Understanding US thread-III

All threads that are locked or marked for deletion will be moved to this forum. The topics will be cleared from this archive on the 1st and 16th of each month.
Locked
A_Gupta
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13239
Joined: 23 Oct 2001 11:31
Contact:

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by A_Gupta »

KJo wrote:.. I mean lobbied to allow this hollowing of US IT industry in the name of capitalism and "free markets". Who cares about free markets if you are unemployed after all the education and experience?
Well, in the same tone "who cares about free markets if you can't afford health care?"

The answer was made clear in this elections. "Free markets" to Americans is like "Jesus" to Christians, holy thing not to be examined closely or criticized.
A_Gupta
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13239
Joined: 23 Oct 2001 11:31
Contact:

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by A_Gupta »

Trump's executive order resulted in the revoking of the visas of people who were already in the country. Is revokation equivalent to expiration? The media is not discussing this, but if these people don't leave the country within the grace period allowed after expiration, won't they be guilty of overstaying their visas? Trump's executive order is quite clear about targeting people who overstay their visas.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

amitkv wrote:This whole thread has been derailed by h1b discussion. Maybe a nukkard or h1b thread is more appropriate for this discussion.
I agree, and BTW, apologies to amitkv. I quoted you in firing off a rant, but in no way intended that your post was bad!!!! Yours was actually a sensible post, a rarity these days on these threads. :mrgreen:
OTOH, it is quite understandable that the Unmentionable Term is of prime concern to many people, and an extremely sensitive topic. It's just that things look very different from different perspectives.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

Just to understand the US understanding of the term "Free Markets".
If the US Insurance Company Fleecers-e-Suckers Inc is faced with delays and many forms to fill before starting operations in India, that is Protectionism. Disgusting. If Chettiar Labs is denied permission to sell a generic version of a $40,000 per pill US drug for $0.25 each, that is Free Market. With Rule Of The Law. Hope you are clear about this.
Gus
BRF Oldie
Posts: 8220
Joined: 07 May 2005 02:30

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Gus »

A_Gupta wrote:Trump has gamed the US income tax and bankruptcy laws. Similarly Trump has used the services of innumerable small businesses and then not paid them, and held them at bay with his formidable legal team. Trump University was a fraud.

Indian IT companies have legally gamed the H1-B system, and so may have some of the workers.

The varied reactions to these two sets of facts is fascinating to observe.
'selective listening' is a term used to describe this...people only hear what they want to hear and simply ignore all else or explain it away as 'oh that's just stuff he says to get to power, he will only do what I think he will do or what I want him to do'
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

Look at what has been happening. Trump et al are either settling or buckling in court if faced with tough legal opposition. First the TRump U, then the Golf Club... Wonder what happens when WTO starts slamming the US.
Gus
BRF Oldie
Posts: 8220
Joined: 07 May 2005 02:30

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Gus »

http://www.fox4news.com/news/u-s-world/233112569-story
ICE agents will be enforcing laws put in place during the George W. Bush administration and changed in the Obama administration that will allow them to identify and remove people here legally who are convicted of a certain group of crimes and people here illegally and in police custody for any reason

People in the U.S. legally with a green card, but have a conviction of certain offenses -- domestic violence, unlawful carrying of a weapon, multiple thefts, possession of a controlled substance – will be placed in deportation proceedings.
Gus
BRF Oldie
Posts: 8220
Joined: 07 May 2005 02:30

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Gus »

http://talkingpointsmemo.com/livewire/h ... rder-chaos
A government attorney disclosed during a Friday hearing in federal court in Virginia that 100,000 visas have been revoked in the chaos generated by President Donald Trump signing an executive order on immigration last week.

The State Department told the Associated Press, however, that the actual number of revoked visas is less than 60,000 and that the number given out in court Friday likely included exempt visa holders like "diplomatic and other visas that were actually exempted by the travel ban."

In a statement to TPM, State Department Bureau of Consular Affairs spokesman William Cocks said the number of revoked visas was less than 60,000.

