A_Gupta wrote:Can the women of Pakistan have a significant effect on its evolution? E.g., Pakislam weighs down on women, will they take it forever?
Here is what I believe about this. If you look at "family size" distribution over large parts of Pakistan you find that each woman is probably having about 6 children (family size 8 ). A woman with 6 children is typically weighed down from age 16 to 40 just looking after children and fending for the family. For a wealthy woman who has everything, including home help - six children may be tolerable. But if you must live in grinding poverty - then the woman can't be a shining example of a happy citizen.
Oh for sure she will not blame Islam. The idea that Islam has something to do with this is certain - in the sense that the Islamic republic of Pakistan does not encourage birth control. Actually even knowledge of the rhythm method is useful birth control - but that knowledge is likely to be unavailable to these women. But she is unlikely to blame Islam for her suffering. Being unexposed to any experience outside her narrow life - she might curse, but accept her fate.
For the same reason. given the choice between food, shelter, fuel and war with India, the woman is likely to choose the former because troublesome kafirs are nowhere to be seen, but hunger and poverty is visible. But she has no such choice and that is why she is good for jihadi organizations. She can "give away" a son for jihad (one less mouth to feed) That still leaves her with five kids - assume three girls and two boys. The three girls will go on to lead lives like mummy. It is what those two boys do that will be of interest to us. I am certain that Pakistan does no have the support system to take every young man to fight jihad. Many just fall through the holes in the system but find themselves alive and with nothing to do. Many will take to crime. In fact if we go back to Kasab's story - the guy just wanted a gun to commit robbery before he was recruited.
Pakistan's social system keeps this mass of people in debt and in check. With the police and army being both brutal and corrupt - young men who fight the system will be beaten into submission, or perhaps just killed. This has worked fine for Pakistan up until now. Correction - I believe the problems in the system are beginning to show. At a population level of 165 million Pakistan seems to be in serious crisis. The Pakistani army - the nominal "leader" of Pakistan is unable to keep all 165 million in tight control the way it was possible perhaps 10 or 20 years ago. Even with all that Islam, many are opposed to the army and are joining together with various sub armies to fight each other and fight the Pakistani army. Perhaps that is why Hamid Gul fondly hoped for an Indian attack after 26/11 - saying that Baitullah Mehsud and Hakimullah etc would all join forces with the Pakistani army to fight India. Those two potential Paki patriots are dead now - less than one and a half years later. The video interview is still there though
So clearly there is some turmoil in Pakistan which is not being openly admitted by the ruling elite. The longer they deny it the better. Pakistan's population must climb to well over 200 million for us to see more social strife. The unemployed, uneducated, unemployable sons of Pakistan's women may join jihad - for a salary. Those who do not get that salary and those whom the system cannot absorb are going to fight with whoever is nearby. And let the Pakistan army and Paki police be nearby. An intact Pakistan is in India's interests. No?