern day banks which are just an elaborate scam printing money out of thin air.
The govts should provide proper structure and legality to the chit funds and monitor them properly.
My CT of the day:
It seems to me that thanks to You Pee A, the desi public sector banks were on the verge of collapsing. I think what NaMo did was that he first put the temple gold as a sort of collateral to stop the banks from collapsing. Then, he started this scheme of initiating all the new accounts for the poor.
The way fractional reserve works is: it can generate money based on number of accounts. So, if the accounts increase, then the banks can start generating the money. This is the real aim of all the push for the new accounts.
The fact that the poor will come into the 'mainstream economy' is a collateral advantage. The real advantage is that the banks have been saved and a bloodbath on the streets has been avoided.