"Fewer than 60,000 individuals’ visas were provisionally revoked to comply with the Executive Order," Cocks said in the statement. "We recognize that those individuals are temporarily inconvenienced while we conduct our review under the Executive Order. To put that number in context, we issued over 11 million immigrant and non-immigrant visas in fiscal year 2015. As always, national security is our top priority when issuing visas."

The Washington Post first reported that in court Friday morning, a the government's lawyer explained that 100,000 visas had been revoted, but it was unclear how many of those visa holders had been returned to their home countries. Now, the number itself appears to be in question.

The court case in Virginia centers around two Yemeni men who landed Saturday at Dulles Airport and were returned to Ethiopia. They were detained coming to the United States to be with their father, who is a U.S. citizen in Michigan, and were then "coerced into renouncing their claims to legal permanent residence in the United States," according to the Post.
NRao
BRF Oldie
Posts: 19326
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Illini Nation

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by NRao »

Tee Mama has reversed himself on Israel, Russia (return Crimea!!!!) and Japan/South Korea.

And, under the this-is-what-I-think, but he-is-the-expert guise, he has outsourced his policies.

Meanwhile, pontificating on other's rating, while his own sinks!

His wall is crumbling. Why would it not? $12-15 billion weighs a lot.

But his base (pun intended) is solid.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

There u go! Bomb Eyeran!
http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/03/sport/ira ... index.html
The US wrestling team won't be able to compete in this month's Freestyle World Cup in Iran because visas were denied to its members,
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

As I understand the US political leadership at present, the main difference between the Democrats and the Republicans is that the former don't talk to the POTUS while the latter are yelling at/contradicting him. :rotfl:
Melwyn

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Melwyn »

I always had a suspicion that Trump was not 100% comfortable about running for President. Or that he was in it for the publicity.
It seems to be the case of "be careful what you ask for"!

Trump's long time friend Howard Stern says the same thing and it does not sound too good.

http://money.cnn.com/2017/02/02/media/k ... -on-trump/

"I personally wish that he had never run, I told him that, because I actually think this is something that is gonna be detrimental to his mental health too, because, he wants to be liked, he wants to be loved," Stern said. "He wants people to cheer for him."
"I don't think it's going to be a healthy experience. And by the way, he's now on this anti-Hollywood kick. He loves Hollywood. First of all, he loves the press. He lives for it. He loves people in Hollywood. He only wants hobnob with them. All of this hatred and stuff directed towards him. It's not good for him. It's not good. There's a reason every president who leaves the office has grey hair."

"I remember saying to him when he announced his presidency, I remember being quite amazed, because I remember him being for Hillary Clinton," Stern added.

"And I remember him being very--I mean he was pro-abortion. So the new Donald Trump kind of surprised me."
Stern said he doesn't believe Trump has had a change of heart on issues like abortion, but is instead playing to his base.

The radio host said he also believed Trump ran for president solely to get a larger contract from NBC for "The Apprentice."
"I think it started out as like a kinda cool, fun thing to do in order to get a couple more bucks out of NBC for The Apprentice, I actually do believe that," Stern said.

"He just wanted a couple more bucks out of NBC, and that is why Donald is calling for voter fraud investigations. He's pissed he won. He still wants Hillary Clinton to win. He's so f—ing pissed, he's hoping that he can find some voter fraud and hand it over to Hillary."
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

He's pissed he won. He still wants Hillary Clinton to win. He's so f—ing pissed, he's hoping that he can find some voter fraud and hand it over to Hillary."
This Stern is a class A jerk himself, hain? I think Trump may not mind handing over to Bernie Sanders after he does what he set out to do, which is to sign 100 Executive Orders in a month. One day he will look in the mirror and imagine having to kiss snot-nosed babies instead of P.B.'s for the next 3.9 years and that is going to send him over the edge. Probably will sign an Exec Order closing the WHOTUS and moving to Atlantic City.
hanumadu
BRF Oldie
Posts: 5353
Joined: 11 Nov 2002 12:31

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by hanumadu »

