first picture is a twin seat trainer (LT-5208) and the second is a single seat fighter (LA-5041)
https://x.com/AdithyaKM_/status/1967930242800173474 --->
Saar, I posted this in the Naval Aviation thread, but posting here. Minor quibbles like supply chain issues and massive cost increases, should not affect the world's largest MIC
is the issue with mid course guidance? Any experts in here could shed more light on the issue from the details available?
With Due respect seeing Su-30 with J-10C sticker, I think it has the best range in subcontinent, the PL-15 seems to be easily jammed and the AIm-120C-5 seems to have lesser range. Astra MK-2 in numbers will be very useful along with Uttam/ Viprukshaka while Astra Mk3 is getting developed, it is always the Ist gen which takes the longest time, now we make the AESA seekers it is much better.Prem Kumar wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 00:08 Astra-1 is the longest range AAM with the IAF today. Let that sink in!
AdityajiAditya_V wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 11:15further on the Night of 9 May to 10 May Morning- PAF did not show up Firing Amraams/ PL-15 while their airbases were being hammered- something went very wrong for the PAF on 6-7 May night.Prem Kumar wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 00:08 Astra-1 is the longest range AAM with the IAF today. Let that sink in!
Which makes one wonder - do they even have any Astra-1's available for the Tejas Mk1A squadrons even if integration is successfully completed? With ~500 missiles ordered (and most not yet delivered), that won't even be enough to put a pair on each of our Su-30MKIs, let alone any leftovers for the Tejas squadrons. In between, we still don't know whether the MiG-29Ks will also be equipped with them.Prem Kumar wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 00:08 Which is why the anemic order for Astra-1 by the IAF is grating! So is the sloth of HAL to get the Astra-1 certification for Tejas
The Chinese operate 600+ J-10s even J-8, JH-7 after the arrival of F-22 and F-35s. Creating a Chinese Air Force equivalent in terms of stealth aircraft require patience and whole heartedly investing in indigenous capability. It's not just the money but the mindset that matters. The shortcut of imports will take us nowhere.Rakesh wrote: ↑19 Sep 2025 17:38 https://x.com/VishnuNDTV/status/1968944415826723183 ---> TEJAS MK1A - THE INSIDE STORY
• Is the Tejas still relevant in the face of Chinese 6th gen threats?
• Will we see the Tejas armed with the Meteor air to air missile?
• The HAL Dhruv crashes in the Navy and Coast Guard - who is responsible - HAL or Coast Guard and Navy?
Integrating every missile in inventory is excellent. But it must not be at the cost of delaying Astra MK2 and Mk3 for import substitute. Priority and first integration should be Astra MK2 and Mk3 followed by Meteor. Since he is mentioning it to be on the second batch of 97, there is ample time to get everything done. Also until MK2 and MK3 is fully integrated, the French will play their usual game of not sharing enough of what we want to make it happen. Cost quoted will be high during negotiations. Once MK2 and MK3 is integrated successfully, they will be behind us with the cheapest offers to integrate Meteor to Tejas and buy more at reasonable rates. Business.
Any idea why it has not been inducted? Delayed deliveries?Prem Kumar wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 00:08 Astra-1 is the longest range AAM with the IAF today. Let that sink in!
Meteor hasn't been inducted, R-77 is relatively short-ranged and R-37 induction (if any) is miniscule
Only the people directly involved will know what the issue was. Could be a datalink issue, since the radar has to pass target related and then guidance related data to the missile and then the missile needs to be able to pass it's position and status data back to the aircraft. The good thing is that this is being managed here in India since Astra Mk1 is our missile. If this was a foreign missile, this software change would take a lot longer.uddu wrote: ↑17 Sep 2025 19:43is the issue with mid course guidance? Any experts in here could shed more light on the issue from the details available?
https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-ne ... 31857.html
“The missile integration with the aircraft is complete. The aerodynamic studies, the signalling to the missile... all that is done. The safety review board has to clear the missile software changes made by the Hyderabad-based Defence Research and Development Laboratory. After Astra is fired, everybody will be happy,” he said.
Ok. Provide the authoritative source for this.Prem Kumar wrote: ↑18 Sep 2025 00:08 Astra-1 is the longest range AAM with the IAF today. Let that sink in!
Meteor hasn't been inducted, R-77 is relatively short-ranged and R-37 induction (if any) is miniscule
Which is why the anemic order for Astra-1 by the IAF is grating! So is the sloth of HAL to get the Astra-1 certification for Tejas-Mk1a - WTF were they doing all these years, making tall promises month after month?!
P.S: I also think that the IAF wanting to induct missiles > 200 Km range is to keep importing Rampage, Scalp, Crystal Maze, R-37, Meteor & S-400
Astra-1, Astra-2, Akash-NG are in the sub-200 Km range, So is SAAW, the G-series bombs and HSLD-Mk1. And in order to hoodwink the masses, they renamed Rampage as HSLD-Mk2
Seems like even Astra-2 is dead-on-arrival, though we have nothing better than even Astra-1 today! Astra-2, after all the trials, will get the same paltry order of 200 - 400 missiles
Only the Rudram-2 and 3, Gandhiva & Kusha will be in the > 200 Km bracket. All of them are several years away from induction, with the exception of Rudram-2. Till then, imports-galore! Then move the goalpost to > 300 Km or ask for hypersonic interception
I don't think he ever mentioned that Astra Mk2 isn't coming. In fact Vishnu is too eager and goes on to talk about how the middle pylon can carry the Astra Mk1 and then the Astra Mk2 and the HAL CMD nods.uddu wrote: ↑20 Sep 2025 09:44Integrating every missile in inventory is excellent. But it must not be at the cost of delaying Astra MK2 and Mk3 for import substitute. Priority and first integration should be Astra MK2 and Mk3 followed by Meteor. Since he is mentioning it to be on the second batch of 97, there is ample time to get everything done. Also until MK2 and MK3 is fully integrated, the French will play their usual game of not sharing enough of what we want to make it happen. Cost quoted will be high during negotiations. Once MK2 and MK3 is integrated successfully, they will be behind us with the cheapest offers to integrate Meteor to Tejas and buy more at reasonable rates. Business.