Arjun wrote:Muppalla wrote:Again the US is successful by this leak to call out Pranab Da is not their favorable leader. Among the so called "heavyweights", the name of Pranab Da is appearing but not others. What that means is so far - They don't want anyone other than MMS as PM including the yuvaraj. So they sent a message to their viceroys in India that do not change the PM and we like MMS the darling.
So which other name should have appeared out there? Is it PC, or Antony? And by not mentioning them does it imply that the US is supporting them? A little bit of CT is harmless, but when we have multiple posters taking off from your conclusions, we need to be sure that what you are concluding has no alternative simpler explanations.
That is my read from the wiki leaks. Everyone is presenting their minds. My take is very simple and I never ask anyone to follow mine. I read all that presented by others. I don't see any CT as far as wikileaks and my thoughts are concerned.
Anything that you did not get a confirmation via press conference by Mrs.Clinton or Mr.MMS doesn't mean they are CTs. Deductions and analysis from news and event cannot be called as CTs.
Here is my take again.
(1) Wikileaks are not some real leaks. They are deliberate and selective.
(2) From a global persepective US is attempting to show that they are not anti-Islam (particularly showing pro-Sunni) in spite of their drone attacks and smoking out al-keeda
(3) In pusuit of (2) above, they have leaked stuff where some arab countires asking even Israel to attack Iran. Saudhi Arabia's prince directly requested US to takeout Nukes of Iran.
(4) Continuing same line of pro-sunni, they go to the extent of telling to Paki audience, yes we understand the problem of Kashmir and we are sympathetic to your point of view. They go to the length of leaking tourturing JK civilians.
(5) Further to that they go to the lenght of leaking how they are working with India's charming leaders like Rahul Gandhi who actually in agreement that LeT is not the real threat but it was Hindus.
That is the essential message that they sent to globe in the name of leaks. The leaks are coming one at a time and not all 250,000 at one place. They may keep coming for the rest of our lives and they may based on the required context onlee.
From purely Indo-US point of view also I see:
(1) They think that Indo-US Nuke deal is served on a plate by MMS inspite of all the constraints. Hence they see a friend in MMS and they just don't want a change. Especially they do not want Pranab Da and his left oriented anti-US drivel. They made it clear.
(2) They don't even want the Yuvraaj as his extreme pro-Mullah apeasement puts him to anti-US club.
From the sequence of the leaks that is really apparent and where is CT? If you go by record of US state department, these are real leaks done and they sorry. If you think they are right then that is your take. I don't buy that.