UlanBatori wrote:
He's pissed he won. He still wants Hillary Clinton to win. He's so f—ing pissed, he's hoping that he can find some voter fraud and hand it over to Hillary."
This Stern is a class A jerk himself, hain?
And that Trump is his good friend shows what a jerk Trump himself is.
And that Trump still got elected shows how badly the democrats effed up. All Hillary had to do was make some soothing noises against Islamic terrorism, jobs and big corporations for the fence sitters. I still don't understand why they were so stubborn and just dug in.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

My evil 6th coujin and family would have at least abstained... not that it made any difference in Dera KKK Khan where DT was winning by 80-20. But I know what you mean. My take has always been that the donkeys and elephants are both as crooked as they come, but the elephants are more effective thieves, the donkeys just bray pompous and leave a mess.
hanumadu
BRF Oldie
Posts: 5353
Joined: 11 Nov 2002 12:31

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by hanumadu »

I could not make up my mind if I wanted elephants or donkeys to win and I still cannot. I did not have too much concern that Hillary would have resulted in more IT (the kind pakistan speciallizes in). How much more could she have added to it? Nor was I concerned leftists in India would get a shot in the arm. Modi looks like he is in control and more and more people were getting tired of the sickular liberals. We needed more of it (just like pakistan needs more Islam) before people were thoroughly disgusted.

DT was a wild card, no saying how he will turn out to be. Probably just fun and nothing much more.

One thing for sure is I did not have much hope on either.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

Keep fingers crossed or whatever through midnight CST. 80,000+ evil Great Satanites congregating in one nice confined space. They HAVE banned all aircraft flight including drones, and grounded one who tried flying over the practice field. Declared a No Drone Zone. But have they declared it a No Truck Zone? Stay out of the city is my advice.

Good thing it is not in Rooskystan.
devesh
BRF Oldie
Posts: 5129
Joined: 17 Feb 2011 03:27

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by devesh »

UlanBatori wrote:Keep fingers crossed or whatever through midnight CST. 80,000+ evil Great Satanites congregating in one nice confined space. They HAVE banned all aircraft flight including drones, and grounded one who tried flying over the practice field. Declared a No Drone Zone. But have they declared it a No Truck Zone? Stay out of the city is my advice.

Good thing it is not in Rooskystan.
where?
GShankar
BRFite
Posts: 974
Joined: 16 Sep 2016 20:20

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by GShankar »

You talkin 'bout SB LI?
A_Gupta
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13239
Joined: 23 Oct 2001 11:31
Contact:

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by A_Gupta »

Rural areas in Georgia are going to be even shorter of physicians than they are now, because Americans don't want to work as primary care physicians in rural areas; and most of the physicians are immigrants; and of these, a significant percentage are from the Trump-banned countries. These rural areas are, of course, strongly pro-Trump.

http://www.wnyc.org/story/immigrant-doc ... ation-ban/
Kakkaji
BRF Oldie
Posts: 3893
Joined: 23 Oct 2002 11:31

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Kakkaji »

A_Gupta wrote:Rural areas in Georgia are going to be even shorter of physicians than they are now, because Americans don't want to work as primary care physicians in rural areas; and most of the physicians are immigrants; and of these, a significant percentage are from the Trump-banned countries. These rural areas are, of course, strongly pro-Trump.

http://www.wnyc.org/story/immigrant-doc ... ation-ban/
Scare-mongering.

Doctors from India alone can fill all the vacancies caused by the ban on these 7 countries.

It is the same line that was taken by Angela Merkel - that she wanted to let in the refugees from Middle East and North Africa or else there will not be enough labour to fill the jobs in Germany. Heck, she can fill all those jobs if she allows in immigrants from India - and they will not be driving trucks in crowds either.
Dipanker
BRF Oldie
Posts: 3021
Joined: 14 May 2002 11:31

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Dipanker »

Perceived allies and enemies of America by Americans. Allies are on predictable line, the Europeans and the AUS and NZ.

Which Country Is America’s Strongest Ally? For Republicans, It’s Australia


The democrats view India slightly more favorably than Republicans.
Yagnasri
BRF Oldie
Posts: 10532
Joined: 29 May 2007 18:03

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Yagnasri »

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world ... 62346.html

The same problem everywhere. Even in India there are serious problems with merchant bankers etc looking for commission and not for protection of the lenders.
darshan
BRF Oldie
Posts: 4018
Joined: 28 Jan 2008 04:16

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by darshan »

A_Gupta wrote:Rural areas in Georgia are going to be even shorter of physicians than they are now, because Americans don't want to work as primary care physicians in rural areas; and most of the physicians are immigrants; and of these, a significant percentage are from the Trump-banned countries. These rural areas are, of course, strongly pro-Trump.

http://www.wnyc.org/story/immigrant-doc ... ation-ban/
Good riddance if true. In many of these states, from AZ to FL, pakis and BDs have taken over these areas from state prisons to native american territories. Singha had earlier posted a link about opoid issues and these rural facilities combined with similar community running pharmacy joints are huge part of it. Like Kakkaji said, that India may become a benefactor of this if these pakis et al are sent home packing.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

Federal Judge in Washington State issues nationwide restraining order against TrumBanzee. Bill Gates' Attorney General calls Administration "Keystone Cops".

Finally some Americans are stepping forward to support their Constitution. IMO what this is showing is the utter, total spinelessness and oiseuleness in DupleeCity. None of those DHS oiseules had the spine to say, hey, you can't do this. It's unconstitutional. So I have to agree with the Zee that the DC swamp needs to be drained. But I wish they would use a sewage pump and and big pipes, not an orange-toupeed hippo splashing around in the mud.
Singha
BRF Oldie
Posts: 66589
Joined: 13 Aug 2004 19:42
Location: the grasshopper lies heavy

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Singha »

Donald J. Trump ‏@realDonaldTrump
Countries charge U.S. companies taxes or tariffs while the U.S. charges them nothing or little.We should charge them SAME as they charge us!


5,276

26.1K

Donald J. Trump
5h
Donald J. Trump ‏@realDonaldTrump
We must keep "evil" out of our country!
A_Gupta
BRF Oldie
Posts: 13239
Joined: 23 Oct 2001 11:31
Contact:

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by A_Gupta »

Kakkaji wrote:
A_Gupta wrote:Rural areas in Georgia are going to be even shorter of physicians than they are now, because Americans don't want to work as primary care physicians in rural areas; and most of the physicians are immigrants; and of these, a significant percentage are from the Trump-banned countries. These rural areas are, of course, strongly pro-Trump.

http://www.wnyc.org/story/immigrant-doc ... ation-ban/
Scare-mongering.

Doctors from India alone can fill all the vacancies caused by the ban on these 7 countries.

It is the same line that was taken by Angela Merkel - that she wanted to let in the refugees from Middle East and North Africa or else there will not be enough labour to fill the jobs in Germany. Heck, she can fill all those jobs if she allows in immigrants from India - and they will not be driving trucks in crowds either.
This year's matching process of residencies is already in disarray. Do listen to the broadcast.
Yagnasri
BRF Oldie
Posts: 10532
Joined: 29 May 2007 18:03

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by Yagnasri »

If rural Khanland needs doctors, I am sure they can get suitable people from say Poland. Even our fellows will jump at the opportunity to have a Greencard and fat dowry.
habal
BRF Oldie
Posts: 6922
Joined: 24 Dec 2009 18:46

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by habal »

Kakkaji wrote:
A_Gupta wrote:Rural areas in Georgia are going to be even shorter of physicians than they are now, because Americans don't want to work as primary care physicians in rural areas; and most of the physicians are immigrants; and of these, a significant percentage are from the Trump-banned countries. These rural areas are, of course, strongly pro-Trump.

http://www.wnyc.org/story/immigrant-doc ... ation-ban/
Scare-mongering.

Doctors from India alone can fill all the vacancies caused by the ban on these 7 countries.

doctors from India are never found in India.
esp certain specialities. viz gastro surgeon, ENT, ortho are very rare.

but they can be found aplenty in US & UK where they are not wanted.

scumbags. highest. order.
NRao
BRF Oldie
Posts: 19326
Joined: 01 Jan 1970 05:30
Location: Illini Nation

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by NRao »

rohitvats
BR Mainsite Crew
Posts: 7826
Joined: 08 Sep 2005 18:24
Location: Jatland

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by rohitvats »

The sanctimonious BS about Indian IT companies gaming H1B is hilarious. American or European companies doing it would have by now become case studies of 'Competitive Strategies' on some fancy business college. US companies do everything to screw competition and game the business environment - just look at their shenanigans in their contract with MOD.

All this whining is because some seem to have been at the receiving end of this US implemented system - which benefits US companies and it's shareholders. What Indian companies make is their part of legitimate contract.

It's basically 'I, me and Myself'. Which is alright unless you shroud it under sophisticated BS about competence and ethics.

H1B was implemented by USA for its own interest and benefit; SDRE simply saw a business opportunity and took it. I'm sure there are cases of substandard work and people in this business. But had they been a norm, Indian IT companies would've been wiped out by now. Fact that they continue to do relatively OK means bad work and bad people are exception, rather than norm.

If USA now modified the system, it will again be to benefit USA and Americans. Which includes PIO who've opted for US Passport. Again, nothing wrong in it. I've quite a few batchmates who've gone for green card; kids were born in US and citizenship should be some years away.

But please, let's not have the holier than thou sermons on Indians deserving H1B visa restriction for bad work they do. It's about YOUR job prospects and how H1B restrictions give YOU better opportunities as American citizens.
LokeshC
BRFite
Posts: 697
Joined: 15 Aug 2016 04:36

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by LokeshC »

^^^^ + 100000001.

Thank you for expressing what I felt like, but could not really find the words.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

^^^^^^ -175,3457,321.

Not to interrupt the hate-fest, but I think the point about sdre companies "gaming" etc was not sanctimonious re: US interests, but the fact that they chose to sit back and get fat (sfdre?) on the low-hanging fruit rather than scramble up the food chain and to higher levels in the floodplain. Otherwise we would be yadayada about Trumpanzee banning those evil yindoo-named ChandraGupta Enterprise Systems and Asoka Operating Systems and entire AI-based corporate structures from India, threatening the struggling (look at US automobile quality and MS Windows 10 quality) and Apple to be put of bijnej. That would be a straight WTO protectionism issue and India would rule there too as on the modern ICC (pre-Supreme Court).

Back in the 1970s the Computer Science Department didn't even exist in most universities - let alone Information Technology or (whatever) Science. But there were people studying Computer Science in Math and EE depts. They used to stay at the research leading edge, and post the latest papers they could find on this exotic thing called a Trans -sister, which the rest of us thought was what Sanjay Gaundi gave to those who followed the Kabir - Tree Doha D1cktum. Able to receive AIR/AkashVani in all the newfound spare time since there was nothing else to do most of the night. (Incidentally the Nobel-Prize winner associated with stealing that invention was Shockley, who would have fit right in the US administration: his best-known writing are those that "prove" his theories on the racial inferiority and genetic incapability to do mathematical reasoning, of the non-pinkassed.

This field slowly attracted the brightest and the best: you could spend your days relaxing in an AIRCONDITIONED Computer Center instead of sweating in the smithy or foundry like real engineers. Lots of wimmens went into the field... A few guys at IISc mortgaged their homes (more to the point, spent their dowry) setting up companies and offering the proposition that software, being mostly math and requiring little hardware facilities, was suited to development in India. So they could offer a worldwide service. They set up a Consultancy Service to solve problems for customers far away, sending programs via shakly telephone modems, whatever. They were simply ahead of the rest of the world.

That was over 45 years ago. Are Indian "EyeTee companies" today world leaders in anything other than "body-shopping", putting people in a rat-race of cost-cutting, a race to the bottom?

Instead of being reigning champions in AI and computational technology, Indians are dhoti-shivering about every letter in the visa rules tweaked by some semi-literate used-car salesgirl in the COTUS. The Big Bijnejjes run "e-FFLUENT" or COMSOL or MATLAB or big Finite Element codes and other garbage imported from Yoo Ess or Yoo Kay or Hitlerstan at huge cost instead of developing the codes in India. Because Indian companies are too lazy to invest in developing their own and beating the world with those. So much easier to body-shop someone to do the grunt work at those companies, and sit back and collect the money saved by cheating them out of a decent world-class wage for wold-class work.

Even in Indian so-called "Invention Incubators" one finds that the "products" that their review teams approve to go forward, are those that imitate western middle-class consumer preferences, rather than those suited for India. The "competitive edge" cited by most Indian companies is that Indians work cheap and the Indian rupee keeps falling. Period. But.. that idea of Indian companies taking the initiative in developing concepts suited first for India, then the world, would be too deep for some of our dear postors.

One small exception: see DC microgrid work of Prof. Jhunjhunwala & team in IITM. Now winning worldwide acclaim, and acknowledged leaders in that field. Because their focus started with understanding the problems in India.
durvasa
BRFite
Posts: 171
Joined: 11 Dec 2000 12:31

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by durvasa »

Agree with Rohitvats. Last seen India per capita GDP (nominal) is somewhere between Kenya and poorest sector of Betelgeuse, about 30x less than US and most developed nations. And a major reason for this we lack in skilled people. THis 'body-shopping' and eyetee-ytee jobs that are mocked by many supposedly evolved "coolies' now living in Massaland is a major jump on what Indian 2nd, even top-tiered engineers did earlier in India.

Even if these call-centre/bodyshopping pay Rs 2-3 lakh/year locally or just 40K in the US, taking jobs of oh-so-smart yanks;for Indian economy that's a major value addition even if not needing much smarts. I don't like the term, but it seems that many among us consider these jobs as new-age shudras that we won't do and won't respect anyone doing this.

We need more of these IT-shudra jobs and we need to use every loophole, every legal or illegal trick in the trade to get them. India should be call-centre, support-centre of the world. What's happening in the USA, if we strip highfalutin words, is older immigrants (Europeans or Indians) trying to stop new ones from sharing their loot. Nothing new in that and I don't grudge them. Every squatter has done the same in history.

Learn from China or Japan or Korea, when they were ridiculed for decades for their poor products but they kept chugging. We need to get 30mn otherwise jobless or unemployable Indians in basic IT services jobs. Then we may get .oo1% of them to create something new and inspire others. Indian govt has to use its influence (however puny) to focus DT on mfg jobs stolen by China/Mexico than on IT services,

Though I never worked in these companies, Infosys, Wipro, TCS are doing yeoman service to India by giving jobs to millions. Half the Indians working in tech who are US citizens, some now pontificating to natives, have reached there by holding their coattails. It's not Infosys mandate to create IPs and build Google/FB/MS. It's in services business like BMTC or Bescom or Chenai sanitation board. Others like us should take ownership to create IP. I have respect for these companies for bringing $100bn+ to India, every year and jobs to millions.

India startup scene is hotting up through they are still mostly into clones. But things are changing. I cofounded one and got decent funding to hire a strong tech team. Many others are doing much better.

Anyway, back to Read-only mode.
Last edited by durvasa on 04 Feb 2017 18:15, edited 1 time in total.
ldev
BRF Oldie
Posts: 2614
Joined: 06 Nov 2002 12:31

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by ldev »

UlanBatori wrote: Because Indian companies are too lazy to invest in developing their own and beating the world with those. So much easier to body-shop someone to do the grunt work at those companies, and sit back and collect the money saved by cheating them out of a decent world-class wage for wold-class work.
So very true. And so sad that encouraging the deployment of Indian workers overseas seems to have become a central plank even in Indian think tanks and in fact even with GOI. Of course it is no surprise that it is a priority for the Indian body shopping industry!!

India in 10 years: Relearning navigation in foreign waters
Flowing from these, we can identify three major priorities for Indian foreign policy. For starters, India can no longer presume to benefit automatically from globalization. Our trade policy will have to be a lot more nimble in the years ahead to face the challenge of slowing globalization and related developments like China’s Belt and Road Initiative (an international transport network that aims to connect the continents of Asia, Africa and Europe). We would also need to focus on building our domestic markets and integrating the rest of South Asia with it. And we have to ensure the international mobility of our skilled workers.
Hey, how about ensuring that Indian per capita income surpasses China in the next 10 years. Because that will ensure that all Indians, especially those living in India benefit from a higher wage. And will ensure that skilled workers will stay in India to contribute their skills without sacrificing anything in terms of income. Or that is not a priority because then what will happen to the wage arbitrage which is the basis for the business model for the Indian IT industry.

Shocking that the India-UK free trade accord foundered because one of the sticking points was mobility of Indian labour. :shock:
Is this an acknowledgement that India does not have the ability to absorb it's own labour? Rather than trying to push this labour offshore, how about doing something to increase employment and increase income at the same time within India?

Historically finance, IT etc are support functions. If core industries which require IT support and will provide the bulk of employment to Indians are not developing fast enough IT itself becomes superflous at least within India. The answer is to develop those basic manufacturing industries in India to absorb labour and so that the domestic IT industry can provide that domestic support rather than body shopping to the US etc.
UlanBatori
BRF Oldie
Posts: 14045
Joined: 11 Aug 2016 06:14

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by UlanBatori »

This is it. TSJi, what has this Great Nation come to? :(( :((
President Donald Trump will not head to Milwaukee for a previously scheduled visit of a Harley-Davidson factory after the company decided it wasn't comfortable :(( hosting him amid planned protests, an administration official said Tuesday.
Trump had been scheduled to tour the factory Thursday where he also planned to sign executive orders related to American manufacturing.
What next? COLT Peacemaker factory refuses to fly Old Glory? Beef Jerky + Spitting Tobaccer/Chewing Gum Factory bans baseball caps, red pickups and checked flannel Logger shirts and requires long skirts and high heels instead?

Who the heck expects to be COMFORTABLE on a HARLEY-DAVIDSON? Do they now require all employees to ride tricycles to work I wonder.

it's one thing for Wharton to cancel e-visit of phoren leader, but quite another for Harley-Davidson to cancel visit of POTUS out of fear of the Liberal Commie Pinkos. The whole Board needs to go. Can't the Zee sign another Executive Order expelling them to Somalia?
rohitvats
BR Mainsite Crew
Posts: 7826
Joined: 08 Sep 2005 18:24
Location: Jatland

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by rohitvats »

UlanBatori wrote: Not to interrupt the hate-fest, but I think the point about sdre companies "gaming" etc was not sanctimonious re: US interests, but the fact that they chose to sit back and get fat (sfdre?) on the low-hanging fruit rather than scramble up the food chain and to higher levels in the floodplain. <SNIP>
Ulanbatori - You're conflating two different issues.

One is about the lack of innovation by Indian IT/ITES companies and not doing anything to rise-up the value chain. That is a business call and your mango SDRE H1B visa holder working in US is not exactly responsible for it. I can understand the lament about IT/ITES sector in general and missed opportunities due to myopic business calls. But can't fathom the logic somersault to somehow pin that to the chest of IT/ITES 'Coolie' working in India or USA.

Second is the 'LOOOOOVVVEEEE' that some PIO with American citizenship on this forum tend to show for these mango 'Coolies' working in USA on H1B visa. That has and had nothing to do with lack of innovation by Indian IT/ITES companies; it was pure and simple whine-fest about these cyber Coolies disrupting their big American dream. The hate-fest is there.

For them, restriction on H1B visa might mean better pay and more opportunities. Be that as it may, people at least should've guts to spell it out as it is. And not couch it in some BS about how Indians had it coming because they aren't good enough. And how each of them 'Gundaswamy' and 'Keshavraju' are worthless pile of sh1t.

As I said earlier, it is perfectly all right to look out for yourself. After all, it is you who has to put bread on the table. But don't belittle others when you do that.
pravula
BRFite
Posts: 577
Joined: 07 Aug 2009 05:01

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by pravula »

Trump blasts 'so-called' federal judge's block of travel ban

The opinion of this so-called judge, which essentially takes law-enforcement away from our country, is ridiculous and will be overturned!
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) February 4, 2017
KJo
BRF Oldie
Posts: 9926
Joined: 05 Oct 2010 02:54

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by KJo »

rohitvats wrote:
UlanBatori wrote: Not to interrupt the hate-fest, but I think the point about sdre companies "gaming" etc was not sanctimonious re: US interests, but the fact that they chose to sit back and get fat (sfdre?) on the low-hanging fruit rather than scramble up the food chain and to higher levels in the floodplain. <SNIP>
Ulanbatori - You're conflating two different issues.

One is about the lack of innovation by Indian IT/ITES companies and not doing anything to rise-up the value chain. That is a business call and your mango SDRE H1B visa holder working in US is not exactly responsible for it. I can understand the lament about IT/ITES sector in general and missed opportunities due to myopic business calls. But can't fathom the logic somersault to somehow pin that to the chest of IT/ITES 'Coolie' working in India or USA.

Second is the 'LOOOOOVVVEEEE' that some PIO with American citizenship on this forum tend to show for these mango 'Coolies' working in USA on H1B visa. That has and had nothing to do with lack of innovation by Indian IT/ITES companies; it was pure and simple whine-fest about these cyber Coolies disrupting their big American dream. The hate-fest is there.

For them, restriction on H1B visa might mean better pay and more opportunities. Be that as it may, people at least should've guts to spell it out as it is. And not couch it in some BS about how Indians had it coming because they aren't good enough. And how each of them 'Gundaswamy' and 'Keshavraju' are worthless pile of sh1t.

As I said earlier, it is perfectly all right to look out for yourself. After all, it is you who has to put bread on the table. But don't belittle others when you do that.
rohit, it you are talking about me, come out and say it. Why hide behind calling me "people"? :mrgreen:
What Ulan Batori says is correct to the power of Googolplex.

Yes, overuse of H1B has ruined the IT market in the US and it is being turned into a commodity space except in the Bay Area. Now everyone cannot live in the Bay area. Yes, many Indians are not good enough. If you went to Rural College of Engineering, Hulkoti for Automobile Engineering and had no aptitude for IT and just got dragged in because they were hiring everybody in class and the money was good, then there is very little chance this person can be good. The moment things get rocky, their chuddis come off. Like Rohit Sharma in kirket. These are the Gundaswamys and Keshavrajus who have ruined the image of Indians as mediocre because of their lack of professionalism and incompetence. Like that TCS fellow who held me hostage at 1am :(( ing he had no experience being WebSphere admin (though he was placed there as Admin) and wanted me to help him out by telling him to click. He should have mailed me his salary too. Before installs, he and his gang wanted us to give them detailed information with screenshots on "where all to click" :rotfl: . I think he was a Saravanan from TCS Chennai office.

And yes, we are all looking for ourselves. Aren't you too? You are looking for yourself by wanting to flood the US with H1Bs and making undeserved money. I am looking out for myself by wanting only those selected ones to be allowed to come to the US and the rest stay back and do whatever else the want to do so that the IT market in the US is robust and vibrant. Many folks in India and even on this forum think an IT job is an entitlement they deserve.
kiranA
BRFite
Posts: 375
Joined: 25 Dec 2016 09:37

Re: Understanding US thread-III

Post by kiranA »

1) The fraud/abuse in h1b is next to zero. it is one industry where even the smallest player rigorously follows the most arduous regulation set to discourage as much as follows the industry.
2) Its disgusting to judge other peoples work if you are not a customer or their employer. And stereotyping few peoples work to entire group is unfit anywhere. but rather surprising such vicious negative stereotypes against Indians in this forum.
3) h1b is non-immigration visa. its a trade issue - its the ability of indians to travel and ply their trade where there is demand for trade. India has everyright to complain about restriction on h1b. It cant complain about immigrant visas like green card because thats perogative of USA.
4) USA can easily eliminate demographic "threat" by removing dual intent from h1b and making it only non-immigrant. but that means uncle sam cant take social security and medicare cut from wages of h1b.
5) USA is a country where even illegal immigrant unskilled labor is celebrated . Ever heard of ceasar chavez ? there is not a single big city in USA which did not name a street on his name. Here the best of Indian youth gave their prime years to work on mission critical projects of american corporate behemoths. Why is this forum of all the places so keen to run them down ?
Locked